The Poor Creature cafe sits empty at Yukonstruct in Whitehorse on Oct. 17, after the owner took a day off to deal with the news that their lease will not be renewed at the end of the month. (Crystal Schick/Yukon News)

Yukonstruct cafe owner says decision to not renew lease came “out of the blue”

The Poor Creature’s lease ends on Oct. 31. Owner Brioni Connolly said she was expecting a renewal

A Whitehorse vegan cafe owner says she feels blindsided by Yukonstruct’s decision to not renew her lease.

Brioni Connolly has operated The Poor Creature out of Yukonstruct’s building in downtown Whitehorse since November 2018.

Although she signed a one-year lease with an end-date of Oct. 31, 2019, Connolly told the News that she was under the impression that it would be renewed, based on informal conversations she’d had with various staffers about future plans for the cafe.

However, on Oct. 11, Connolly received a letter from Yukonstruct stating that her lease would not be renewed.

“We always had a great relationship and I always held Yukonstruct in high regard up until I was handed that letter on Friday,” she said in an interview Oct. 17. “This came literally out of the blue.”

Connolly said that, to date, Yukonstruct has not provided her reasons as to why it’s choosing to not renew her lease. It has, she said, offered to give her an extension on how soon she must leave the space, but communication has otherwise been limited.

In an emailed statement, Yukonstruct executive director Lana Selbee wrote that the organization understood that “some people have questions about why Yukonstruct decided to not negotiate a new commercial lease agreement with The Poor Creature.”

“We are committed to protecting the privacy of all of our tenants,” the email says. “We hope that people will respect this position and recognize that this is a private and confidential matter that we are not willing to discuss publicly.

“Yukonstruct wants to clarify that The Poor Creature’s lease was not terminated. Their one year lease came to an end and, with a lot of consideration, our board of directors made the difficult decision not to negotiate a new lease. The Poor Creature knows that we are open to extending their time, in order to facilitate their transition.

“We are dedicated to continue to offer a positive and inclusive space and to continue the good work we’ve done in the community over the past 6 years.”

Selbee was not available for a phone interview and also declined via email to answer follow-up questions from the News, adding only that Yukonstruct “has been in communication” with Connolly and “will continue the dialogue with our tenant in private.”

Connolly said she plans on fighting the non-renewal of her lease.

She’s received immense support since she began writing about the situation on The Poor Creature’s Facebook page after receiving the letter Oct. 11, something she said she believes to show that Yukonstruct members weren’t consulted on whether they wanted the cafe to remain in the space.

“I mean, they consulted recently if the membership wanted a bike rack, they consulted on, does the membership want to buy more spoons for the kitchen? But when it came to this and my livelihood and this cafe space that was quite treasured by the Yukonstruct community, they didn’t consult with the membership,” she said.

“I’m finding that really bizarre and I’m not the only one who finds that very strange, so for that reason alone, I feel like it’s important to fight for it.”

Contact Jackie Hong at jackie.hong@yukon-news.com

Small BusinessYukon

Get local stories you won't find anywhere else right to your inbox.
Sign up here

Just Posted

Many continue to opt for take-out as dining rooms reopen

City considers options for more patio space

Yukon government suspends phone program for vulnerable women after data overage issues

The Yukon government suspended service without warning last month to cell phones… Continue reading

Campgrounds reopening June 4

Yukoners are asked to stick to their “double-bubble” households, respect social distancing… Continue reading

Yukon government has valid claim in Wolverine mine bankruptcy, judge rules

“This application arises because of an irresponsible mining venture in the Yukon”

City tickets 50 on day one of return to parking meter enforcement

A total of 50 parking tickets were issued June 1 by the… Continue reading

Driver charged in 2019 Whitehorse pedestrian death

A driver has been charged in relation to the 2019 death of… Continue reading

Council holds off on designation decision for portion of the tank farm

Decision comes in light of notice of violation to project proponent

UPDATED: Yukon government clarifies businesses available to travellers

Travellers can stop anywhere along the approved route in one of the marked communities

City hall, briefly

A look at decisions made by Whitehorse city council this week. June… Continue reading

Pilot Station salmon sonar to go ahead this season

The Pilot Station sonar, located near the mouth of the Yukon River… Continue reading

Renovations start at LePage Park

The Yukon Historical and Museums Association has started a resurfacing project for… Continue reading

Most Read