Justice system slowly adapting to FASD realities

A Carmacks man was found not guilty of assault last month because he was exposed to alcohol in the womb, signalling a growing awareness by adjudicators that FASD sufferers require alternatives to the criminal court system.

A Carmacks man was found not guilty of assault last month because he was exposed to alcohol in the womb, signalling a growing awareness by adjudicators that FASD sufferers require alternatives to the criminal court system.

Robin Sam left his uncle’s house on December 20, 2009, only to return a few hours later. In a violent episode he did not recall in court, he beat his uncle, leaving the man bruised, bloodied and suffering from a fractured eye socket.

Sam was arrested the next day. He suffers from “significant cognitive limitations,” and has a lengthy history with mental health providers. Though he was never diagnosed with Fetal Alcohol Spectrum Disorder, “community reports suggest a likelihood of prenatal exposure to alcohol,” say court documents.

Sam pleaded guilty to the aggravated assault charge. But Territorial Court Judge Karen Ruddy was not convinced Sam understood criminal responsibility by way of a mental disorder.

“There’s a burgeoning awareness in the criminal justice system that current approaches and historical approaches to probation orders and justice may not work for individuals with FASD,” said Brooke Alsbury, the executive director of the Fetal Alcohol Syndrome Society of Yukon.

While this is not the first case where criminal responsibility was found lacking due to neonatal alcohol exposure, it was probably buoyed by the recent push by the Canadian Bar Association to bring FASD on the national justice agenda, said Alsbury.

At its annual meeting in August, the bar association, which represents lawyers, judges and justice workers across the country, passed a resolution declaring the need for the justice system to accommodate FASD sufferers.

FASD impairs judgment, makes it difficult to control impulsive behaviour and reduces a person’s ability to understand the consequences of their actions, says the resolution. On the other hand, the justice system functions on the assumption a person acts in a voluntary manner and makes informed choices, it says.

Sentencing options are ineffective in changing the behaviour of people with FASD, it continues.

As well, the Charter of Rights and Freedoms guarantees “substantive and not merely formal quality before and under the criminal law without discrimination on the basis of their disability,” the resolution says.

With that in mind, the association calls for all governments to spend time and money looking at alternatives for people with FASD in the justice system and to amend current sentencing laws.

Despite a growing consensus, the solution to FASD sufferers in the court system is far from clear.

FASD is a spectrum disorder, meaning every case will be different, said Alsbury.

But research is offering some promising leads.

“What we do know is that support and structure in the community can be incredibly helpful,” she said. “When we look at alternatives to the justice system, we need to examine the ways in which we can build support and work collaboratively with the community.”

“The either/or situation – either no support in the community or putting people in jail – isn’t a good way to go about it,” she said.

Housing is a fundamental piece of the puzzle, she added.

Sam’s situation shows that at the individual case level, an awareness of FASD is having an effect.

Ruddy relied on the testimony of Dr. Shabehram Lohrasbe, who wrote two court-ordered psychiatric assessments on Sam, and psychologist Bill Stewart, who has counselled and provided support services for Sam in Carmacks, in her decision.

But here, at the systemic level, change hasn’t happened yet, said Alsbury.

“That’s why the Canadian Bar Association’s recent announcement is pretty critical,” she said.

“It’s starting to recognize, at that level, that we can have some common language and roll out some new systems on that understanding,” she said.

Contact James Munson at

jamesm@yukon-news.com

Just Posted

Short-tailed grouse are the singing, dancing lotharios of the avian world

It’s Dirty Dancing for birds, with every male trying to be Patrick Swayze

Yukon government puts $530k towards Gladue report pilot project

Three-year pilot project will train people to write Gladue reports for Indigenous offenders

Greyhound cleared to end routes in Yukon, northern B.C.

Company says ridership on nine routes has dropped 30 per cent in last five years

Yukon Quest wraps up with awards banquet

Commando and Dutch win Golden Harness Award, juicy steaks

No Resource Gateway construction work this season, YG says

‘We’re not as advanced as we would have liked to have been but we still are advancing’

YG seeks to ease neighbourhood concerns over housing first project

YG will consult more once design for downtown building is complete

Cold weather hampers Babe Southwick Memorial Race

‘It was nice to see people out there because we didn’t expect as many volunteers to show up’

Former Whitehorse RCMP officer gets conditional discharge for sexual assault

Judge Richard Scheider sided with the defence’s argument that conditional discharge was appropriate

Tagish dog rescue owner asks court to change dog surrender order

Shelley Cuthbert is asking for changes to an order requiring her to surrender 10 dogs per month

Dangerous offender hearing underway for former Yukon man who sexually abused 13 girls

The man pleaded guilty to sexually abusing 13 girls over seven years in the Yukon, B.C. and Ontario

Team Yukon has strong showing at Whistler Super Youth and Timber Tour

‘Anwyn absolutely destroyed the competition’

Yukon skier turns in personal best at Junior World Championships

‘It was another great international racing experience’

Most Read