Convicted killer to get new trial

The B.C. and Yukon Court of Appeal has ordered a new trial for a woman convicted of murder in 2009.

The B.C. and Yukon Court of Appeal has ordered a new trial for a woman convicted of murder in 2009.

In October 2009, a jury found Alicia Ann Murphy guilty of the second-degree murder of Evangeline Billy, who drowned in the Yukon River in Whitehorse in 2008.

Murphy’s case rested heavily on the testimony of two women, her sister Tanya and Rae Lynne Gartner. Both women testified Murphy told them she killed Billy and tried to stage is as a sexual assault.

Murphy denied she killed Billy and said she never confessed.

She insists that during the two-hour window when investigators claim the murder happened she was with a drug dealer and then later at home.

The alibi came late in the trial. The drug dealer had died and police were not able to investigate.

During the trial, prosecutors called police officers to testify to their impressions of the witnesses’ statements, the lead investigator’s methodology and his working theories around the crime scene and cause of death.

While arguing the appeal, prosecutors insisted that this testimony was just part of the “narrative” of the story. But the appeals judges disagreed. They said the testimony had no probative value.

“Had the defence raised police misconduct, such as bullying or other oppressive conduct, then the interaction of the witnesses with the police would have had some relevance; but in any event it could not have been used to bolster the Crown’s case, only to answer some point taken by the defence,” the decision says.

“No such allegation arose. What the witnesses said to the police, their demeanour, emotional condition and cooperativeness, should have had nothing to do with their testimony at trial, yet it was used to make the evidence more reliable.”

Oath-helping – calling evidence during a trial with no other purpose than to bolstering a witness’s credibility – is not allowed in Canadian law.

The two women who claimed that Murphy confessed were so central to the case that this mistake cannot be ignored, the court said.

“Since there was no other overwhelming evidence of guilt, it cannot be said the verdict would necessarily have been the same despite the error.”

That same method by prosecutors, to tell a “narrative,” led to other mistakes, the appeal court said.

The lead investigator testified as to how he and his team followed proper procedures throughout the investigation.

He talked about his working theories on the crime scene and cause of death.

That included the opinion that the state and position of clothing on the victim’s body shows that a sexual assault had been staged, the court said. But opinion evidence should not have been allowed.

“The prejudice to the appellant lay in the opinion of a staged sexual assault, for the Crown argued that was something only the perpetrator and the police would have known and hence the value of the appellant’s admission was enhanced,” the court said.

No date has been set for when Murphy will next appear in court.

Contact Ashley Joannou at

ashleyj@yukon-news.com

Get local stories you won't find anywhere else right to your inbox.
Sign up here

Just Posted

Wyatt's World for Oct. 28, 2020.
WYATT’S WORLD

Wyatt’s World for Oct. 28.… Continue reading

Yukon Child Care Board chair Amy Ryder says the board could be playing a bigger role in childcare policy making if they had more financial support from the Yukon government. (Submitted)
Yukon Child Care Board asks for larger role in annual report

The board is asking for a larger budget to increase outreach and advice

Yukon’s clocks will no longer change in March and November but will remain permanently on Pacific Daylight Saving Time. (Courtesy Yukon government)
Off the clock: Yukon prepares to end seasonal time changes

Starting on Nov. 1 Yukon will be one hour ahead of Vancouver and two hours ahead of Alaska

Dawson City as scene from West Dawson. Art Webster, the vice-chair of the Dawson Regional Planning Commission resigned last month over the Yukon governments unwillingness to pause speculative staking. (Joel Krahn/Yukon News file)
Vice-chair resigns from Dawson land-use planning commission

NDP warns that not pausing mining activity is the road to a second Peel decision

The opening ceremonies of the Canada Summer Games in Winnipeg on July 28, 2017. The 2021 Canada Summer Games have officially been rescheduled for Aug. 6 to 21, 2022, exactly one year from the date the national competition was originally set to take place in the Niagara region of Ontario. (Canada Summer Games/Flickr)
Canada Summer Games dates set for 2022 but uncertainty remains for Yukon athletes

Yukon athletes continue waiting to get back into schools

A proposed Official Community Plan amendment would designate a 56.3 hectare piece of land in Whistle Bend currently designated as green space, as urban residential use. Whitehorse city council passed first reading on a bylaw for the designation change at its Oct. 26 meeting, prompting an upcoming public hearing on Nov. 23 ahead of second reading on Dec. 7. (Courtesy City of Whitehorse)
Local contractors will be given an advantage on a contract for the design and construction services that will see a new reception building at Robert Service Campground decided city councillors during the Oct. 26 council meeting. (Crystal Schick/Yukon News file)
Local firms will get advantage on contract for new Robert Service Campground building

Yukon-based companies competing for contract for new reception building will receive 20 extra points

Fallen trees due to strong winds are seen leaning on to power lines which caused some power outages around the territory on Oct. 26. (Courtesy of ATCO)
Wind knocks out power around the Yukon

High winds on Oct. 26 knocked out power to Faro, parts of Whitehorse and beyond

The Yukon government is asking for all claims in a lawsuit over the Takhini elk herd be struck by the court. (Mike Thomas/Yukon News file)
Yukon government asks for Takhini elk lawsuit to be struck

The Yukon government is asking for all claims in a lawsuit over… Continue reading

The Yukon government has filed a reply to an outfitter’s petition challenging the reduction of its caribou quota to zero. (Yukon News file)
YG replies to outfitter’s legal challenge over caribou quota

The Yukon government has filed a reply to an outfitter’s petition challenging… Continue reading

The Yukon government is encouraging people to get the flu vaccine this year, saying that with COVID-19, it’s “more important than ever.” (Black Press file)
Get flu vaccine, Yukon government urges

The Yukon government is encouraging people to get the flu vaccine this… Continue reading

Benjamin Munn, 12, watches the HPV vaccine in 2013. Beginning Jan. 1, 2021, the Human Papillomavirus (HPV) vaccine will be available to all Yukoners up to, and including, age 26. Currently the program is only available to girls ages nine to 18 and boys ages nine to 14. (Dan Bates/Black Press file)
HPV vaccine will be available to Yukoners up to, including, age 26

Beginning Jan. 1, 2021, the Human Papillomavirus (HPV) vaccine will be available… Continue reading

Whitehorse City Hall. (Joel Krahn/Yukon News file)
City hall, briefly

A look at decisions made by Whitehorse city council this week

Most Read