An icy fall lands in court

Does the city of Whitehorse have a responsibility to stop citizens from slipping on the ice? Yes — but only if they’re walking on a…

Does the city of Whitehorse have a responsibility to stop citizens from slipping on the ice?

Yes — but only if they’re walking on a sidewalk.

And what if it’s a sidewalk crossing over a laneway?

That’s the question being asked in a landmark eight-year-old slip-and-fall case currently before the Yukon Supreme Court.

In February of 2000, Barbara Schan was walking along the west side of Second Avenue. Crossing an alley adjacent to the TD Bank, she slipped on a patch of ice and fell to the ground, seriously injuring her ankle.

If she had slipped just a few feet further, she could have sued TD Bank for failing to maintain the sidewalk in front of its business.

However, given that it was an alleyway, she had essentially fallen in a no-man’s-land of sidewalk snow clearance.

In 2000, municipal bylaw held that sidewalk areas needed to be cleared by the owners of the property that the sidewalk fronted. However, the law made no provision for sidewalks that crossed over alleys or laneways.

“This happened on a sidewalk that crossed over a laneway, it didn’t front on anybody’s property so nobody was cleaning it,” said Jim Tucker, Schan’s lawyer.

Only a matter of months after Schan’s fall, the city changed its bylaw, ruling that property owners adjacent to laneways were now required to clear away snow that had gathered in sidewalks crossing those laneways.

“They’ve basically shifted the burden onto the property owners,” said Tucker.

The bylaw change also freed the municipality from any further lawsuits.

“It’s conceivable that (someone will slip) again, but it won’t happen like this again,” said Tucker.

Schan can still seek damages from the city for her fall, but her case weighs heavily upon the definition of what exactly she slipped on.

Since Schan slipped on a sidewalk crossing a laneway, it could either be considered a highway or a sidewalk.

“If it’s a highway we have to prove gross negligence … a high bar to get over,” said Tucker.

“If it’s a sidewalk, and that’s what the judge is going to determine, then I’d say we don’t have to prove gross negligence,” he said.

The city has defended itself by saying, “the plaintiff knew or ought to have known of slippery conditions and failed to take any appropriate steps, to ensure her own safety.”

An ice-related slip-and-fall case is not unprecedented in Canadian history, but it is extremely rare.

In 1897 a Queen’s medical student argued a similar case against the city of Kingston after injuring her hip, causing her to be “laid up in the hospital for 24 weeks.”

The case was dismissed.

Since the Schan case is exceptional, it is not opening the door towards a whole series of other ice-slipping lawsuits directed at the city, said Tucker.

“You cannot have the municipality getting sued every time someone falls down,” he said.

“Ice and snow, it’s a part of our lives — and it’s slippery stuff.”

Get local stories you won't find anywhere else right to your inbox.
Sign up here

Just Posted

Chief Medical Officer of Health Dr. Brendan Hanley announced two new cases of COVID-19 on May 11. (Crystal Schick/Yukon News file)
Two new cases of COVID-19 reported, one in the Yukon and one Outside

One person is self-isolating, the other will remain Outside until non-infectious

Courtesy/Yukon Protective Services Yukon Wildland Fire Management crews doing a prescribed burn at the Carcross Cut-Off in May 2020.
Prescribed burns planned near Whitehorse neighbourhoods to improve wildfire resistance

Manual fuel removal and the replacement of conifers with aspens is also ongoing.

Chloe Tatsumi dismounts the balance beam to cap her routine during the Yukon Championships at the Polarettes Gymnastics Club on May 1. (John Tonin/Yukon News)
Gymnasts vie in 2021 Yukon Championships

In a year without competition because of COVID-19, the Polarettes Gymnastics Club hosted its Yukon Championships.

Yukonomist Keith Halliday
Yukonomist: Yukon Budget 2.0

If the banks that finance the Yukon’s growing debt were the only… Continue reading

The deceased man, found in Lake LaBerge in 2016, had on three layers of clothing, Dakato work boots, and had a sheathed knife on his belt. Photo courtesy Yukon RCMP
RCMP, Coroner’s Office seek public assistance in identifying a deceased man

The Yukon RCMP Historical Case Unit and the Yukon Coroner’s Office are looking for public help to identify a man who was found dead in Lake LaBerge in May 2016.

Yukon Zinc’s Wolverine minesite has created a mess left to taxpayers to clean up, Lewis Rifkind argues. This file shot shows the mine in 2009. (John Thompson/Yukon News file)
Editorial: The cost of the Wolverine minesite

Lewis Rifkind Special to the News The price of a decent wolverine… Continue reading

Letters to the editor.
Today’s mailbox: border opening and Yukon Party texts

Dear Premier Sandy Silver and Dr Hanley, Once again I’m disheartened and… Continue reading

Fire chief Jason Everett (Crystal Schick/Yukon News file)
City launches emergency alert system

The city is calling on residents and visitors to register for Whitehorse Alert

Two young orienteers reach their first checkpoint near Shipyards Park during a Yukon Orienteering Association sprint race May 5. (John Tonin/Yukon News)
Orienteers were back in action for the season’s first race

The Yukon Orienteering Association began its 2021 season with a sprint race beginning at Shipyards.

Whitehorse City Hall (Yukon News file)
City news, briefly

A look at issues discussed by Whitehorse city council at its May 3 meeting and the upcoming 20-minute makeover.

Deputy Prime Minister Chrystia Freeland met with MP Larry Bagnell and representatives from the Tourism Industry Association via Zoom on May 4. (Facebook)
Deputy Prime Minister Chrystia Freeland met with MP Larry Bagnell and representatives from the Tourism Industry Association via Zoom on May 4. (Facebook)
Deputy Prime Minister talks tourism in “virtual visit” to the Yukon

Tourism operators discussed the budget with Freeland

Polarity Brewing is giving people extra incentive to get their COVID vaccine by offering a ‘free beer’ within 24 hours of their first shot. John Tonin/Yukon News
Polarity Brewing giving out ‘free’ beer with first COVID vaccination

Within 24 hours of receiving your first COVID-19 vaccine, Polarity Brewing will give you a beer.

Most Read