A little land dispute raises big questions about final agreements

A legal battle between a farmer and a trapper in Yukon Supreme Court this week could change the way First Nations’ final agreements are viewed.

A legal battle between a farmer and a trapper in Yukon Supreme Court this week could change the way First Nations’ final agreements are viewed.

Are they a step towards reconciling Canada’s shoddy history of treating its aboriginal citizens?

Or are the final agreements all-inclusive documents that lay out all the responsibilities the Crown owes First Nations under certain circumstances?

A dispute over the fate of a 65-hectare chunk of land in Little Salmon/Carmacks First Nation’s traditional territory lies at the heart of the case.

The First Nation is challenging a Yukon government decision to issue land to Larry Paulsen, who wants to grow hay, raise livestock and spot-harvest timber.

The area, located about 40 kilometres north of Carmacks, is near the First Nation’s settlement lands.

It also overlaps trapline No. 143, owned by Little Salmon/Carmacks elder Johnny Sam since 1957.

After being approved by the Land Application Review Committee, the Yukon government accepted Paulsen’s application for the land in 2004.

But the First Nation asserts it was not properly consulted before the government approved the application.

And the decision could have adverse effects on the elder’s trapline, the surrounding environment and wildlife values, and the First Nation as a whole, Justice Ron Veale heard this week.

The government had a duty to consult and, if appropriate, “accommodate” the First Nation in considering Paulsen’s application, aboriginal rights lawyer Arthur Pape argued in his submission on Wednesday.

That is the case, even though the duty is not specifically included in the First Nation’s final agreement, he said.

Pape, a high-profile Vancouver-based lawyer, came to Whitehorse to represent Little Salmon/Carmacks.

The treaty is not the end of the process; it’s a step in the government’s reconciliation with First Nations, Pape told the court.

“You can’t make the argument that this was not covered in the land claim because things come up that we don’t anticipate.”

The government had no duty to consult, Crown lawyer Penelope Gawn argued on Thursday.

The rights laid out in the final agreement replaced any duty the government had to consult or accommodate, she told the court.

If the government had a duty to consult the First Nation in circumstances like this, it would have been outlined in the final agreement, which Gawn described as a “comprehensive document.”

The Little Salmon/Carmack’s final agreement includes the word “consult” or “consultation” more than 60 times, argued Gawn.

In its land claim, the First Nation also had the option to choose the land in question as a special-management area and it did not, said Gawn.

It is “vitally important” that the treaty not be “undermined” by additions after the fact, she said.

However, the argument was not meant to imply that all of the final agreements were set in stone and must be rigidly followed forever, said Gawn after questioning from Veale.

The First Nation was alerted to Paulsen’s application through the Yukon’s Land Application Review Committee process.

It replied with a letter listing concerns about the application, but did not attend, or ask for a postponement of the meeting discussing the application, which took place in August 2004, argued Gawn.

Paulsen’s application was approved following that meeting.

But because the First Nation was considered a member of the land application review committee, it could not be granted intervener status to appeal the decision, Gawn told the court.

The land application review process was established by government to serve its own interests, said Pape.

The First Nation was “out of luck,” he said.

“That’s pretty astonishing, and that’s why we’re here,” he told the court.

Pape cited case law from recent Supreme Court decisions involving the government’s duty to consult and to accommodate the concerns of aboriginal peoples.

He heavily cited from the Mikisew Cree decision of 2005, which arose from a proposal to run a winter road through areas many local First Nations families used for hunting and trapping.

In that case, the Supreme Court ruled governments have the power to infringe on historic treaty rights, but also have the duty to consult First Nations if they’ll be adversely affected by those decisions.

Pape argued the circumstances in the Mikisew Cree decision were comparable to those of the Little Salmon/Carmacks case.

Gawn countered this case is “novel” because the Little Salmon/Carmacks dispute involves a “modern” land claim, which is a more sophisticated treaty than the Mikisew Cree was functioning under.

Lawyers for both sides agreed that modern land-claim agreements are negotiated on a much more level playing field than their historic counterparts.

Meanwhile, Paulsen’s lawyer, Christina Sutherland, argued her client was an “innocent third party” in the dispute.

He’s put more than $25,000 into the property, plus the time and money tied up in the legal proceeding, she told the court.

He wants the land and has been waiting and will be waiting for a long time, she said.

The hearing is scheduled to finish on Friday.

The land has not been transferred, nor will be transferred until the court makes a judgment on the case.

Get local stories you won't find anywhere else right to your inbox.
Sign up here

Just Posted

Wyatt’s World

Wyatt’s World for March 5, 2021.

Yukonomist: School competition ramps up in the Yukon

It’s common to see an upstart automaker trying to grab share from… Continue reading

The Yukon government responded to a petition calling the SCAN Act “draconian” on Feb. 19. (Yukon News file)
Yukon government accuses SCAN petitioner of mischaracterizing her eviction

A response to the Jan. 7 petition was filed to court on Feb. 19

City councillor Samson Hartland in Whitehorse on Dec. 3, 2018. Hartland has announced his plans to run for mayor in the Oct. 21 municipal election. (Crystal Schick/Yukon News file)
Councillor sets sights on mayor’s chair

Hartland declares election plans

Whitehorse RCMP will provide internet safety training due to an uptick of child luring offences. (iStock photo)
RCMP hosting internet safety webinars for parents and caregivers

The webinars will take place on March 23 and 25

Chief Medical Officer of Health Dr. Brendan Hanley receives his first dose of the COVID-19 vaccine from Public Health Nurse Angie Bartelen at the Yukon Convention Centre Clinic in Whitehorse on March 3. (Crystal Schick/Yukon News)
State of emergency extended for another 90 days

“Now we’re in a situation where we see the finish line.”

The Yukon government says it is working towards finding a solution for Dawson area miners who may be impacted by City of Dawson plans and regulations. (Joel Krahn/Yukon News file)
Miner expresses frustration over town plan

Designation of claims changed to future planning

Team Yukon athletes wave flags at the 2012 Arctic Winter Games opening ceremony in Whitehorse. The 2022 event in Wood Buffalo, Alta., has been postponed indefinitely. (Justin Kennedy/Yukon News file)
2022 Arctic Winter Games postponed indefinitely

Wood Buffalo, Alta., Host Society committed to rescheduling at a later date

Crews work to clear the South Klondike Highway after an avalanche earlier this week. (Submitted)
South Klondike Highway remains closed due to avalanches

Yukon Avalanche Association recommending backcountry recreators remain vigilant

RCMP Online Crime Reporting website in Whitehorse on March 5. (Haley Ritchie/Yukon News)
Whitehorse RCMP launch online crime reporting

Both a website and Whitehorse RCMP app are now available

A man walks passed the polling place sign at city hall in Whitehorse on Oct. 18, 2018. The City of Whitehorse is preparing for a pandemic-era election this October with a number of measures proposed to address COVID-19 restrictions. (Crystal Schick/Yukon News file)
City gets set for Oct. 21 municipal election

Elections procedures bylaw comes forward

A rendering of the Normandy Manor seniors housing facility. (Photo courtesy KBC Developments)
Work on seniors housing project moves forward

Funding announced for Normandy Manor

Tom Ullyett, pictured, is the first Yukoner to receive the Louis St-Laurent Award of Excellence from the Canadian Bar Association for his work as a community builder and mentor in the territory. (Gabrielle Plonka/Yukon News)
Tom Ullyett wins lifetime achievement award from the Canadian Bar Association

Ullyett has worked in the Yukon’s justice ecosystem for 36 years as a public sector lawyer and mentor

Most Read