A responsibility to protect, sometimes

Homa Arjomand, of the International Campaign Against Shariah Court in Canada, reports anti-Gadhafi forces in Libya are raping women to punish their husbands for serving under the Gadhafi regime.

Homa Arjomand, of the International Campaign Against Shariah Court in Canada, reports anti-Gadhafi forces in Libya are raping women to punish their husbands for serving under the Gadhafi regime.

“According to Shariah law,” says Arjomand, “enemies’ wives should be raped and they have started raping these women already.”

The currently recognized leader of the interim government, former Gadhafi justice minister Mustafa Jalil, has promised Libyan Shariah will be “moderate,” though he went on to announce a repeal of Gadhafi’s westernized marriage and divorce laws, which included a prohibition on polygamy. Even in moderate Islamic states, polygamy makes chattel of women. In less moderate ones, a woman may be stoned to death for the crime of having been raped.

Canada was in the forefront of the military action against Gadhafi’s forces in Libya, a leader among 17 nations who waged an air war that killed an estimated 10,000 people and handed the country over into unknown hands. We took this action in the spirit of Responsibility to Protect, or R2P, the doctrine that says we the powerful liberal (ahem) democracies of the world have a duty to prevent mad dictators from slaughtering civilians. We do offer a 40-year period of grace on that one, of course, especially if the dictator in question agrees to keep the oil flowing, and handle a few of our more delicate interrogations for us on the side.

Those who find themselves under the protection of R2P, should they survive, often wake up to the realization that there is a time limit on the program. In the case of Libyan civilians, that moment would appear to have arrived when Gadhafi died. Dictator murdered, protection delivered, mission accomplished, hands washed: goodbye, Libya.

The problem with doctrines like R2P is that no matter how noble the sentiment, they are far more likely to reflect national interests than international responsibility. That’s why millions of civilians are brutalized, raped, murdered or driven into exile every year without a great deal of interference from powerful liberal democracies. We turn a blind eye to atrocities all the time, how do we pick our Libyas? Who gets defence agreements, and who gets bombs?

In Libya’s case, to judge by the players, there appears to have been not so much a conspiracy as a confluence of interests. Mustafa Jalil was known as a moderate in Gadhafi’s Libya, who as justice minister spoke out against human rights abuses by security forces. How he survived so long in his post is as yet unexplained, but he is among a number of members of the transitional council who appear to have at least a passing interest in human rights.

If things don’t work out for acting prime minister Ali Tarhouni in Libya, he’s kept a fall-back position. A Libyan-born American, he still has his job on the faculty of the University of Washington Michael G. Foster School of Business. Tarhouni inherited the prime minister’s job from his friend Mahmoud Jibril, who formerly taught strategic planning at the University of Pittsburgh, and who has been at the forefront of efforts to liberalize trade in North Africa.

The teaming up of right-leaning hyphenated Americans with human rights advocates and powerful, but disaffected members of the old regime recalls the so-called colour revolutions, where local discontent coincided with US funding and organizational help to unseat governments, which opposed “liberalized trade.” Another striking similarity is that Gadhafi had become more and more of a stone in the shoe of liberalized trade, which he was not alone in identifying as Western economic imperialism in a thin disguise.

In a speech to the United Nations General Assembly in 2009, Gadhafi called for the African Union to have a permanent seat on the Security Council. Though hardly a radical move in itself, it was indicative of the dictator’s Pan-Africanism. However mad he might have been, Gadhafi had the oil money to influence African affairs, and he made use of it. He was a driving force behind the African Investment Bank, and the African Monetary Fund, both of them inimical to globalist interests.

In its ideal form, Responsibility to Protect is hard to argue against. If we are strong enough to stop Pharaoh’s army, how can we refuse? Too often the world has stood by and let innocents be slaughtered, not for want of the might to stop it, but for lack of political will. In practise, R2P turns out to be typical of high-sounding doctrines in a colonial world – a tool of colonialism.

Next time you hear that your government is going to war to protect somebody, think long and hard before you believe it. It might be true, and it might not. Consider the women being raped by our allies in Libya tonight. Who’s protecting them?

Al Pope won the Ma Murray Award for Best Columnist in BC/Yukon in 2010 and 2002. His novel, Bad Latitudes, is available in bookstores.

Just Posted

UPDATED: Whitehorse Transit cancels some runs as union works to rule

City, YEU locked in dispute over severance pay, long-service bonuses

Unsolved murders team will take pressure off Major Crimes Unit, Yukon RCMP superintendent says

Supt. Brian Jones says Major Crimes Unit workload from last year wasn’t sustainable

Yukon housing minister promises announcement ‘in the coming days and weeks’

Opposition presses for details as social housing wait list balloons

Transit workers serve City of Whitehorse strike notice

Residents advised to make alternate travel arrangements starting March 19

Cleanup work set to start at former site of Whitehorse oil refinery

Crews will use thermal technology to remediate sludge pit that dates back to 1940s

Whitehorse city council approves Porter Creek group home

Concerns about crime, noise and consultation overblown, councillors say

I’m Fur Real offers platform for artisans to sell their work

‘There’s nothing better than buying something from the person who made it’

Perfect snow and weather conditions for Yukon Championships

‘These next few days, we will be in our glory’

Yukon Rivermen finish regular season at home

‘Having five teams visit us and 15 home games was incredible’

The huge cost of distracted driving

Distracted driving is a very serious issue affecting road safety across the country

Fiscal policy continuity in 2018 Yukon budget

Get ready for a big wave of debt

Yukon’s Eagle mine secures funding to get it to production

Utility board signs off on mine’s power purchase agreement

Parties spar over the size of French high school planned for Whitehorse

New school to have room for 150 students, earlier report called for space for 200

Most Read