Make the social net more equitable

Having money does not make somebody smart. It makes them wealthy. Similarly, not having money does not make someone stupid.

Having money does not make somebody smart.

It makes them wealthy.

Similarly, not having money does not make someone stupid.

But society rarely credits our impoverished citizens with intelligence.

It views them with suspicion. And well-paid agents tell clients precisely what they must do with the social assistance the government doles out.

The help comes with strings attached because the state assumes it knows what people need to have better lives.

But, as we know, our governments sometimes have a hard time planning a subdivision.

So, let’s go to crazy town for a minute.

Why not simply give the poor a wage, with no strings attached? Cut the red tape, the case workers and the thousands of rules and simply pay them a guaranteed income.

Nuts, right?

Not really.

Under the current social service regime, the wage gap is growing and poverty is not going away.

Six in 10 Canadians would be in financial trouble if their paycheque were delayed a week, according to a poll conducted last year by the Canadian Payroll Association.

One in 10 Canadians lives below the poverty line. And, despite our wealth, our record on child poverty is at best one of neglect. If you factor in aboriginal communities, it is abysmal.

Every month, 770,000 Canadians use food banks, and almost half of those relying on them are children.

This suggests the current system isn’t working all that well.

So, perhaps it’s time to try something different. Something radical.

Something simple.

Get rid of social assistance. And EI. And Old Age Security, supplementary pensions, student grants, housing subsidies, child tax benefits and the myriad programs that service the nation’s poor.

Instead, guarantee everyone a minimum annual income – somewhere between $12,000 and $20,000, or whatever society decides would provide folks with an acceptable life.

And then, let them live it.

Any money a Canadian citizen earns above the grant would be theirs to keep.

Such a program would remove the stigma of being a recipient. People would be better off working, because any money they earned above the guaranteed income would be theirs, though taxed at normal levels.

And, at a tax rate of 50 per cent, middle-income Canadians would be forced to pay the state back half the grant in taxes anyway.

Fraud would be eliminated, because everyone would get it. And you couldn’t get a more efficient delivery.

The Fraser Institute, in a paper suggesting such a plan, estimates it would cost about the same as the existing social net. But some of the cost would be recovered through taxes on those who were better off.

There is plenty of evidence that, if such a system were in place, people would manage their money better than the bureaucrats we currently task with strong-arming them into better lives.

In developing nations, where such programs are becoming common, the effect has been to greatly reduce childhood poverty and improve literacy.

If you give people money, most spend it caring for their children and invest whatever is left to improve their own income, through education or whatever.

Studies by the World Bank have also shown such measures improve health and education.

And in Britain, the “personalized budgets” offered the elderly and infirm were expanded to an admittedly small test group of impoverished people as well. Nine out of the 15 people in the study moved into better housing, said a report in the Globe and Mail.

It wasn’t a total success. One person went to jail, another couple moved out of housing. But most spent their wages on food, clothing and shelter.

A federal parliamentary committee has also recently examined the issue.

It’s really not that hard to see why.

Such a system would be far easier to administer than the existing one, with its overlapping bureaucracies and case workers who are tasked with interpreting hundreds of rules, often trying to manipulate them to fit oddball circumstances.

Government programs are often about simply getting people off the streets. Perhaps the goal should be about normalizing them – making society more equal, come what may.

Perhaps it’s time to remove the stigma and shame that comes with our existing social programs, and the way they are administered.

Maybe it’s time for a little more trust.

Society must remember that poverty is not about being stupid. It’s about not having money.

And that’s something completely different. (Richard Mostyn)

Just Posted

Walmart to end overnight RV camping this summer

If only drivers of vehicles equipped with beds, fridges and showers could find shelter….

Look who’s 40: Dawson City Music Festival still kicking

‘I hope that they get to see some mind-blowing music’

How did the Yukon government fail to foresee the Whistle Bend housing crunch?

Adding 150 new continuing care workers to a town where rentals are scarce requires better planning

Whitehorse knight seeks return of swords stolen from truck

‘To anybody who’s not doing medieval martial arts, they’re basically just two big metal sticks’

Yukon’s housing-first project set to go over its original budget estimate

The lowest bid came in at $3.9 million. The government originally estimated $2.7 million

New logo unveiled for 2019 National Aboriginal Hockey Championships

‘I think bringing this tournament to Whitehorse will show some of these kids what is possible’

Yukon man found guilty of sexually abusing two girls

The man was found guilty of three counts of sexual interference and acquitted on two others

Destruction Bay motel owners appeal human rights pantsing case

Talbot Arm Motel co-owners Suzanne Tremblay and Charles Eikland filed a notice of appeal July 10

Atlin’s music festival breaks the rules, in a good way

With no cell service and the marketing kept to a minimum, this little festival is actually fun

New name, same data: Carproof to become Carfax Canada

Automotive data firm Carproof has announced that its name will change to… Continue reading

Jessica Frotten captures 4 medals at Canadian Track and Field Championships

‘I’ve had such amazing support system, that’s number one’

Whitehorse dressage show a competition for all ages

‘It’s about being one with your horse and working as a team and celebrating the harmony’

Most Read