Today’s mailbox: Two sides of firearms

Letters to the editor published May 13

Firearms debate about more than just guns

The litmus test for one’s belief in freedom is if you support someone else’s right to do something you do not support yourself.

Maybe it is protecting someone’s freedom of speech even though you find their words offensive, or maybe you defend a woman’s right to choose even though you believe all life is sacred.

The debate over civilian firearms ownership falls into a similar category.

Earlier this month, Prime Minister Justin Trudeau prohibited hundreds of thousands of legally-owned firearms; what he called “military-grade assault weapons, designed for one purpose and one purpose only; to kill the largest number of people in the shortest amount of time.”

Sounds good if you say it fast enough, except that it is not true.

Is the Jeep or Hummer in your neighbour’s driveway a “military-grade assault vehicle” because of its predecessors on the battlefield?

Of course not, no more than the ballpoint pen on your desk is an “astronaut-grade anti-gravity writing utensil,” or the pair of Huggies adorning your toddler’s derriere is a “space diaper,” despite their lunar mission origins.

In fact, many of the newly-prohibited guns were specifically manufactured to comply with Canadian legislation, so if anything, they were literally designed for Canadian sport shooting and hunting.

For people whose understanding of firearms is based in fact as opposed to rhetoric, the ban is also puzzling for not only what is included, but what is not.

A number of single shot big-game hunting rifles are listed, and legal opinions even suggest the ban’s language technically prohibits common duck hunting shotguns, yet some guns that are functionally identical to the so-called “assault weapons” are not.

And while the Liberals’ ban is predicated on the notion that certain firearms are not suitable for hunting, it includes an amnesty period for Indigenous peoples to continue to be able to use them — for hunting.

The Liberals know this will be divisive; in fact, they are counting on it.

As a minority government, they have enacted this ban through an Order in Council, bypassing democratic process and parliamentary debate, in the midst of a global pandemic’s massive economic and social upheaval, where Canadians are otherwise preoccupied with providing for their families and concerned over unprecedented infringements on our civil liberties.

Can you imagine the outcry if a government were to pass new regulations under the same circumstances on another controversial topic, say reproductive rights?

The Liberals have intentionally poked the proverbial hornets’ nest purely for political gain, hoping to vilify anyone who opposes them and further divide Canadians.

Fortunately, even those who do not like guns see this for what it is; a shameless and transparent attempt to distract from the Liberals’ multiple failures and try to appear they are doing “something,” while having absolutely no effect on the criminal use of firearms.

But for those gun owners who said “nobody needs an assault weapon” and now find themselves paraphrasing Charlton Heston over the likelihood of willfully surrendering their beloved hunting gun, remember — you voted for this.

Will you make the same mistake again?

Jonas J. Smith

Whitehorse

An abhorrent image of frontier masculinity

For the men — and I single you out as most of the editorials related to the new gun ban fall within your gender jurisdiction (sic) — concerned about your right to own and use military-grade weapons, I seriously ask you to examine your masculinity in relation to the machines you bring into the natural world.

This type of “frontier masculinity” is a cause for concern on many levels. While there have been some prominent examples of encounters with nature that have ended tragically, for the most part these are rare or connected to an increase in human density in our wild spaces. These encounters were quick, and likely even if a weapon for protection were available, a well trained bear or herding dog to detect and deter, might have been a more effective option for protection. The image of a woman with child walking a trap line with a M14 or Mini 14 or M1A is equally as disturbing as how this story had ended; suited rather as an image accompanied to the unfortunate reality of civil war.

As an individual who came north from an inner-city community that has experienced a drastic increase in gun-related violence in recent years, and especially violence from police who are reacting with heightened fear, I commend the current government’s “rapid fire” response to limiting guns on our streets and within our communities, for all our nations. It is a strong statement on the values we want to promote in our country, and the future we want for our children.

And for those who choose to carry, or rather, who choose to promote their right to carry into an otherwise benevolent space weapons intended for military use, please do take the time to reflect on the evolution of hunting/self-preservation in the north, and what your own imagine of masculinity, perhaps developed in response to media and technological “innovation”, could mean for these places.

Carrie Boles

Whitehorse

Get local stories you won't find anywhere else right to your inbox.
Sign up here

Just Posted

Phase two of the Yukon’s reopening plan could start July 1

New phase would include travel between B.C. and the Yukon

Spas, hair salons, tattoo parlours and more ready for reopening

Many personal services shops set June date to offically welcome back customers

Community Development Fund awards announced

January intake sees $1.4 million for 24 community projects

Alaskan telecom finishes fibre line linking state to Lower 48 via the Yukon

Northwestel is among the Canadian companies carrying MTA’s traffic down south

Civil liberties group pens letter questioning Yukon’s COVID-19 border restrictions

Canadian Civil Liberties Association arguing the Yukon’s border control measures are unconstitutional

City hall, briefly

A look at decisions made by Whitehorse city council this week. June… Continue reading

Pilot Station salmon sonar to go ahead this season

The Pilot Station sonar, located near the mouth of the Yukon River… Continue reading

Renovations start at LePage Park

The Yukon Historical and Museums Association has started a resurfacing project for… Continue reading

Contract awarded for mixed-income housing project

The Yukon government has awarded a $16.8-million contract to build the mixed-income… Continue reading

Watson Lake man charged with gun offences after break-and-enter

Alfred Magun, 60, was arrested and charged with eight offences

Top of the World Highway border crossings remain closed

The Little Gold Creek and Poker Creek border crossings will remain closed… Continue reading

Gymnasts return to Polarettes

Club reopens, summer camps also approved

Yukon College becomes Yukon University

Yukon College has officially become Yukon University, or “YukonU.” The post-secondary institution… Continue reading

Most Read