Liberal tax proposal not worth the political pain

Pick your battles

When I was younger and more idealistic I received some helpful advice that has guided me in my approach to life ever since: Pick your battles.

There are so many things about the world that need to be fixed. Putting the changes we want to see in the context of the effort needed and the pushback expected to accomplish them is part of living a pragmatic existence.

When Justin Trudeau mused in the last election about how some wealthy Canadians use the small business deduction to avoid taxes and implied that a future government led by him might do something about it, I chalked it up as just another politician talking. Nothing would ever come of it.

When Trudeau was raked over the coals for allegedly committing one of the great sins of Canadian politics — speaking ill of small business — I thought he had learned a valuable lesson.

But here we are in the midst of a pitched battle over changes to the way small businesses are taxed in Canada.

You can call me lukewarm about the proposals. I recognize that existing rules provide certain tax advantages to small incorporated businesses which aren’t available to other Canadians and that is arguably unfair.

But is it worth it? Did the Liberals pick this battle wisely?

The longer this debate goes on the less the expenditure of political capital seems justified. We now have some polling data suggesting the party may have taken a bit of a hit politically. One poll from Angus Reid suggests that 45 per cent of Canadians now want a change of government. The personal popularity of the prime minister is down significantly as well, and while it is difficult to attribute cause and effect in politics the business tax changes have inspired anger that crosses party lines in a way few other government policies have.

The Liberals stirred a hornet’s nest because what they proposed disrupted a well-engrained status quo — a status quo that businesses have built their existence around for decades with the implied blessing of the government. In fact some provinces even encouraged doctors to incorporate as a way to effectively offer them more pay without actually doing so. If these were indeed “loopholes” they were loopholes that successive governments saw no need to change.

The “loopholes” messaging that the government has employed to try to sell the changes has not been particularly helpful to its cause. The Liberals have avoided calling this move a tax increase even though that’s the effective result for those businesses that previously took advantage of the ability to income sprinkle, and earn passive income within the corporation. Their total tax bill will go up.

The Liberals were working from the reasonable assumption that the public believes raising taxes is bad, but closing loopholes is good. But it turns out that some Canadians take the accusation that they have been taking advantage of “loopholes” personally as if they are guilty of some sort of wrongdoing. Rather than causing business owners to reflect on the advantages that their incorporation bestows upon them, the messaging decision to refer to legal mechanisms by which they have been structuring their businesses to limit taxes as “loopholes” has added a sense of personal insult to the injury of a higher tax bill.

Thankfully for the government, per their own numbers, only a handful of Canadians will be affected thus limiting the political pain. Right?

Not so fast. The problem the government seems to be facing is that Canadians who don’t run small businesses of their own (or run small businesses but aren’t affected by the changes) empathize with the experience of those who do.

Running a small business is a tough, often insecure existence. Your next paycheque is never guaranteed. You are ever subject to the cycles and whims of the market, the fickle tastes of customers, and the rise and expansion of the competition.

If you lose your job there is no severance pay or employment insurance to fall back on. If you have a bad year, it is not as simple as going to your employees and asking them to share in the pain by taking a cut in pay. An employee’s pay is more or less guaranteed. Layoffs are extremely expensive when you consider the cost of severing employment relations.

Some supporters of the changes have suggested that none of this matters and that the reward to be found for suffering these risks and headaches ought to come from the market and not the government. That may be the case, but tax policy — despite the best wishes of some economists and political theorists — has never been value neutral and promotes all sorts of decision-making. The tax code gives preferential treatment in more than a few places. Retirement savings and raising children are encouraged. Capital gains (paid disproportionately by the well-off) are taxed at half the rate of ordinary income.

So why shouldn’t tax policy encourage and promote small businesses? Do we want to live in a society where we all slave away for large faceless corporations with no sense of loyalty to the communities they live in?

It is not clear to me if the goal of these changes is actually to make taxation fairer (the purported rationale) or to increase government revenue by a few hundred million dollars. Neither seems worth the political price this government is paying.

And while it is certainly true that there has been a lot of misinformation and misplaced fear, the visceral reaction the government has prompted just doesn’t seem worth it. This battle doesn’t seem to be well-chosen. If this government wants to avoid further damage to its political prospects it should probably back off.

Kyle Carruthers is a born-and-raised Yukoner who lives and practises law in Whitehorse.

federal governmenttax policy

Just Posted

Rodney and Ekaterina Baker plead guilty to offences under the Yukon’s Civil Emergency Measures Act for breaking isolation requirements in order to sneak into a vaccine clinic and receive Moderna vaccine doses in Beaver Creek. (Facebook/Submitted)
Couple who broke isolation rules to get vaccines in Beaver Creek fined $2,300

Crown and defence agreed on no jail time for Rod and Ekaterina Baker

X
WYATT’S WORLD

Wyatt’s World for June 16, 2021.… Continue reading

Chief Medical Officer of Health Dr. Brendan Hanley. (Yukon News file)
COVID-19 outbreak surges to 50 active cases in the Yukon

Officials urge Yukoners to continue following guidelines, get vaccinated

Team Yukon during the 2007 Canada Winter Games in Whitehorse. (Submitted/Sport Yukon)
Whitehorse will bid for 2027 Canada Winter Games

Bid would be submitted in July 2022

File Photo
The overdose crisis, largely driven by synthetic opioids such as fentanyl and carfentanil was the topic of an online discussion hosted by Blood Ties Four Directions Centre and the Canadian Drug Policy Coalition on June 8 and 10.
Discussion of overdose crisis in Yukon leaves participants hopeful for future

The forum brought together people including some with personal drug use and addiction experience.

Two participants cross the finish line at the City of Whitehorse Kids Triathlon on June 12 with Mayor Dan Curtis on hand to present medals. (Stephanie Waddell/Yukon News)
2021 Kids’ Triathlon draws 76 young athletes

Youth ages five to 14 swim, run and bike their way to finish line

Lily Witten performs her Canadian Nationals beam routine on June 14. John Tonin/Yukon News
Three Yukon gymnasts break 20-year Nationals absence

Bianca Berko-Malvasio, Maude Molgat and Lily Witten competed at the Canadian Nationals – the first time in 20 years the Yukon’s been represented at the meet

For the second year running, the Yukon Quest will not have 1,000 mile race. Crystal Schick/Yukon News
The Yukon Quest will be two shorter distance events instead of a 1,000 mile race

After receiving musher feeback, the Yukon Quest Joint Board of Directors to hold two shorter distances races instead of going forward with the 1,000 mile distance

Western and Northern premiers met this week to discuss joint issues. (Joe Savikataaq/Twitter)
Premiers meet at Northern Premiers’ Forum and Western Premiers’ Conference

Nunavut Premier Joe Savikataaq virtually hosted both meetings this year

The sun sets over Iqaluit on Oct. 26, 2020. Nunavut’s chief public health officer says two COVID-19 cases at Iqaluit’s middle school came from household transmission and the risk to other students is low. (Emma Tranter/Canadian Press)
Iqaluit school’s contacts and classmates cleared after two COVID-19 cases

With an outbreak ongoing in Iqaluit, the Aqsarniit middle school has split students into two groups

An extended range impact weapon is a “less lethal” option that fires sponge or silicon-tipped rounds, according to RCMP. (File photo)
Whitehorse RCMP under investigation for use of “less lethal” projectile weapon during arrest

Police used the weapon to subdue a hatchet-wielding woman on June 4

Sean Kilpatrick/Canadian Press
Citizenship Minister Marco Mendicino holds a press conference in Ottawa on Nov. 12, 2020. The federal government is announcing that Indigenous people can now apply to reclaim their names on passports and other government documents.
Indigenous people can now reclaim traditional names on their passports and other ID

The move comes in response to a call to action from the Truth and Reconciliation Commission in 2015

Teslin Lake is one of two bodies of water the Yukon Government has place on flood watch. (Google Maps Image)
Flood watch issued for Teslin Lake, Yukon River at Carmacks

The bodies of water may soon burst their banks due to melting snow and rainfall

Most Read