EDITORIAL: The Yukon justice department keeps finding ways to fall short

When the Yukon justice department announced in April its plan to retrofit a unit at the Whitehorse Correctional Centre to become the territory’s new halfway house, astute observers immediately notice something — the WCC is in fact not in the community.

But after more contemplation, it’s just as bizarre as it sounds.

When the Salvation Army’s Yukon Adult Resource Centre closed at the end of April, the department swooped in and did what it does best — make things worse for inmates.

Or should I say hotel guests? After all, when confronted with the shortcomings of the facility at a justice conference in 2018, assistant deputy minister Al Lucier called the WCC his hotel, describing various parts of the justice system as “travel agents” that “book” inmates into his facility.

That, naturally, was a very different time. The WCC was being inspected by David Loukidelis for the mishandling of Michael Nehass, an inmate with mental health issues who served time at the WCC for nearly six years.

Nehass, for the record, was never convicted of the charges that saw him put in jail and he served more time waiting for trial than he would have if he had pleaded guilty.

And it was also the same month that a study ranked the Yukon’s justice system as the worst in the country for the second year in a row.

Armed with that knowledge then, the department’s decision to try to spin this most-recent decision as innovation is just as nonsensical but suddenly more believable.

Andrea Monteiro, Yukon’s director of corrections, told the News on April 15 that the joint venture between the government and the John Howard Society of British Columbia was “an innovative partnership, all the way down from the location to a new NGO in the territory.”

That doesn’t seem like the kind of innovating anyone should aspire to.

Like it or not, halfway houses exist to serve as a bridge between incarceration and the general public.

I’m sure Lucier and the rest of his hotel staff will do their utmost to prepare the three-tiered building known as Unit E to fill the role, but it’s simply not a department that has earned the benefit of the doubt from the public or the media.

When the government reached a settlement over four human rights complaints in 2018, the department’s response wasn’t a mea culpa, but rather a desperate attempt to spin that into a positive.

“This settlement is a strong signal of our ongoing efforts and intent to improve how we provide mental health care services and manage those in custody at the Whitehorse Correctional Centre,” Lucier said in a press release at the time.

It’s been nearly two years, and the decision-making has not changed.

So when a legal advocacy organization and a group of lawyers banded together on May 4 to send a letter to the department, the response of the government was entirely predictable.

Would the government be open to relocating the halfway house, the one that opened just days earlier, to somewhere more in line with the spirit of a halfway house?

“I would say, absolutely no, not at this point,” Lucier said on May 5.

He said a lot of planning went into the transition. Time will tell if that is true; ATIPP exists and will reveal eventually what really did or didn’t happen.

At the very least, that’s a weak reason to do something. It is, however, a strong indication of the incredible inertia holding back reform in the department.

It’s easy to ignore things like this. After all, the perception is that the only affected people are criminals.

They wouldn’t be in this situation if they hadn’t broken the law, some say.

Except Nehass was never convicted.

Except the man who spent hours covered in his own feces in a cell at the WCC was never convicted.

The department seems to like to operate under the assumption that all who are under its purview are guilty.

That is not true and has never been true.

While many will be content to push these rather complicated issues from their mind and allow the government to punch down on some of society’s most vulnerable, not all will.

Guilty or not, all people deserve the rights and protections afforded to them by the law.

A halfway house at a jail is not a halfway house, even if you call the jail a hotel.

The WCC is one hotel that doesn’t need an expansion.


Get local stories you won't find anywhere else right to your inbox.
Sign up here

Just Posted

Places of worship able to reopen this Sunday, YG says

Update includes new guidelines for sports, places of worship and updates to essential services rules

Yukon border control measures constitutional, YG says in reply to CCLA letter

“As Canadians, we also acknowledge that our rights must have ‘reasonable limits’”

Whitehorse city councillor looking into origin of the naming of Spook Creek

A member of Whitehorse city council is looking into a claim that… Continue reading

Sport Yukon hands out annual major awards

Sport Yukon handed out its major awards for 2019 on May 28,… Continue reading

Yukon Government issues tender for bioethical resource review

The Department of Health and Social Services (HSS) is looking for a… Continue reading

Yukon Party argues school councils should be consulted about next school year

The Yukon Party claims teachers and school councils have not been consulted… Continue reading

Today’s mailbox: Emergencies and emergency room workers

Letters to the editor published June 5

Road tests for Class 5 driver’s licences to resume in phase two of reopening

Road tests for all non-commercial vehicle licences, such as Class 5, are… Continue reading

City hall, briefly

A look at decisions made by Whitehorse city council this week. Final… Continue reading

Yukon RCMP see increase in domestic assault, mental health cases

Police in the territory have seen an increase in those areas compared to the same time last year

Poor Creature ordered to pay Yukonstruct legal costs

A judge has ordered the owner of the Poor Creature café to… Continue reading

City tickets 50 on day one of return to parking meter enforcement

A total of 50 parking tickets were issued June 1 by the… Continue reading

Most Read