Yukon lawyer must stick with client despite money troubles

A Yukon Legal Aid lawyer is stuck with her client despite his failure to pay legal fees, the Supreme Court of Canada has decided.

A Yukon Legal Aid lawyer is stuck with her client despite his failure to pay legal fees, the Supreme Court of Canada has decided.

The court’s judgment, released on March 22, examined the murky question of whether a lawyer can dump their client during the legal process. While a client can decide to leave a lawyer at any time, a lawyer doesn’t have that freedom.

The court decided a lawyer should be able to leave their client for ethical reasons, but it wasn’t so generous when the reason for withdrawal is a non-payment of fees.

A request for withdrawal should only be refused if the court “determines, after weighing all the relevant factors, that allowing withdrawal would cause serious harm to the administration of justice,” says the judgment.

In the case of Jennie Cunningham, a Yukon Legal Aid lawyer, the court sidestepped the question of whether the withdrawal of her services would harm the administration of justice. That’s because the appeal that brought the case to Ottawa relates to the jurisdiction of the Yukon’s Territorial Court, which refused Cunningham’s request for withdrawal.

Cunningham had several heavy-hitting intervenors on her side during the case, which was heard last November, including the Law Society of British Columbia, the Law Society of Yukon, the Canadian Bar Association and the Criminal Lawyers’ Association for Ontario.

Four years ago, Cunningham was representing a man charged with sexually assaulting a child. Cunningham’s legal fees were being paid by the Yukon Legal Services Society, also known as Legal Aid, which helps cover legal fees for people who can’t afford them.

In May 2006, Morgan was told he had to update some financial information to have his funding continue. He failed to do that and his funding was stopped. This was within a month of his preliminary inquiry. Legal Aid also told him that Cunningham was no longer on the hook to cover him.

That’s when she applied at the Territorial Court for withdrawal. She indicated that she would take Morgan back if his funding was renewed.

The Yukon territorial court refused her request for several reasons; the seriousness of the charges, the risk of the child’s memory waning if the trial was delayed, the complexity of the legal arguments in the trial and the prejudice against the man because he was charged with being a sex offender.

Justice Leigh Gower agreed with that decision when the case came to him at the Supreme Court of the Yukon. But during the next appeal, the Court of Appeal decided the withdrawal should have been granted.

The Appeal Court argued the law society should regulate lawyers and the decision could come into conflict with a law society disciplinary decision. It also argued that forcing a lawyer to represent a client isn’t fair to that client because their best interest no longer jive.

The case was appealed on the basis that the decision was in the territorial court’s jurisdiction and wasn’t in the hands of the law society. The Supreme Court agreed with that appeal.

Contact James Munson at

jamesm@yukon-news.com

Just Posted

Yukon Liquor Corporation delays plans to hike booze prices

After business owners raised concerns the corporation says it will go back and consult on changes

Yukon chooses Dempster fibre line route

“We needed this last piece”

RRDC to require non-Kaska hunters in Ross River area to get special permit

People hoping to hunt in Ross River area this season need a permit from the Ross River Dena Council

New routes top priority for Whitehorse transit plan

Full Sunday service still off the table, though plan proposes pilot project

City mulls replacing Handy Bus with taxi vouchers

‘Whitehorse Transit must take steps to provide a sustainable solution’

Missing Oregon family found after possibly getting lost on purpose

Officials say family of four was found near Dease Lake after their vehicle was apparently abandoned

Yukon Roller Girls, North Coast Nightmares face off at Scar Wars

‘Our jammers had to work a little bit harder than they’re used to’

Big Cruise doubles down on the Skagway cruise market

The world’s largest leisure travel company is doubling down on the Skagway… Continue reading

Neighbours slam proposed Copper Ridge townhouses

Property values, parking cited as cause for concern

New Wolf Creek accessible trail nears completion

‘It’s a totally different trail and they barely touched anything’

Competition topples Tippy Mah’s Whitehorse condo plans

Work suspended on 44-unit project after pre-sales fall short

One-day event focuses on Yukon housing woes

Territory suffers from low vacancy rate, aging rental stock

Mosquito Enduro-X kickstarts racing season

‘It’s fun, family-type racing and it gets the kids out and riding’

Most Read