Vuntut Gwitchin ‘stuck in the crossfire’ over waterfront land

The Vuntut Gwitchin First Nation has unwittingly become embroiled in a continuing land dispute between the Yukon government and the Ta’an…

The Vuntut Gwitchin First Nation has unwittingly become embroiled in a continuing land dispute between the Yukon government and the Ta’an Kwach’an First Nation.

On Wednesday, it was announced that the Vuntut Gwitchin had emerged as the successful bidder for two disputed lots along the Yukon River close to Ogilvie Street.

But it won’t be seeing the land, or its $600,000 deposit, until court proceedings between the Ta’an Kwach’an and the Yukon government have been resolved.

“We don’t take any position on this issue … we simply are interested in doing business, and these types of uncertainties really do not assist in developing a climate for business,” said Stephen Mills, president of the Vuntut Gwitchin Limited Partnership.

“I don’t think that any potential developer or landowner should get stuck in the crossfire between government and First Nations,” he added.

In a series of letters between Premier Dennis Fentie and the Ta’an Kwach’an from 2004 through 2007, the premier indicated that once the Canada Winter Games had wrapped up, he was open to discussing various “disposal options” for two plots of government-owned riverfront land close to Ogilvie Street.

However, before any discussion could take place, the government opened the lands to public tender on June 25, a move that the Ta’an Kwach’an asserts was a clear breach of the “honour of the Crown.”

The First Nation is now in court to seek an injunction to suspend the sale of the waterfront lots.

If an injunction is obtained, it may even jeopardize the Vuntut Gwitchin’s chances at obtaining alternative downtown land.

The First Nation claimed that as a result of monetary deposits tied up in bids for the riverfront land, it has been unable to bid on a series of other downtown lots that have been offered by the city of Whitehorse.

“Our money was frozen beyond the closing dates for the bids for those (city of Whitehorse) properties. It put us in a position not to bid on those lots, because we had a significant amount of money that was locked away in a safe,” said Mills.

Should the Ta’an Kwach’an obtain an injunction, the Vuntut Gwitchin have indicated that it would seek damages from the Yukon government.

The Yukon government, in turn, has claimed that they would refer these damages to the Ta’an Kwach’an.

In court proceedings on Wednesday, Roger Watt, lawyer for the Ta’an Kwach’an, reasserted that since all official statements made by Fentie are infused with the “honour of the Crown,” his decision to disregard a purchase meeting with the Ta’an Kwach’an was an unlawful breach of the government’s duty to aboriginal groups.

“The concept of the honour of the Crown infuses all of (the government’s) dealings with aboriginal peoples,” said Watt.

 “The honour of the Crown is not engaged in this case because neither aboriginal or treaty rights are involved,” said Penelope Gawn, the lead defence for the government.

The government is asserting that the move to public tender was necessary to maintain the “public interest.”

Given that both the Kwanlin Dun and Ta’an Kwach’an had privately expressed interest in the land, “the fairest and most transparent option was to put theses lots up for public tender,” said Gawn.

“There’s a good deal of co-operation between Kwanlin Dun and Ta’an Kwach’an, so to suggest that the public interest demands a public tender is baseless,” said Watt in a rebuttal.

As well, Gawn alleged that charges by the Ta’an Kwach’an were an attack against the legitimacy of the public tender process.

“There is a public interest in maintaining the integrity of the tendering system,” said Gawn. The Vuntut Gwitchin and the Ta’an Kwach’an “were the only ones who submitted bids — if the bid is reopened they would likely be prejudiced.”

“If there’s been a jeopardization of the tender process, it’s because the tender process has been imposed prematurely in violation of the government’s obligations,” countered Watt.

In court it was also suggested that the Ta’an Kwach’an should have simply bid on then-available city of Whitehorse land rather than pursuing legal action towards the riverfront property.

“We don’t want to be on Second Ave., we want to be on the riverfront,” said Ta’an Kwach’an Chief Ruth Massie in comments outside the courtroom.

Watt asserted that the disputed land was unique in its proximity to existing Ta’an territory, its size, its waterfront status and its proximity to downtown.

Even if other downtown land could be obtained, failure to secure the two riverfront lots causes “irreparable” harm to the Ta’an Kwach’an, said Watt.

The First Nation has indicated that it wishes to use the lots for a commercial joint venture with the Kwanlin Dun. In court statements, Watt alluded to the possibility of a cultural centre.

The Vuntut Gwitchin First Nation plans to use the property “for a mix of residential and commercial space,” said Mills.

“We think it could be developed in such a way that it’s attractive and it fits in well with the waterfront.”

Justice Ron Veale will rule on the injunction on Monday at 4 p.m.

Just Posted

John Hopkins-Hill/Yukon News file
Catherine Elliott, Yukon acting Chief Medical Officer of Health, has announced two new COVID-19 cases in the Yukon.
Two new COVID-19 cases confirmed, Porter Creek Secondary prom cancelled

Graduating students are encouraged to self-isolate and monitor for symptoms

Jim Elliot/Yukon News
Ross and Cindy Smith are finding more reason to smile as the floodwaters that almost reached their farm house were beginning to recede on June 8.
Farms on South Klondike Highway experience severe flooding

The nearest body of water is a lake almost three kilometres away

X
WYATT’S WORLD

Wyatt’s World for June 11, 2021.… Continue reading

Whitehorse courthouse interior on April 6, 2018. (Crystal Schick/Yukon News)
CYFN launches pilot program for community impact statements

First Nations will receive support developing statements after major crimes

Israr Ahmed speaks at a vigil at the Whitehorse Mosque to honour the Muslim family killed in London, Ont. on June 10. (John Tonin/Yukon News)
Yukoners gather to honour Muslim family killed in London

Like many communities across the country, Yukoners came together to honour the Muslim family murdered in London Ontario

The RCMP Critical Incident Program will be training in Watson Lake from June 14-16. Mike Thomas/Yukon News
RCMP will conduct three days of training in Watson Lake

Lakeview Apartment in Watson Lake will be used for RCMP training

John Tonin/Yukon News Squash players duke it out during Yukon Open tournament action at Better Bodies on June 5.
Four division titles earned at squash Yukon Open

The territory’s squash talent was on full display at the 2021 Yukon Open

Runners leave the start line of the 2014 Klondike Trail of ‘98 International Road Relay Skagway. The 2021 race will start at checkpoint six and remain in the Yukon only. (Tom Patrick/Yukon News)
Klondike Road Relay returns to in-person after a virtual year

A modified, in-person Klondike Road Relay will be open to Yukoners

John Tonin/Yukon News Rang Pillai speaks at the Great Yukon Summer press conference on May 27.
‘The sooner the better’: Operators react to Great Yukon Summer campaign

The Great Yukon Summer campaign was announced May 27 and begins June 4

Mayor Dan Curtis stands in front of Minister Richard Mostyn and MP Larry Bagnell during an infastructure announcement made outside Jack Hulland Elementary School in Whitehorse on June 2. (Haley Ritchie/Yukon News)
Safety improvements planned for Whitehorse school zones

Enhanced pedestrian crosses are planned to make walking to school safer

2020 Haines Junction graduates line up for a photo on May 27, 2020 as part of a celebration parade through the village. While the St. Elias Community School is able to host an outdoor grad ceremony for 2021 grads this year, it will also host a parade and group photo as it did last year. (Marty Samis/Submitted)
Ceremonies and parades all part of 2021 grad

2021 sees old traditions return with some 2020 events adopted

A rendering of the proposed new city hall/services building and transit hub. (City of Whitehorse/submitted)
New city hall could cost $24.7 million

Council will be presented with latest plans June 7

Most Read