Shelley Cuthbert walks two of her pitbull-mix rescue dogs, Bebe, left and Brutus, in Whitehorse on April 4. (Crystal Schick/Yukon News)

Tagish dog rescue owner’s application to relocate dogs dismissed

Shelley Cuthbert asked appeal court permission to move dogs to Carcross instead of surrendering them

The B.C.-Yukon Court of Appeal has dismissed an application by Tagish dog rescue owner Shelley Cuthbert requesting she be allowed to relocate dogs instead of surrendering them until her appeal against her neighbours’ lawsuit is heard.

Cuthbert argued her application before a panel of three judges — Justices Mary Newbury, David Frankel and Barbara Fischer, who appeared via video conference — in a Whitehorse courtroom April 9.

After about 20 minutes of deliberation, Newbury said that the panel was “not persuaded” that it should make any changes to the existing order requiring Cuthbert to surrender 10 dogs to the Yukon’s Animal Health Unit on the 15th of every month.

“I understand that you have a big heart and want to take care of these dogs … (but) the law does need to be observed as well,” Newbury said, adding that the panel was concerned that the case appeared to be “dragging on.”

Six of Cuthbert’s neighbours in Tagish Estates won a nuisance lawsuit against her last year that resulted in an order for her to reduce the dogs on her property from 60 to two. Cuthbert filed an appeal and, in January, B.C.-Yukon Court of Appeal Justice John J.L. Hunter granted a partial stay of that order, requiring Cuthbert instead to surrender 10 dogs a month to the Animal Health Unit until her appeal is heard.

Cuthbert’s unsuccessful application had requested for the partial stay to be amended so that she could relocate 10 dogs a month instead to the property of a Carcross citizen who has offered up his land for her use. Cuthbert told the panel she could start moving dogs to that property starting April 15 if the ground was thawed.

Cuthbert said she didn’t want to surrender any more dogs to the Animal Health Unit because not many of them would meet the unit’s criteria for adoption and would be euthanized. Moving them to a temporary location instead, she argued, would be in the best interests of the dogs and justice.

“I don’t want to euthanize any more dogs…. Euthanizing healthy dogs has not been very well-received by the public,” Cuthbert said, referring to the 10 dogs that were euthanized in February. Four of those dogs had been surrendered by Cuthbert to the Animal Health Unit and put down on her request. The other six were returned to their previous owners, who also had them put down.

Cuthbert said she currently has 43 dogs at her property. On top of the 10 that were put down, she said she’s also adopted three out. It’s unclear what happened to the other four.

Lawyer Graham Lang, who’s representing Cuthbert’s neighbours, argued that the application should be dismissed. The proposed relocation relies too heavily on the variable of the ground thawing, he said, and even if the dogs are relocated, it would result in a “catastrophic situation” if Cuthbert loses her appeal and suddenly has to deal with 40 dogs.

“We need to start dealing with this,” he said. “We’ve got the same issue we’ve had for the last two years.”

Cuthbert’s appeal is scheduled to be heard May 10.

Contact Jackie Hong at jackie.hong@yukon-news.com

Just Posted

Child Development Centre marks 40 years of service

CDC now serves families throughout the territory

Triple J’s expands offerings with new skin care line

The products feature Canadian ingredients and environmentally-friendly packaging

Relatives of pedestrian struck in 2001 urge change after latest fatality at the intersection

‘I don’t know what the solution is, but I just think something needs to be done’

Whitehorse officials promise improvements to cycling routes

Commuters say more focus on the downtown is needed

WYATT’S WORLD

Wyatt’s World

Arctic Sports Inter-School Championship draws athletes from as far as Juneau

The three-day event included more than 300 participants from kindergarten to Grade 12

Access road to Telegraph Creek now open

Ministry has spent $300K to date on work to clear rockslide

Freedom Trails responds to lawsuit

A statement of defence was to the Yukon Supreme Court on Nov. 19.

Whitehorse RCMP seeking suspects after robbery at Yukon Inn

Robbery took place in early hours of Nov. 27, with suspects armed with a knife and “large stick”

Yukonomist: Your yogurt container’s dirty secret

You should still recycle, but recycling one might be giving you a false sense of environmental virtue

History Hunter: New book tells old story of nursing in the Yukon

Author Amy Wilson was a registered nurse in the Yukon from 1949 to 1951

Jack Hulland wins 2019 Yukon Elementary School Hockey Tournament

The one-day tournament featured nearly a dozen teams from Whitehorse, Dawson City and Teslin

City news, briefly

Some of the decisions that were made at the Nov. 25 Whitehorse city council meeting

Most Read