Ross River case wraps up in court

No lawyer likes to hear the judge hypothetically rule against them. Especially during the last chance to argue their case. But that's what happened to the Ross River Dena Council's lawyer, Stephen Walsh.

No lawyer likes to hear the judge hypothetically rule against them.

Especially during the last chance to argue their case.

But that’s what happened to the Ross River Dena Council’s lawyer, Stephen Walsh.

Before Walsh began his closing argument on Wednesday, Justice Leigh Gower said if he ruled against the First Nation on the first question of the case, he would likely do the same for the second.

The first question is whether a document drafted 141 years ago has legal clout today.

That document, the 1870 Order, transferred the land that now makes up Canada, including the Yukon, from England. It promised that Canada would “consider and settle” aboriginal claims.

The second question is whether Canada still owes the Ross River Dena Council, which remains without a land claim agreement, any money.

Walsh, clearly taken aback, argued even if the order isn’t a legally binding contract today, Ottawa could still owe the Ross Rover Dena Council money.

That’s because it was a decision made by Parliament that became incorporated into the Constitution of Canada, so it has extra legal force.

And Canada has always had certain responsibilities to care for First Nations, Walsh argued.

The case Canada made is fairly summed up with testimony from Cambridge professor Paul McHugh, who took the stand for the Crown earlier this week.

When the 1870 Order was signed, it would have been absurd to think “Indians” could ever take the Canadian government to court, he said.

Much of his testimony and cross-examination led the court to flip through eight or so binders, ranging from two to eight inches thick, and debate what Canadian and English legislators were thinking back in 1870.

McHugh also pointed out that the order called on Canada “to consider and settle” the First Nations’ claims to compensation for land that Canada wanted to settle, primarily for farming.

“Consider” means Canada could weigh its options and decide whether or not to compensate the aboriginal groups, and deciding not to would “settle” the claim just as much as offering compensation would, he said.

During their closing arguments, Canada’s lawyers also argued that their responsibility to First Nations would only exist if the original document explicitly stated so, or recognized Ross River Dena Council’s specific claim.

The term “Indian groups,” was not specific enough, they said.

Before the seven-day trial ended, Walsh asked Gower to discount McHugh’s testimony. He challenged the professor’s impartiality and asserted his arguments are self-contradictory and ignore past court decisions.

Gower hopes to make his decision before Christmas.

Contact Roxanne Stasyszyn at

Get local stories you won't find anywhere else right to your inbox.
Sign up here

Just Posted

Diane McLeod-McKay, Yukon’s Ombudsman and information and privacy commissioner, filed a petition on Dec. 11 after her office was barred from accessing documents related to a child and family services case. (Crystal Schick/Yukon News file)
Yukon government rejects Ombudsman requests for documentation filed to Supreme Court

Diane McLeod-McKay filed a petition on Dec. 11 after requests for documents were barred

Buffalo Sabres center Dylan Cozens, left, celebrates his first NHL goal with defenceman Rasmus Ristolainen during the second period of a game against the Washington Capitals on Jan. 22 in Washington. (Nick Wass/AP)
Cozens notches first NHL goal in loss to Capitals

The Yukoner potted his first tally at 10:43 of the second period on Jan. 22

Rodney and Ekaterina Baker in an undated photo from social media. The couple has been ticketed and charged under the Yukon’s <em>Civil Emergency Measures Act</em> for breaking isolation requirements in order to sneak into a vaccine clinic and receive Moderna vaccine doses in Beaver Creek. (Facebook/Submitted)
Former CEO of Great Canadian Gaming, actress charged after flying to Beaver Creek for COVID-19 vaccine

Rod Baker and Ekaterina Baker were charged with two CEMA violations each

Yukonomist Keith Halliday
Yukonomist: Are they coming?

One of COVID-19’s big economic questions is whether it will prompt a… Continue reading

Yukon MP Larry Bagnell, along with Yukon health and education delegates, announce a new medical research initiative via a Zoom conference on Jan. 21. (Screen shot)
New medical research unit at Yukon University launched

The SPOR SUPPORT Unit will implement patient-first research practices

The bus stop at the corner of Industrial and Jasper Road in Whitehorse on Jan. 25. The stop will be moved approximately 80 metres closer to Quartz Road. (Crystal Schick/Yukon News)
UPDATED: Industrial Road bus stop to be relocated

The city has postponed the move indefinitely

The Royal Canadian Mounted Police detachment in Faro photgraphed in 2016. Faro will receive a new RCMP detachment in 2022, replacing the decades-old building currently accommodating officers. (Joel Krahn/Yukon News file)
Faro RCMP tagged for new detachment

Faro will receive a new RCMP detachment in 2022, replacing the decades-old… Continue reading

In a Jan. 18 announcement, the Yukon government said the shingles vaccine is now being publicly funded for Yukoners between age 65 and 70, while the HPV vaccine program has been expanded to all Yukoners up to and including age 26. (
Changes made to shingles, HPV vaccine programs

Pharmacists in the Yukon can now provide the shingles vaccine and the… Continue reading

Parking attendant Const. Ouellet puts a parking ticket on the windshield of a vehicle in downtown Whitehorse on Dec. 6, 2018. The City of Whitehorse is hoping to write of nearly $300,000 in outstanding fees, bylaw fines and court fees, $20,225 of which is attributed to parking fines issued to non-Yukon license plates. (Crystal Schick/Yukon News file)
City of Whitehorse could write off nearly $300,000

The City of Whitehorse could write off $294,345 in outstanding fees, bylaw… Continue reading

Grants available to address gender-based violence

Organizations could receive up to $200,000

In this illustration, artist-journalist Charles Fripp reveals the human side of tragedy on the Stikine trail to the Klondike in 1898. A man chases his partner around the tent with an axe, while a third man follows, attempting to intervene. (The Daily Graphic/July 27, 1898)
History Hunter: Charles Fripp — gold rush artist

The Alaskan coastal town of Wrangell was ill-equipped for the tide of… Continue reading

A man walks passed the polling place sign at city hall in Whitehorse on Oct. 18, 2018. While Whitehorse Mayor Dan Curtis is now setting his sights on the upcoming territorial election, other members of council are still pondering their election plans for the coming year. (Crystal Schick/Yukon News file)
Councillors undecided on election plans

Municipal vote set for Oct. 21

Whitehorse City Hall. (Joel Krahn/Yukon News file)
City hall, briefly

A look at decicions made by Whitehorse city council this week.

Most Read