Ross River case wraps up in court

No lawyer likes to hear the judge hypothetically rule against them. Especially during the last chance to argue their case. But that's what happened to the Ross River Dena Council's lawyer, Stephen Walsh.

No lawyer likes to hear the judge hypothetically rule against them.

Especially during the last chance to argue their case.

But that’s what happened to the Ross River Dena Council’s lawyer, Stephen Walsh.

Before Walsh began his closing argument on Wednesday, Justice Leigh Gower said if he ruled against the First Nation on the first question of the case, he would likely do the same for the second.

The first question is whether a document drafted 141 years ago has legal clout today.

That document, the 1870 Order, transferred the land that now makes up Canada, including the Yukon, from England. It promised that Canada would “consider and settle” aboriginal claims.

The second question is whether Canada still owes the Ross River Dena Council, which remains without a land claim agreement, any money.

Walsh, clearly taken aback, argued even if the order isn’t a legally binding contract today, Ottawa could still owe the Ross Rover Dena Council money.

That’s because it was a decision made by Parliament that became incorporated into the Constitution of Canada, so it has extra legal force.

And Canada has always had certain responsibilities to care for First Nations, Walsh argued.

The case Canada made is fairly summed up with testimony from Cambridge professor Paul McHugh, who took the stand for the Crown earlier this week.

When the 1870 Order was signed, it would have been absurd to think “Indians” could ever take the Canadian government to court, he said.

Much of his testimony and cross-examination led the court to flip through eight or so binders, ranging from two to eight inches thick, and debate what Canadian and English legislators were thinking back in 1870.

McHugh also pointed out that the order called on Canada “to consider and settle” the First Nations’ claims to compensation for land that Canada wanted to settle, primarily for farming.

“Consider” means Canada could weigh its options and decide whether or not to compensate the aboriginal groups, and deciding not to would “settle” the claim just as much as offering compensation would, he said.

During their closing arguments, Canada’s lawyers also argued that their responsibility to First Nations would only exist if the original document explicitly stated so, or recognized Ross River Dena Council’s specific claim.

The term “Indian groups,” was not specific enough, they said.

Before the seven-day trial ended, Walsh asked Gower to discount McHugh’s testimony. He challenged the professor’s impartiality and asserted his arguments are self-contradictory and ignore past court decisions.

Gower hopes to make his decision before Christmas.

Contact Roxanne Stasyszyn at

Just Posted

Whether the dust jacket of this historical novel is the Canadian version (left) or the American (right), the readable content within is the same. (Michael Gates)
History Hunter: New novel a gripping account of the gold rush

Stampede: Gold Fever and Disaster in the Klondike is an ‘enjoyable and readable’ account of history


Wyatt’s World for May 14, 2021.… Continue reading

Copies of the revised 2021-22 budget documents tabled in the legislature on May 14. (Haley Ritchie/Yukon News)
Liberals introduce new budget with universal dental and safe supply funding

The new items were added to secure the support of the NDP.

Community Services Minister Richard Mostyn speaks to reporters on May 13. (Haley Ritchie/Yukon News)
Cap on rent increases will take effect May 15

The rollout of the policy is creating ‘chaos,’ says opposition

Yukon News file
A 21-year-old man is in custody after a stabbing in Porter Creek on May 14.
One man in hospital, another in custody, after alleged stabbing in Porter Creek

A police dog was used to track the suspect who was later arrested in a wooded area.

Safe at home office in Whitehorse on May 10, 2021. (John Tonin/Yukon News)
Federal government provides $1.6 million for Yukon anti-homelessness work

Projects including five mobile homes for small communities received funding.

Drilling at Northern Tiger’s 3Ace gold project in 2011. Randi Newton argues that mining in the territory can be reshaped. (Yukon government/file)
Editorial: There’s momentum for mining reform

CPAWS’ Randi Newton argues that the territory’s mining legislations need a substantial overhaul

At its May 10 meeting, Whitehorse city council approved the subdivision for the Kwanlin Dün First Nation’s business park planned in Marwell. (Submitted)
KDFN business park subdivision approved

Will mean more commercial industrial land available in Whitehorse

Main Street in Whitehorse on May 4. Whitehorse city council has passed the first two readings of a bylaw to allow pop-up patios in city parking spaces. Third reading will come forward later in May. (Stephanie Waddell/Yukon News)
Whitehorse council pursuing restaurant patio possibilities

Council passes first two readings for new patio bylaw

Neil Hartling, the Tourism Industry Association of the Yukon president, left, said the new self-isolation guidelines for the Yukon are a ‘ray of hope’ for tourism operators. (Ian Stewart/Yukon News file)
Yukon tourism operators prepared for ‘very poor summer’ even with relaxed border rules

Toursim industry responds to new guidelines allowing fully vaccinated individuals to skip mandatory self-isolation.

A lawsuit has been filed detailing the resignation of a former Yukon government mine engineer. (Joel Krahn/Yukon News file)
A year after resigning, former chief mine engineer sues Yukon government

Paul Christman alleges a hostile work environment and circumvention of his authority led him to quit

Former Liberal MLA Pauline Frost speaks to reporters outside the courthouse on April 19. One of the voters accused of casting an invalid vote has been granted intervenor status in the lawsuit Frost filed last month. (Haley Ritchie/Yukon News)
Voters named in Pauline Frost election lawsuit ask to join court proceedings

The judge granted Christopher Schafer intervenor status

Most Read