Peel documents filed with the Supreme Court of Canada

The environmental groups and First Nations fighting with the Yukon government over the Peel watershed have officially asked the Supreme Court of Canada to hear their case.

The environmental groups and First Nations fighting with the Yukon government over the Peel watershed have officially asked the Supreme Court of Canada to hear their case.

The Peel case, and the way Yukon’s umbrella final agreement is interpreted, will impact all of Canada’s First Nations that have modern treaties, they argue.

“If allowed to stand, the reasoning of the Court of Appeal will inevitably undermine the careful balance between the respective roles in future decision-making of non-Aboriginal governments and Aboriginal peoples that has been so assiduously negotiated and set out not only in the Yukon modern treaties, but in similar modem treaties across Canada,” the document says.

The Supreme Court of Canada judges only hear about 10 per cent of the cases that are sent its way, so lawyers have to prove a case is worth their time.

In the Peel case, both the Yukon Supreme Court and the Yukon Court of Appeal agreed that the Yukon broke the rules when it tried to create its own plan for the giant swath of mostly untouched Yukon land.

While the Peel land use planning commission had recommended 80 per cent protection, the government’s plan was for 29 per cent. The government’s plan was thrown out by both courts.

To fix the mistake, the Yukon Supreme Court said the government could go back and try again to modify the recommended plan. But the judge said the government couldn’t alter balance between protection and development, or allow building new roads or other surface access into the area.

The judge said the government didn’t provide enough detail about the changes it wanted earlier in the process, so those points were off the table.

The Court of Appeal arrived at a different conclusion, saying the government could make any changes it wanted so long as it properly consulted with everyone and provided a more detailed explanation of their plans.

The Yukon government has always maintained that it needs to have final say in the management of public lands.

But the First Nations and environmental groups say that giving the government this much of a do-over is taking things too far.

While most of the Peel case centres around treaty interpretation, Thomas Berger, the aboriginal law pioneer going against the Yukon government, touches on the Peel’s environmental value as being nationally significant.

“The Peel watershed is a national treasure in the custodianship of the government of Yukon and First Nations. The future of the Peel Watershed is a matter of importance not only to Yukoners but to all Canadians.”

The Yukon government will have 30 days to respond to the application for leave to appeal. After that, the other side gets 10 days to respond to any of the government’s arguments.

It will be months before anyone gets a yes or no answer from the Supreme Court of Canada.

Meanwhile, more legal wrangling means more costs.

The Yukon Department of Justice says it spent $232,496 on Outside lawyers for the Yukon appeal alone.

That brings the total spent in the whole thing so far to $285,767.

The First Nations and environmental groups have refused to say how much money they’ve spent so far.

Contact Ashley Joannou at

ashleyj@yukon-news.com

Just Posted

Yukon’s Japanese association launches its first sake festival

Former president says the hope is to bring people together to learn

Yukon First Nations, AFN Yukon, CYFN sign climate change emergency declaration

The declaration was signed on the last day of the Yukon First Nations Climate Action Gathering

Yukon Fish and Game Association opposed to moose management proposals

Executive director Eric Schroff said he thinks Yukon government needs to be more transparent

WYATT’S WORLD

Wyatt’s World

Casino taking more time with mine proposal

Statement not expected to be submitted to YESAB until Dec. 31, 2021

Tr’ondëk Hwëch’in to hold general election in April

On top of voting for chief, three councillors, citizens will vote for a deputy chief for first time

Yukon’s minimum wage set to increase by $1 to $13.71 in April

The increase will make the Yukon’s minimum wage the fourth-highest in the country

City news, briefly

Some of the decisions made at the Whitehorse council meeting on Feb 17

Yukonomist: Three questions on Yukon Zinc and China

The case heard recently in Yukon Supreme Court is particularly troubling

Commentary: Highway plans will negatively impact safety

The proposed Alaska Highway work will impact our safety, our communities and our environment.

Olivia Webster is the final musher to finish the Yukon Quest

‘I guess I’ve always been a grandpa’s girl and he’s my best friend, so I kind of wanted to be like him and so I did it’

Yukon’s Rob Cooke and company finish 10th in the 2020 Yukon Quest

Cooke and his 14 Siberians crossed the finish line at 9:07 a.m. on Feb. 15 in Whitehorse

Lights Out Yukon Invitational Basketball Tournament bigger than ever in sixth year

“Honestly, it was the smoothest tournament I think we’ve run yet”

Most Read