New trial ordered after rape conviction overturned

The Yukon Court of Appeal has ordered a new trial for a man convicted of sexual assault in 2014, ruling the Yukon Supreme Court judge who made the original ruling didn’t properly evaluate the evidence presented at trial.

The Yukon Court of Appeal has ordered a new trial for a man convicted of sexual assault in 2014, ruling the Yukon Supreme Court judge who made the original ruling didn’t properly evaluate the evidence presented at trial.

Because much of the case rested on the complainant’s testimony, the judge had to make a ruling based solely on her credibility.

In this case the trial judge rejected the accused’s evidence and didn’t find that his testimony raised any doubt. But the court of appeal found a number of issues with the trial judge’s ruling.

The judge didn’t take into account evidence that contradicted the complainant’s testimony and made findings based on evidence not heard at trial, the appeal court found.

“I consider that the judgment rests on conclusions material to the credibility assessment that are either unsupported by the evidence or are based upon evidence that was misapprehended,” Justice Mary Saunders wrote for the court.

The accused was seeking to be acquitted.

“As there is a body of evidence supporting the charge, I do not consider an acquittal should be entered,” Saunders wrote.

A publication ban prohibits identifying the victim. In the appeal court’s written judgment, the accused is identified only by the initials MTL.

The case stems from the night of Aug. 31, 2013 when the complainant was at the home of the accused, who was a friend, near Whitehorse.

There’s very little in common between the two testimonies, except for the fact the two had sex.

The question at trial was whether it was consensual.

The victim testified it wasn’t, that the accused made her uncomfortable at a bar that night, touching her.

During the trial she testified she stayed at the accused’s home because she didn’t have a place to stay.

When they got to the accused’s home, he tried to kiss her and she avoided his advances.

She testified she woke up on a couch in the accused’s home, with the man on top of her.

MTL testified the sexual encounter took place when the victim came to his bed.

In its ruling the court of appeal only addressed two of the mistakes the judge made, saying those alone were enough to overturn his decision.

At trial, the accused said bite marks on the woman’s neck were a hickey the victim asked for, while she said the accused bit her “really hard” leaving bruises.

The bites were more consistent with a bite than a hickey, the judge said. But it’s not that clear-cut, the court of appeal said.

“Yet having viewed the photographs, I am unable to conclude they support (the victim’s) version of the sexual encounter as the judge said they did,” Saunders wrote.

“They are at best equivocal and do not provide a basis upon which one may say ‘the marks are more consistent with a bite than a hickey.’”

The judge ruled the victim’s testimony was largely corroborated by her partner, who also testified during the original trial.

That was simply not the case, the Court of Appeal found.

“More troubling is that in narrowing the purported area of corroboration, the statement does not grapple with obvious differences in the overall accounts of (the victim’s partner) and (the victim) that could, depending on the trier of fact’s view of those witnesses, reflect adversely on the reliability of (the victim’s) testimony,” Saunders wrote.

The court cited as an example the victim and her partner contradicting each other about how many calls they made to each other after the alleged sexual assault.

“To the extent the judge considered (the victim’s partner’s) evidence largely corroborated (the victim’s), I conclude the corroboration was on narrow and relatively undisputed facts,” Saunders wrote.

“Significant divergence between their evidence was not acknowledged in the reasons for judgment.”

Contact Pierre Chauvin at pierre.chauvin@yukon-news.com

Just Posted

Finance employee charged with allegedly defrauding Yukon government of nearly $50k

Michael Kipkirui was arrested Nov. 12 and is facing eight criminal charges

CBC North reverses decision to replace local a.m. newscasts with ‘pan-northern’ model

Staff at CBC Yukon felt ‘shock and disappointment’ over the original plan, made public Nov. 18

WYATT’S WORLD

Wyatt’s World

Reclamation fund being explored in wake of Wolverine Mine receivership

The Yukon government isn’t going to require mines pay more than 100 per cent in security

History Hunter: Travel has been a challenge for Yukon MPs

Getting from Yukon to Ottawa was a trek

Team Yukon finishes 3-6 at 2020 Canadian Mixed Curling Championships

Yukon skip Thomas Scoffin won a sportsmanship award at the event as voted on by the players

Yukoner Jessica Frotten racks up top 10s at World Para Athletics Championships

“I’m really putting everything I’ve got into making that Canadian team for Tokyo”

1898 Yukon gold rush photo featuring Greta Thunberg look-alike sends internet into tailspin

Jokes erupted this week after a 120-year-old photo taken by Eric A. Hegg surfaced from archives

Mikayla Kramer finishes top five at Skate Canada BC/YK Sectional Championships

“I love when there is so much energy in the crowd and I really felt that in this competition”

Whitehorse biathlete Nadia Moser earns IBU World Cup spot on Canadian team

Whitehorse’s Nadia Moser will begin the biathlon season at the IBU World… Continue reading

Whitehorse Glacier Bears host swimmers from Inuvik and B.C. at Ryan Downing Memorial Invitational Swim Meet

“Everyone had a good time – it was amazing. It was a really great meet.”

City news, briefly

Some of the decisions made at the Nov. 12 Whitehorse council meeting

Most Read