Little Salmon/Carmacks court case

Having to consult with First Nations on the sale of Crown land would be a “tremendous burden,” the Yukon government argued in court this…

Having to consult with First Nations on the sale of Crown land would be a “tremendous burden,” the Yukon government argued in court this week.

The territory was appealing the decision of Supreme Court Justice Ron Veale that favoured the Little Salmon/Carmacks First Nation.

“The duty to consult and, where appropriate, accommodate, was not met because the Yukon government never engaged the First Nation or Johnny Sam in direct consultation to address the First Nation’s rights in the final agreement,” concluded Supreme Court Justice Ron Veale in a decision handed down about one year ago.

That decision was unlawful, the territory claimed in its appeal.

This week, a packed courtroom heard the arguments of the territory, Little Salmon/Carmacks and several interveners in the precedent-setting case.

In 2004, the Yukon government granted Larry Paulsen 65 hectares of agricultural land 40 kilometres north of Carmacks.

The Yukon Party government did all the necessary consultation as required by the land claims agreement, said the territory’s lawyer.

Notice was sent to the First Nation, giving it the opportunity to prepare and present its views on the land sale.

The government then considered those views.

The land overlaps 0.5 per cent of trapline No. 143, owned by Little Salmon/Carmacks elder Johnny Sam.

The First Nation raised concerns about settlement land adjacent to the proposed agricultural lease and the possibility of archeological sites on the land.

A fish and wildlife management plan for the area was also being negotiated.

The plan should be completed before any land sales are made, argued Little Salmon/Carmacks.

The government promised compensation for the loss of the portion of Johnny Sam’s trapline.

The application was changed and a 30-metre buffer was created to protect a portion of the property where undiscovered heritage and archeological sites may have been located.

Government environmental assessments found there would not be a significant loss of wildlife habitat.

The Canadian government intervened in the appeal.

It challenged Veale’s ruling that there is a duty to consult directly with First Nations once a land claims agreement has been signed.

The court should only exist to see that the land claim processes themselves are reasonable, argued the federal government.

The reason the government has land planning and environmental assessments is to help it avoid having to negotiate on a case-by-case basis.

The agreement anticipates and requires that all parties follow Canadian law and cannot take away certain rights, argued Little Salmon/Carmacks lawyer Arthur Pape.

And the duty to consult is a constitutional right of First Nations.

The Crown argued it believed it could act unilaterally and only did the minimum amount of consultation as specified in the agreement, said Pape.

The government ignored requests to hold a meeting with Little Salmon/Carmacks to discuss the land issues.

While only half a per cent of the trapline is being taken up, Johnny Sam will not be allowed to shoot a firearm within one kilometre of Paulsen’s farm.

A firearm is needed to kill animals caught in traps and the trapline’s cabin is caught in this no-shooting zone.

Also, the government has considered the economic effects, but not the cultural significance of the trapline to the First Nation.

Johnny Sam grew up on the trapline and was using it to educate his grandchildren and other children from the community.

“No one asked why they’re so worried,” said Pape.

“There was no curiosity, no engagement and no inquiry — so there was no accommodation.”

If First Nations were told that the agreement contained all of their rights and nothing more, that would be the end of the negotiation process, Pape continued.

“It’s going to lead to a lot of First Nations saying that the treaty is not worth the paper it’s written on.”

Signing of a land claim agreement was equal to full reconciliation between the First Nation government and Canada, said the territory in its rebuttal to Pape’s argument.

Therefore there was no duty to consult.

It would be a “tremendous burden” to have to consult and accommodate the First Nations on each proposal.

“I don’t think that the obligation to consult and sometimes change plans or alter — or even give up plans sometimes — I don’t think that’s a terrible burden,” replied Pape after the case.

“That’s exactly what governs the First Nation and that’s what the agreement, it seems to me, promised everybody.”

Having to consult with First Nations would not cripple the Yukon’s ability to govern, he said.

“It’s hamstringing their ability to govern in a dishonourable way, and if they think that they have a right to govern in a dishonourable way then they’re dangerous and they’re not willing to pay attention to Canada’s Constitution and that’s not proper.

“That’s why we have courts, to sometimes tell governments that they’re going too far.”

Just Posted

Willow Brewster, a paramedic helping in the COVID-19 drive-thru testing centre, holds a swab used for the COVID-19 test moments before using it on Nov. 24. The Yukon government is reopening the drive-thru option on June 18. (Crystal Schick/Yukon News)
Drive-up COVID-19 testing opening June 18 in Whitehorse

The drive-up testing will be open from 6:30 p.m. to 9:30 p.m. everyday and increase testing capacity by 33 spots

A draft plan has been released by the Dawson Regional Use Planning commission on June 15. Julien Gignac/Yukon News
Draft plan released by the Dawson Regional Land Use Planning Commission

Dawson Regional Land Use Commission releases draft plan, Government of Yukon withdraws additional lands from mineral staking in the planning region

Yukonomist Keith Halliday
Yukonomist: Let them live in trailers

“I found Rome a city of bricks and left it a city… Continue reading

X
WYATT’S WORLD

Wyatt’s World for June 18, 2021.… Continue reading

Chief Medical Officer of Health Dr. Brendan Hanley. (Yukon News file)
Yukon logs nine new COVID-19 cases, 54 active cases

More CEMA enforcement officers have been recruited, officials say

Whitehorse City Hall (Yukon News file)
City news, briefly

A look at decisions made by Whitehorse city council at its June 14 meeting

Murray Arsenault sits in the drivers seat of his 1975 Bricklin SV1 in Whitehorse on June 16. (Stephanie Waddell/Yukon News)
Bringing the 1975 Bricklin north

Murray Arsenault remembers his dad’s Bricklin, while now driving his own

A presumptive COVID case was found at Seabridge Gold’s 3 Aces project. (file photo)
Presumptive COVID-19 case reported at mine in southeast Yukon

A rapid antigen rest found a presumptive COVID case on an incoming individual arriving at the 3Aces project

Jonathan Antoine/Cabin Radio
Flooding in Fort Simpson on May 8.
Fort Simpson asked for military help. Two people showed up.

FORT SIMPSON—Residents of a flooded Northwest Territories village expected a helping hand… Continue reading

A woman was rescued from the Pioneer Ridge Trail in Alaska on June 16. (Photo courtesy/AllTrails)
Alaska hiker chased off trail by bears flags down help

ANCHORAGE (AP)—An Alaska hiker who reported needing help following bear encounters on… Continue reading

Two participants cross the finish line at the City of Whitehorse Kids Triathlon on June 12 with Mayor Dan Curtis on hand to present medals. (Stephanie Waddell/Yukon News)
2021 Kids’ Triathlon draws 76 young athletes

Youth ages five to 14 swim, run and bike their way to finish line

NDP MP Mumilaaq Qaqqaq rises in the House of Commons, in Ottawa on May 13, 2021. THE CANADIAN PRESS/Adrian Wyld
‘Unacceptable’ that Inuk MP felt unsafe in House of Commons, Miller says

OTTAWA—It’s a “sad reflection” on Canada that an Inuk MP feels she’s… Continue reading

Lily Witten performs her Canadian Nationals beam routine on June 14. John Tonin/Yukon News
Three Yukon gymnasts break 20-year Nationals absence

Bianca Berko-Malvasio, Maude Molgat and Lily Witten competed at the Canadian Nationals – the first time in 20 years the Yukon’s been represented at the meet

Most Read