Lawyers representing Canada and the Yukon gave arguments Feb. 7 in Whitehorse on a case looking at a residency requirement for Vuntut Gwitchin citizens to serve as councillors for the First Nation. Cindy Dickson filed a petition challenging the provision last year, claiming it violated the Charter of Rights and Freedoms. (Crystal Schick/Yukon News file)

Lawyers for Canada, the Yukon, say Charter should apply in VGFN residency requirement case

Arguments on the petition from Vuntut Gwitchin citizen Cindy Dickson wrapped up on Feb. 7

Lawyers for the Attorney General of Canada and Yukon government gave submissions Feb. 7 in a case examining how the Charter of Rights and Freedoms overlaps with Vuntut Gwitchin First Nation’s laws, if at all.

Marlaine Anderson-Lindsay, representing Canada, and Mark Radke, representing the Yukon, both argued that Yukon Supreme Court Justice Ron Veale should apply the Charter when considering a petition brought by a Vuntut Gwitchin citizen over a residency requirement to serve on council.

Cindy Dickson, who lives in Whitehorse, is challenging a provision in VGFN’s constitution requiring councillors to move to settlement land within 14 days of an election, claiming it violates section 15 of the Charter and should therefore be struck down.

Section 15 guarantees equality rights for Canadian citizens. Dickson’s lawyers argued Feb. 5 that the residency requirement unfairly and arbitrarily excludes more than half of Vuntut Gwitchin citizens from being on council unless they relocate and is a form of intergroup discrimination.

Vuntut Gwitchin’s lawyers responded that the Charter should not be applied and the matter should instead be examined within the context of the Vuntut Gwitchin constitution. Either way, lawyers for the First Nation argued on Feb. 6, the court should find the requirement is a reasonable restriction and tied to VGFN’s history and legal traditions.

Canada and the Yukon are interveners, or interested third parties, in the matter.

The case, no matter the outcome, will set a precedent for how all self-governing Yukon First Nations’ final and self-government agreements are interpreted in the future.

In her submissions Feb. 7, Anderson-Lindsay said Canada recognized the significance of the questions raised by Dickson’s petition.

The application of the Charter in this case is a matter of law and not contract, she argued, referencing VGFN’s argument that it never agreed to the Charter being applicable to its self-government, which is why it’s not named in any agreements.

The Canadian Constitution, which describes itself as the “supreme law of the land” and of which the Charter is a part of, applies to all governments within the nation’s constitutional framework, Anderson-Lindsay continued. She argued it would be hard to see how the Vuntut Gwitchin government wouldn’t be captured by the Charter.

Anderson-Lindsay also argued that previous court cases have found Indigenous legal traditions to be part of Canadian law, and that the agreements from which VGFN’s constitution flows are themselves constitutional documents, making them subject to Charter scrutiny.

Dickson applied for relief under the Charter and not the Vuntut Gwitchin constitution, she noted; while the latter has Charter-like clauses, it does not offer Charter reliefs.

Radke, the Yukon government lawyer, also argued that the Charter applies but for a different reason.

VGFN’s self-government and final agreements, Radke submitted, were not a “codification” of the Vuntut Gwitchin’s inherent self-government rights but a delegation of power from the territorial and federal governments.

Following that view, neither the Yukon nor Canada can transfer authorities without also transferring the responsibilities that come with them, including compliance with the Charter.

The Yukon government’s position, Radke said, is that self-government agreements are part of the legal fabric of the territory. They were not intended to address First Nations’ inherent right to self-government, he argued, with that issue “left for another day.”

While Radke said the Yukon government wasn’t denying that right can exist, he argued VGFN’s constitution was not a manifestation of that right, nor was it meant to stand apart from the Canadian Constitution.

He noted the powers the VGFN holds allows it to make laws and decisions that can impact both its citizens and non-citizens — for example, land-based decisions that have the potential to impact the constitutional rights of anyone entering the land.

Radke added that the Yukon government had concerns about the “uncertainty” that could arise if the court were to find the Charter didn’t apply to self-government agreements.

In her reply submissions, VGFN lawyer Krista Robertson argued that the Vuntut Gwitchin constitution was not a program of the territorial government. The final and self-government agreements, she said, recognize VGFN’s inherent rights and establish a cooperative arrangement of how to coordinate powers — it was not a hand-over.

Dickson’s lawyer, Bridget Gilbride, was also given an opportunity to give a reply.

VGFN placed a large emphasis on leadership selection being an inherent right, she said, but an affidavit it submitted from a former chief showed that the Vuntut Gwitchin didn’t previously vote for chief, and that one chief, Peter Moses, never stayed in Old Crow during his tenure.

That history bears very little resemblence to VGFN’s current residency restriction and democratic vote, she said.

The rights at issue, she said — the right to equality and the right to hold office — are universal democratic rights recognized by the United Nations, Gilbride continued, and not specific or unique to Indigenous peoples.

Gilbride argued that the residency requirement was failing to do what it claims to in regards to protecting and preserving VGFN culture and maintaining the seat of government in Old Crow. Instead, she submitted, it puts citizens who live off settlement land at risk of losing their connection with their community and culture, and led to a councillor seat sitting empty in the 2018 election after Dickson and another person’s nominations were rejected.

VGFN’s other lawyer, Kris Statnyk, gave the final reply.

He argued that VGFN’s right to select leaders has an inherent source, and was not a power it was delegated from Canada or the Yukon, and that Gilbride was inviting the court to have a “frozen rights” approach.

Historically, Statnyk said, a physical, cultural and spiritual connection to the land was essential for Vuntut Gwitchin leaders, something that was decided by Vuntut Gwitchin society. The leadership selection process has since evolved, he said, and argued that the residency requirement was a “modern expression” of Vuntut Gwitchin’s pre-contract right to select leadership.

Yukon Supreme Court Justice Ron Veale reserved his decision.

Contact Jackie Hong at

Vuntut Gwitchin First Nation

Just Posted

The Fireweed Market in Shipyards Park will open on May 13. Joel Krahn/Yukon News
Whitehorse’s Fireweed Market opens May 13

The Fireweed Market will return with ‘exciting’ new and returning vendors

Ron Rousseau holds a sign saying ‘It’s time for a cultural shift’ during the Yukoners: Raise Your Voice Against Misogyny rally on May 11. (John Tonin/Yukon News)
Protest held to condemn Yukon Party MLAs’ texts

A rally was held outside of legislature to condemn the inappropriate texts messages of Yukon Party MLAs Stacey Hassard and Wade Istchenko.


Wyatt’s World for May 12, 2021.… Continue reading

Health Minister Tracy-Anne McPhee and Chief Medical Officer Dr. Brendan Hanley announced youth vaccination clinics planned for this summer. (Alistair Maitland/Yukon government file)
Vaccination campaign planned for Yukon youth age 12 and up

The Pfizer vaccine was approved for younger people on May 5.

Chief Medical Officer of Health Dr. Brendan Hanley announced two new cases of COVID-19 on May 11. (Crystal Schick/Yukon News file)
Two new cases of COVID-19 reported, one in the Yukon and one Outside

One person is self-isolating, the other will remain Outside until non-infectious

Neil Hartling, the Tourism Industry Association of the Yukon president, left, said the new self-isolation guidelines for the Yukon are a ‘ray of hope’ for tourism operators. (Ian Stewart/Yukon News file)
Yukon tourism operators prepared for ‘very poor summer’ even with relaxed border rules

Toursim industry responds to new guidelines allowing fully vaccinated individuals to skip mandatory self-isolation.

A lawsuit has been filed detailing the resignation of a former Yukon government mine engineer. (Joel Krahn/Yukon News file)
A year after resigning, former chief mine engineer sues Yukon government

Paul Christman alleges a hostile work environment and circumvention of his authority led him to quit

Former Liberal MLA Pauline Frost speaks to reporters outside the courthouse on April 19. One of the voters accused of casting an invalid vote has been granted intervenor status in the lawsuit Frost filed last month. (Haley Ritchie/Yukon News)
Voters named in Pauline Frost election lawsuit ask to join court proceedings

The judge granted Christopher Schafer intervenor status

Haley Ritchie/Yukon News file
File photo of the legislative assembly. The previous spring sitting began on March 4 but was interrupted due to the election.
Throne speech kicks off short spring legislature sitting

The government will now need to pass the budget.

The deceased man, found in Lake LaBerge in 2016, had on three layers of clothing, Dakato work boots, and had a sheathed knife on his belt. Photo courtesy Yukon RCMP
RCMP, Coroner’s Office seek public assistance in identifying a deceased man

The Yukon RCMP Historical Case Unit and the Yukon Coroner’s Office are looking for public help to identify a man who was found dead in Lake LaBerge in May 2016.

Yukon Zinc’s Wolverine minesite has created a mess left to taxpayers to clean up, Lewis Rifkind argues. This file shot shows the mine in 2009. (John Thompson/Yukon News file)
Editorial: The cost of the Wolverine minesite

Lewis Rifkind Special to the News The price of a decent wolverine… Continue reading

Letters to the editor.
Today’s mailbox: border opening and Yukon Party texts

Dear Premier Sandy Silver and Dr Hanley, Once again I’m disheartened and… Continue reading

Fire chief Jason Everett (Crystal Schick/Yukon News file)
City launches emergency alert system

The city is calling on residents and visitors to register for Whitehorse Alert

Most Read