Judge halts McLean Lake development

The McLean Lake Residents’ Association is lauding a recent Supreme Court judgment that stopped a quarry and cement batch plant from setting up…

The McLean Lake Residents’ Association is lauding a recent Supreme Court judgment that stopped a quarry and cement batch plant from setting up near Sleeping Giant Hill.

“We’re pleased with the outcome,” said association president Skeeter Miller-Wright on Wednesday.

Justice Ron Veale found that a city bylaw allowing the cement batch plant in the McLean Lake area was invalid.

“There is no authorization to proceed with the McLean Lake quarry development at this time,” Veale said in his 31-page judgment, which was publicly released Tuesday.

The case was brought before the courts last month by the McLean Lake Residents’ Association, which is opposed to the batch plant.

Both the territory and the city governments defended their decision to allow the development.

Veale found that the Yukon government acted reasonably in its decision and met its responsibility.

However, the city didn’t fare so well.

Veale found that hydrological and hydrogeological testing should have been done prior to passing the bylaw.

In the city’s Official Community Plan, there is a specific policy for dealing with gravel extraction in the McLean Lake area.

The policy states that water testing should be done prior to further gravel extraction.

There are no “vague words,” the testing is “mandatory,” Veale said in his judgment.

Whitehorse Mayor Bev Buckway is taking the judgment in stride.

“I don’t view that as a big negative decision,” Buckway said after city council’s meeting on Tuesday.

“Obviously Justice Veale has reviewed the case carefully.

“There are a number of items in the document that he was supportive of and, of course, there was one that he wasn’t supportive of.”

City council did not receive a copy of the judgment until Tuesday evening so it had not had a chance to discuss it, said Buckway.

However, council will continue to work on the issue, given the work the developer has done so far.

“I would assume that that would be the mode to go. Try to get the study done and find out if everything is OK.

“And if it’s not OK then we want to know that too.

“It was never our intent to do something that was harmful,” she added.

Council believed there was no need for a hydrological study, due to the fact that the operation didn’t need a water licence.

Veale disagreed.

Council and city management will meet on Wednesday to determine how to proceed.

“Now it’s in the city’s hands,” said Miller-Wright.

“If they decide they still want to develop the site they’ll have to get the water work done.”

Normally the developer pays for the expensive water testing, he said.

“They didn’t respond to public pressure, now we’ll see how they respond to judicial pressure.

“It will be interesting to see how they handle this.”

Meanwhile, the McLean Lake Residents’ Association will continue to oppose development of the site.

The area should be protected as a recreational site, similar to the one around Chadburn Lake, said Miller-Wright.

Maintaining a pristine area near to the city’s centre is very important, he said.

The idea was always on the backburner, but stopping the development was the first priority.

“The bylaw has been quashed. Now we can start to develop the idea of protecting the area for recreational and esthetic purposes.”

Get local stories you won't find anywhere else right to your inbox.
Sign up here

Just Posted

Arrest made in 2019 Ross River murder

Phillip Atkinson, 63, has been charged with first-degree murder in the death of Mary Ann Ollie

Brother of slain Carmacks man wants review of Yukon justice system

Lennie Charlie’s brother, Wilfred “Dickie” Charlie, was killed by Mario and Tyler Skookum in 2017

Council turns down zoning amendment

Property owners will not be permitted to add a suite to their RR-zoned home

Tr’ondëk Hwëch’in issues voluntary closure on fall chum fishing

The closure comes during the worst fall chum run on record

Yukon government will fund one type of glucose monitors for adults

The Yukon T1D Support Network says coverage needs to go further

Lawsuit against Freedom Trails settled

The suit was dismissed with consent of all parties

Tank farm takes another step towards development

OCP designation passes second reading

Climate change strategy targets 30 per cent reduction in territory greenhouse gases by 2030

The strategy includes rebates for electric vehicles but puts off mining targets for two years

Watson Lake to hold mayoral byelection

Residents of Watson Lake will elect a new mayor on Oct. 8.… Continue reading

Teslin Tlingit Council elects chief, deputy chief

Teslin Tlingit Council citizens have elected Eric Morris as the new Naa Sháade Háni

Yukon Party nominates Dixon for Copperbelt North

The new leader was previously the MLA for the riding

Teslin Tlingit Council to hold election

Election day is Sept. 15, 2020

City hall, briefly

A look at decisions made by Whitehorse city council this week

Most Read