Health survey was illegal: ombudsman

It may be illegal, but it worked. That's the reaction by the Department of Health and Social Services to a scolding it received from Yukon's ombudsman for violating privacy laws.

It may be illegal, but it worked.

That’s the reaction by the Department of Health and Social Services to a scolding it received from Yukon’s ombudsman for violating privacy laws.

The controversy involves a Health Department survey sent to Yukoners this summer. It warned, “If you do not sign and return this card your health care could be cancelled.”

Some residents took this as a threat. “This undermined the voluntary nature of the survey,” wrote Yukon ombudsman Tracy-Anne McPhee in a report released this week.

It wasn’t an empty threat, either. The Health department took the names of approximately 300 nonrespondents and cancelled their health insurance, without notice, if they had not filed a temporary absence form, a change of address form or visited a health-care professional in the past year.

The results were “somewhat absurd,” McPhee found. Some Yukoners may have had their health insurance yanked for no other reason than their refusal to return a voluntary survey, she noted.

Health’s defence? “To their knowledge no one who was entitled to insurance was actually denied health care and only a small group of people were inconvenienced by having to … provide evidence of Yukon residency and have their health-care insurance reinstated.”

But “this is missing the point,” wrote McPhee. “Cancellation of health-care insurance is not an available penalty for failing to respond to a voluntary survey.”

The Health Department took these measures to weed out one-time Yukoners who no longer live in the territory, but still use Yukon’s plush extended medical care to obtain cheaper drugs.

That’s an expense that Yukon’s cash-strapped Health Department cannot afford, said Health spokesperson Pat Living. “The well is not bottomless.”

Health officials had good reason to suspect freeloaders exist: the number of people on the health-care insurance registry outnumbers Yukon’s population by up to 2,000 people, said Living.

The department had conducted similar surveys over the past decade, but received few responses. While the warning on the survey may have angered some residents, it was also effective in boosting the number of responses.

McPhee concluded the survey ran afoul of the law in two ways. First, the Health Department and statistics bureau lacked a modern data-sharing agreement, as required under the Access to Information and Protection of Privacy Act.

Such an agreement does exist, said Living. But it predates Yukon’s privacy laws.

Second, the survey should have given recipients the option of objecting to sharing their personal information with the Health Department, said McPhee. Health will comply with all of McPhee’s recommendations, said Living.

The department still hasn’t settled on what next summer’s survey will look like.

Contact John Thompson at

Just Posted

No licenses for private pot sales until zoning is approved

The earliest the City of Whitehorse could approve pot shop zoning is April 8


Wyatt’s World

Yukoners react to the Many Rivers layoffs

‘I need help right now’

Yukon poet channels his downtown flirt

“There’s something to be said for getting out of your comfort zone.”

Contractor seeks miners lien against Minto mine owner, claiming $3M in unpaid bills

Dumas Contracting Ltd. claims that Minto Explorations Ltd. owes it more than $3 million

Commentary: What will the carbon tax mean for non-profits?

Hannah Zimmering, Bill Thomas & Charlotte Hrenchuk On behalf of members of… Continue reading

2019 Yukon Quest ends with finish banquet in Fairbanks, Alaska

“It’s a very strange up and down in this race. An extremely emotional cocktail to go with this race.”

German rookie wins 2019 Yukon Quest red lantern

Hendrik Stachnau was the last musher to cross the finish line

Hospital workers are prepared to strike

‘They’ve had enough’

Whitehorse mayor calls tax and fee increases reasonable

Council approved the 2019 operations budget

Team Yukon attends pep rally before heading off to Canada Winter Games

The Games are taking place in Red Deer, Alta., from Feb. 15 to March 3.

How should you pay for your new vehicle?

There are two main ways to finance your vehicle: purchase financing andleasing.

This year’s Sima Cup medals were delicious

A local bakery provided the prizes

Most Read