Harsher punishment for harsher youth

Yukon's Child and Youth Advocate says Ottawa's proposed changes to the Youth Criminal Justice Act are inappropriate.

Yukon’s Child and Youth Advocate says Ottawa’s proposed changes to the Youth Criminal Justice Act are inappropriate.

Under the proposed Bill C-4, youth as young as 14 who commit serious crimes could face the same punishments as adults.

But the new legislation ignores mental health, said Andy Nieman, who was in Ottawa this week presenting his concerns alongside other youth advocates.

“There is no focus on mental health treatment or diagnosis in the Yukon for youth,” said Nieman. “Bill C-4 will just paint everyone with the same brush.

“Youth with FASD will be treated the same as people that have no mental illness, and that is not appropriate or fair.”

The Youth Criminal Justice Act, as it stands now, has more focus on rehabilitation and reintegration of young offenders, said Nieman.

“And it also speaks to assisting those who have mental health illness and issues instead of just warehousing them,” he said.

“Basically, Bill C-4 wants to introduce amendments that would simply be focused more on punishment, deterrents and denunciation,” he said. “It will be a mini-system of the adult system and we feel that’s an infringement on the rights of the youth in situations that are going to affect them in a very detrimental way.”

Changes to the Youth Criminal Justice Act have been coming for a while.

In December 2006, Justice Merlin Nunn, from Nova Scotia, released a review of the act with 34 recommendations.

He covered many things, including a new definition of “violent offence.”

Nunn’s recommendations were widely accepted in the legal world.

When the act came under review, the Liberals insisted the government accept Nunn’s report almost entirely, said Larry Bagnell, Yukon’s MP.

But Bill C-4 “would go far beyond Justice Nunn’s recommendations,” according to the Canadian Bar Association’s review of the bill in June 2010.

The proposed bill is so extreme, even Nunn rejects it.

The bar association’s report quotes an interview Nunn gave to the Canadian Press.

“There’s no evidence anywhere in North America, that I know of, that keeping people in custody longer, punishing them longer, has any fruitful effects for society. Custody should be the last-ditch thing for a child.”

But Bagnell is confident his party would support the bill if it returns to the House as it is now, even with its lack of address to root causes of crime or rehabilitation, he said.

“There are some good things in the bill that are needed,” said Bagnell, mentioning its prohibition of imprisoning young offenders in adult facilities. “It’s easier to talk about the good things because there are not as many of them.”

“Fortunately, I don’t think it mandates the longer and harsher sentencing. It gives the justices the option of it, but we have more faith in our judges that they will understand.”

Nieman doesn’t share that faith.

“We know that the courts are overcrowded across Canada,” he said.

“Another fear is that undiagnosed and untreated youth will simply be warehoused and punished without getting the treatment that they need. It would simply be a warehouse punishment.”

Identifying, diagnosing and treating people with mental illness at an early age as possible should be the goal, said Nieman – even before they come into conflict with the law.

“When we diagnose it and treat it at an early age, it’s going to save society millions and save people a lot of heartache instead of just warehousing them and perpetuating the situation and leaving them untreated. That’s just going to create a bigger problem down the road.”

Bill C-4 has undergone second reading and is currently in committee.

It has a long way to go, and with an election expected in the spring, its future is even more uncertain, said Bagnell.

Contact Roxanne Stasyszyn at


Just Posted

Northwestel says it is investigating into the cause of the total communications blackout throughout the territory after a power failure in Whitehorse on Wednesday night.
Internet outage prompts criticism on Dempster fibre project delays

The Liberals responded that they have proceeded cautiously to avoid high costs.

A motorcycle with driver pulled over on the right side of the North Klondike Highway whose speed was locked in at 171 kilometres per hour. (Courtesy/Yukon RCMP)
Patrols of Yukon highways find poorly-secured loads, intoxicated drivers

The ongoing patrols which police call ‘Operation Cooridor’ is mainly focused on commercial vehicles.

Awaken Festival organizers Meredith Pritchard, Colin Wolf, Martin Nishikawa inside the Old Firehall in Whitehorse on May 11. (Haley Ritchie/Yukon News)
Performing arts fest plans to awaken artistic talent in Whitehorse and the rural North

‘A value of ours is to make theatre as accessible as possible.’

April Mikkelsen tosses a disc during a ladies only disc golf tournament at Solstice DiscGolfPark on May 8. John Tonin/Yukon News
Yukon sees its first-ever women’s disc golf tournament

The Professional Disc Golf Assocation had a global women’s event last weekend. In the Yukon, a women’s only tournament was held for the first time ever.

Dave Blottner, executive director at the Whitehorse Food Bank, said the food bank upped its services because of the pandemic. (John Tonin/Yukon News)
Food Bank sees Yukoners’ generosity firsthand

“Businesses didn’t know if they could stay open but they were calling us to make sure we were able to stay open.”

More than 25,000 people have received the firsdt dose of the vaccine, according to the Yukon government. (Black Press file)
Yukon has now vaccinated 76 per cent of eligible adults

The territory has surpassed its goal of 75 per cent as a first step toward ‘herd immunity’

A prescribed burn is seen from the lookout at Range Road and Whistle Bend Way in Whitehorse May 12. (Stephanie Waddell/Yukon News)
Editorial: Are you ready for a forest fire?

Citizens for a Firesmart Whitehorse have listed some steps for Yukoners to boost safety and awareness

Caribou pass through the Dempster Highway area in their annual migration. A recent decision by the privacy commissioner has recommended the release of some caribou collar re-location data. (Justin Kennedy/Yukon News)
Privacy commissioner recommends release of caribou location data

Department of Environment says consultation with its partners needed before it will consider release

Chief Medical Officer of Health Dr. Brendan Hanley. (Crystal Schick/Yukon News)
Family pleased youth will be able to get Pfizer vaccine

Angela Drainville, mother of two, is anxious for a rollout plan to come forward

Safe at home office in Whitehorse on May 10, 2021. (John Tonin/Yukon News)
Federal government provides $1.6 million for Yukon anti-homelessness work

Projects including five mobile homes for small communities received funding.

Drilling at Northern Tiger’s 3Ace gold project in 2011. Randi Newton argues that mining in the territory can be reshaped. (Yukon government/file)
Editorial: There’s momentum for mining reform

CPAWS’ Randi Newton argues that the territory’s mining legislations need a substantial overhaul

At its May 10 meeting, Whitehorse city council approved the subdivision for the Kwanlin Dün First Nation’s business park planned in Marwell. (Submitted)
KDFN business park subdivision approved

Will mean more commercial industrial land available in Whitehorse

Most Read