Hands free driving case back in front of a judge

The argument over what constitutes “hands-free” driving in the Yukon continues.

The argument over what constitutes “hands-free” driving in the Yukon continues.

The case of Ian Pumphrey and his $287 ticket was appealed to the Yukon Supreme Court yesterday.

In January a Yukon territorial court judge threw out Pumphrey’s ticket saying that, since the Yukon didn’t have the necessary regulations in place, his unique set of circumstances meant there was reasonable doubt.

Pumphrey insists that he pulled over and stopped to answer the phone, put in on speaker mode and then tucked it behind his ear before he started driving again.

Territorial court judge Donald Luther encouraged the Yukon government to create the regulations to close the loophole.

Instead, the government appealed the decision.

In court yesterday, government lawyer Karen Wenckebach told Supreme Court Justice Leigh Gower that the court should look at the ordinary meaning of “hands-free.” She argued that it was “absurd” to think that someone would consider something being used between your shoulder and your ear as being “hands-free.”

Pumphrey, who is representing himself in court, countered that the whole appeal was ridiculous.

He said it was not good governance to appeal something as small as a traffic ticket instead of just fixing the problem with regulations.

There “seems to be a culture in this government to appeal any decision that goes against its wishes,” he said, pointing to cases involving the Peel watershed and the Ross River Dena Council.

“Now it’s come down to summary conviction tickets.”

Pumphrey asked the judge to order the government to pay him up to up to $7,200 in costs for the time he has spent working on the case.

Gower reserved his decision.

Just Posted

What’s the deal with airline food? Yukon Comedy Festival aims to find out

‘We’re trying to give them the most Yukon experience ever’

Broken elevator means mobility nightmare for Whitehorse seniors

Elevator in Closeleigh Manor has been out of service three times in the last year

All 150 Whistle Bend continuing care beds slated to open this fall

Specialized units to open in 2019 and 2020, but for now all the beds will be for continuing care: YG

Taxi driver charged in Salvation Army hit-and-run

Police have formally laid charges against a taxi driver accused in a… Continue reading

Man pleads guilty to manslaughter in 2016 Pelly Crossing death

A man charged with second-degree murder in the 2016 death of 18-year-old… Continue reading

Yukon investor fumes after Victoria Gold issues new shares

250 million shares part of deal to finance construction, CEO says

Porter Creek group home gets final go-ahead from City of Whitehorse

‘In order for youth to be successful, they need to have life skills’

Mayo, Yukon, DJ Dustin Miles bound for festival in Norway in April

‘It’s not like playing Arts in the Park in Mayo, you know?’

Whitehorse city council approves Porter Creek group home

Concerns about crime, noise and consultation overblown, councillors say

I’m Fur Real offers platform for artisans to sell their work

‘There’s nothing better than buying something from the person who made it’

Most Read