Government to appeal Ross River ruling

The Yukon government is hoping that the Supreme Court of Canada will hear its appeal of a court ruling that called into question the way mineral claims are staked on the traditional lands of unsigned First Nations.

The Yukon government is hoping that the Supreme Court of Canada will hear its appeal of a court ruling that called into question the way mineral claims are staked on the traditional lands of unsigned First Nations.

Last December the Yukon Court of Appeal ruled that the government had a duty to consult with First Nations before a mineral claim was staked.

Under the current legislation, anyone can stake a claim in the territory. And once the claim is registered with the mining recorder, the holder of the claim has the right to carry out Class 1 exploration work. That includes things like clearing trees, building trails, digging up rock and even the use of explosives.

The Ross River Dena Council brought a suit against the Yukon government in 2011, arguing that the status quo was a violation of its aboriginal rights.

It lost the case initially but won on appeal.

The Yukon Court of Appeal found that “(w)hile Class 1 exploration programs are limited, they may still seriously impede or prevent the enjoyment of some aboriginal rights in more than a transient or trivial manner.”

In making its ruling the three-judge appeals court made two declarations.

The first was that the territory has a duty to consult with unsigned First Nations about where staking can take place within their traditional territories. The second was that the government has an obligation to notify – and where appropriate – consult and accommodate First Nations before any mining or exploration activities can take place.

The court suspended its declarations for a year, giving the territory time to make the necessary legislative changes.

The Yukon government has accepted the requirement to consult with First Nations before exploration activity can take place and is working with both industry and First Nations governments on how to incorporate consultation into the Quartz Mining Act, said Premier Darrell Pasloski.

But it has applied for leave to appeal the first declaration with the Supreme Court of Canada.

“We want to know exactly what the rules are around consultation, around the whole issue of mineral staking,” said Pasloski. “This is a significant issue and not only affects the Yukon but there’s interest in almost all the jurisdictions across the country on this.”

Getting the high court to hear a case is a two-part process.

First the government has to ask the court’s permission by filing a leave to appeal, which it did this week.

Only if the court accepts that application will the case move forward.

The vast majority of those cases never make it past that stage, but Ken Coates, a Canadian historian who studies the history of the North and First Nations rights, said he thinks this case has a fairly good chance of being heard by the court.

“I’m not surprised that the Yukon government is taking it to court and I wouldn’t be surprised if the Supreme Court decided to hear it as well,” he said. “If they don’t, then it kind of stands as law rather untested in the sense that it hasn’t gone to the Supreme Court and so there would be a question in other parts of the country whether that same ruling would apply.”

Most of the Yukon’s First Nations are covered by modern treaties, but there are still two, the Kaska – which includes both the Ross River Dena and Liard First Nation – and the White River First Nation, that don’t have an agreement with the territorial government.

All told, their unsettled land claims span 122,230 square kilometres of the territory.

The Yukon is hardly the only jurisdiction where there are unsettled First Nations land claims.

Many parts of the country have either no treaties – as is the case in most of B.C.- or very old treaties which don’t deal with issues like land surrender, said Coates.

“Northern Saskatchewan, which is the most active mining jurisdiction in the country right now, has old treaties rather than new ones – 1870s up to the early part of the 20th century,” he said.

There is nothing in those older treaties that deal with the government’s duty to consult with First Nations, because at the time that legal obligation didn’t exist and no one was thinking about large-scale resource development, said Coates.

But they are now.

“There’s no question that the rest of the country will watch this very closely to see what happens with this court case.”

The Supreme Court isn’t expected to make a ruling on the government’s application for several months.

If the court allows it to move forward, the entire process is likely to take 18 months to two years before it is resolved, said Thomas Ullyett, the assistant deputy minister for the Department of Justice.

Contact Josh Kerr at

joshk@yukon-news.com

Get local stories you won't find anywhere else right to your inbox.
Sign up here

Just Posted

Yukonomist Keith Halliday
Yukonomist: Yukon Budget 2.0

If the banks that finance the Yukon’s growing debt were the only… Continue reading

Yukon Supreme Court Chief Justice Suzanne Duncan dismissed an application on May 3 seeking more transparity on the territory’s state of emergency declaration. (Joel Krahn/Yukon News file)
Supreme Court rules confidential memo can’t be used in challenge of state of emergency

Court upholds cabinet confidentiality after request to use internal government memo as evidence.

XX
WYATT’S WORLD

Wyatt’s World for May 7, 2021.… Continue reading

Yukon Party MLAs Wade Istchenko and Stacey Hassard are facing criticism for crude text messages in a group chat. (Submitted)
First Nations leaders call for stricter punishment of Yukon Party MLAs

Queer Yukon has also criticized the two individuals involved in an inappropriate group chat

Fire chief Jason Everett (Crystal Schick/Yukon News file)
City launches emergency alert system

The city is calling on residents and visitors to register for Whitehorse Alert

Two young orienteers reach their first checkpoint near Shipyards Park during a Yukon Orienteering Association sprint race May 5. (John Tonin/Yukon News)
Orienteers were back in action for the season’s first race

The Yukon Orienteering Association began its 2021 season with a sprint race beginning at Shipyards.

Whitehorse City Hall (Yukon News file)
City news, briefly

A look at issues discussed by Whitehorse city council at its May 3 meeting and the upcoming 20-minute makeover.

Deputy Prime Minister Chrystia Freeland met with MP Larry Bagnell and representatives from the Tourism Industry Association via Zoom on May 4. (Facebook)
Deputy Prime Minister Chrystia Freeland met with MP Larry Bagnell and representatives from the Tourism Industry Association via Zoom on May 4. (Facebook)
Deputy Prime Minister talks tourism in “virtual visit” to the Yukon

Tourism operators discussed the budget with Freeland

Polarity Brewing is giving people extra incentive to get their COVID vaccine by offering a ‘free beer’ within 24 hours of their first shot. John Tonin/Yukon News
Polarity Brewing giving out ‘free’ beer with first COVID vaccination

Within 24 hours of receiving your first COVID-19 vaccine, Polarity Brewing will give you a beer.

A Yukon government sign is posted to one of the trees that have been brought down for the sewer project in Riverdale explaining the project. The area is set to be revegetated with grass when it is complete. (Stephanie Waddell/Yukon News)
Planned stormsewer outfall will improve drainage on Selkirk Street

Resident raises concern over clearing as council considers agreement.

The Yukon Wildlife Preserve’s baby bison, born April 22, mingles with the herd on April 29. (John Tonin/Yukon News)
Yukon Wildlife Preserves welcomes two bison calves

A bison calf was the first 2021 baby born at the Yukon Wildlife Preserve

A map provided by the Yukon government shows the location of unpermitted logging leading to a $2,500 fine. (Courtesy/Yukon government)
Man fined $2,500 for felling trees near Beaver Creek

The incident was investigated by natural resource officers and brought to court.

Most Read