First Nation helps judge see problem with mining system

The Yukon Supreme Court has declared the territory is obliged to consult with the Ross River Dena Council about mining exploration in its traditional territory after mining claims are granted.

The Yukon Supreme Court has declared the territory is obliged to consult with the Ross River Dena Council about mining exploration in its traditional territory after mining claims are granted.

It wasn’t exactly what the First Nation applied to the court for. It was hoping for a declaration the duty to consult must be fulfilled before the claims are issued.

But after the claim is granted, the First Nation can determine the potential impact exploration might have while giving some security to the claim holder, wrote Justice Ron Veale in his decision.

And the duty to consult about new exploration can be satisfied by simply giving the First Nation the government’s monthly report from the mining recorder, wrote Veale.

But after reviewing the whole process of recording and issuing mining claims, and considering exploration has met unprecedented levels over the past two years, Veale questioned the government’s ability to monitor the work going on in the territory.

A major reason for his declaration that consultation doesn’t need to happen until after a mining claim has been issued is because the government doesn’t find out about the claim until then.

When the mining recorder records a mining claim, it is the first record the government has. There is no notice or permit required for exploration work. And the Yukon Environmental and Socio-Economic Assessment Board doesn’t need an application until exploration is past the initial first stage.

Veale also reviewed three agreements signed between the territory and the Kaska Nations, which includes the Ross River Dena Council and the Liard First Nation.

One, which was in effect from March 2003 until August 2005, said the territory will “not agree to any significant or major dispositions of interest in lands or resources or significant or major authorizations for exploration work and resource development in Kaska traditional territory without consulting and obtaining the consent of the Kaska.”

The agreement led to changes in the Quartz Mining Act forms, which now notify people wishing to record a claim in Kaska traditional territory that the lands “are subject to unsettled aboriginal land claims.”

All three agreements between the Kaska and the territory acknowledge the aboriginal group asserts rights and claims in the area.

The clarification in Veale’s decision was that, as territorial counsel argued, the agreements don’t acknowledge the Kaska have established those aboriginal rights and claims, just that they assert that they have them.

The Kaska constitute two of three Yukon First Nations that have not settled a land claim or signed a self-government and final agreement.

Negotiations began with Canada in 1996. In 1999, the Liard First Nation and the Ross River Dena Council requested they negotiate at the same table, to sign a single, Kaska agreement or two separate but very similar agreements. But in June of 2002, Canada’s mandate to negotiate expired and, when a formal offer to settle was turned down, negotiations ended.

Because of these earlier negotiations, eight per cent of the Ross River Dena Council’s traditional territory is in withdrawal from staking until March 31, 2013, wrote Veale.

Despite that, out of 226,961 quartz mining claims in good standing in the territory, there are 8,633 active in the First Nation’s traditional territory, covering 14 per cent of that area, the decision said.

In total, the Ross River Dena Council’s traditional territory makes up 13 per cent of the territory, or 63,110 square kilometres, which is roughly the same size of Latvia or Lithuania, the decision continued.

Kaska traditional territory represents 23 per cent of the Yukon and encompasses one out of three operating mines in the territory.

Veale’s decision also notes from January 2011 to the end of June, the number of quartz mining claims in good standing in the Yukon has increased by 68,542.

Exploration program costs in that same time have increased by about $100 million, the decision said.

Contact Roxanne Stasyszyn at

Just Posted

Driver files lawsuit over fire truck crash

Lisa Gallant-McRobb filed a statement of claim related to the Jan. 22 crash late last month

Without hemodialysis option, Yukon man returns home to die

Terry Coventry said he hopes the Yukon government will consider offering hemodialysis in the future


Wyatt’s World

Porter Creek Rams ride strong first quarter to boys Super Hoops win against F.H. Collins Warriors

After two days of competition, the F.H. Collins Warriors are 0-2 in boys play and 2-0 in girls play

Yukon officials issue warning after three fentanyl deaths last month

There were also a handful of overdoses that did not result in deaths

Commentary: Yukon firearm owners need a voice in Ottawa

Are Yukoners being effectively represented in Ottawa?

Toonie Tournament raises food and funds for Whitehorse Food Bank

“It was more about getting the kids out playing soccer and fundraising for the food bank”

Dahria Beatty wins bronze at Opa Cup cross-country skiing race in Slovenia

Whitehorse’s Emily Nishikawa was 10th in the 10-km race

RCMP asks B.C. cannabis shop to remove image of Sam Steele

Owner happy to comply with RCMP, but wants more information first

Team Yukon narrowly misses out on podium at Canadian Curling Club Championships

In both men’s and women’s competition, Team Yukon finished fourth

EDITORIAL: Time for the Yukon Party’s opening act

Having a competitive leadership race could be good for the party

City news, briefly

Some of the news from the Dec. 2 Whitehorse city council meeting

Arctic Sports Inter-School Championship draws athletes from as far as Juneau

The three-day event included more than 300 participants from kindergarten to Grade 12

Most Read