The Charter of Rights and Freedoms applies to Vuntut Gwitchin First Nation’s government, Yukon Supreme Court Justice Ron Veale ruled, but its requirement for chief and council to reside on settlement lands doesn’t discriminate against citizens living outside Old Crow. (Crystal Schick/Yukon News file)

Charter applies to Vuntut Gwitchin, residency requirement not discriminatory, Yukon judge rules

Justice Ron Veale described case as “complex,” with “many cultural, political and legal ramifications”

The Charter of Rights and Freedoms applies to Vuntut Gwitchin First Nation’s government, a Yukon judge has ruled, but its requirement for chief and council to reside on settlement lands doesn’t discriminate against citizens living outside Old Crow.

Yukon Supreme Court Justice Ron Veale issued a 72-page decision on what he described as “a complex case with many cultural, political and legal ramifications” on June 8.

The decision is the first of its kind in the legal history of Yukon First Nations’ final and self-government agreements, setting a precedent that’s likely to impact all self-governing Yukon First Nations.

It was sparked by the filing of a petition in early 2019 by Vuntut Gwitchin citizen and Whitehorse resident Cindy Dickson.

Dickson had tried to run for a councillor position in Vuntut Gwitchin’s 2018 election but had her nomination forms rejected due to the fact that she didn’t live on settlement land, then a requirement for all candidates under the Vuntut Gwitchin constitution.

That residency requirement has since been amended to state that anyone elected to council must relocate to settlement lands within 14 days.

Old Crow is the only permanent community on Vuntut Gwitchin settlement lands.

The petition was heard in court in February.

Dickson’s lawyers argued that the residency requirement violated section 15 of the Charter, which guarantees equality rights to all Canadians. Dickson, they said, was more than qualified to run for council, noting her deep connections with her heritage as well as her work and education. Moving to Old Crow would be impractical for her, they said, and she would have inadequate housing and access to education and medical care for her son, among other things.

About 260 Vuntut Gwitchin citizens live in Old Crow, Dickson’s lawyers noted, while 301 lived elsewhere — it was only fair, they argued, for those citizens to have representation on council too.

Lawyers representing Vuntut Gwitchin claimed that the issue was “purely political,” and one that shouldn’t be heard by the court. The Charter, they argued, doesn’t apply to the Vuntut Gwitchin government as it was never consented to during negotiations, and the Vuntut Gwitchin have, and have always had, the right to determine how to govern themselves according to traditional practices.

Both sides filed affidavits from Vuntut Gwitchin citizens supporting either the preservation or removal of the residency requirement.

In his decision, Veale found that the Charter does apply to Vuntut Gwitchin governance. He noted that the Vuntut Gwitchin final agreement states the agreement “shall not affect the rights of Yukon Indian People as Canadian Citizens,” and that nothing in either the final or self-government agreements “explicitly states that the Charter does not apply to the VGFN Government.”

The Vuntut Gwitchin government, Veale wrote, is also captured by a section in the Charter which declares that all bodies acting as a government or “exercising inherently ‘government’ activities” fall within the Charter’s scope.

He found, however, that Vuntut Gwitchin’s “residency requirement as a general principle, is not discriminatory for a number of reasons.” The requirement, he explained, doesn’t deny citizens the right to vote, nor the right to run for the position of chief or councillor.

He noted elsewhere in the decision that since “time immemorial to the present day, all VGFN Chiefs and Councillors have been residents in the VGFN Traditional Territory.”

“The evidence is that all VGFN citizens have suffered displacement and alienation from imposed colonial laws, residential school and resource development without the consent or involvement of VGFN citizens,” Veale wrote. “The purpose and effect of the residency requirement is to enhance the homeland and preserve it for all VGFN citizens…

“… (The) residency requirement is not an infringement of Ms. Dickson’s equality right but recognition of the role of non-residents VGFN citizens in their homeland. The residency requirement does not discriminate but ensures a role that respects rather than denigrates the rights of non-resident VGFN citizens.”

Even if the residency requirement violated Dickson’s equality rights, Veale wrote, it would be “shielded” by another part of the Charter protecting Aboriginal and treaty rights.

Veale did, though, strike down the portion of the requirement that calls for elected councillors to move to settlement land within 14 days, declaring that it “arguably creates a disadvantage in that it imposes an arbitrary disenfranchisement… of a successful candidate who was unable to find housing or could not relocate in such a short time frame.”

He suspended the invalidity of the “within 14 days” part for 18 months “to permit the VGFN General Assembly to review the residency requirement to determine if they wish to amend it.”

In an emailed statement June 9, Vuntut Gwitchin Chief Dana Tizya-Tramm highlighted Veale’s finding the residency requirement does not discriminate against non-resident citizens but “ensures a role that respects rather than denigrates the rights of non-resident VGFN citizens.”

“This is a significant finding that protects the residency requirement as a contemporary exercise of our inherent right to self-government and upholds the sacred relationship between our homelands and community governance that has been maintained under Vuntut Gwitchin law with the guidance of our Elders for millennia,” Tizya-Tramm wrote.

The decision, however, also raises “broader issues” about the Charter and its application to “the exercise of the inherent right to self-government.”

“These issues extend far beyond the scope of our residency requirement and are of regional and national significance … We are carefully reviewing the decision in its entirety and will be thoroughly considering all of our options before determining any next steps,” he said.

Dickson, in an email June 10, said she was “disappointed with some parts of the decision” but declined to comment further, explaining that she was still reviewing the document.

Contact Jackie Hong at jackie.hong@yukon-news.com

Vuntut Gwitchin First Nation

Get local stories you won't find anywhere else right to your inbox.
Sign up here

Just Posted

Dawson the dog sits next to the Chariot Patrick Jackson has loaded and rigged up to walk the Dempster Highway from where it begins, off the North Klondike Highway, to the Arctic Circle. (Submitted)
Walking the Dempster

Patrick Jackson gets set for 405-kilometre journey

Liberal leader Sandy Silver speaks outside his campaign headquarters in Dawson City following early poll results on April 12. (Robin Sharp/Yukon News)
BREAKING: Minority government results will wait on tie vote in Vuntut Gwitchin

The Yukon Party and the Liberal Party currently have secured the same amount of seats

Yukonomist Keith Halliday
YUKONOMIST: The Neapolitan election

Do you remember those old bricks of Neapolitan ice cream from birthday… Continue reading

Chief Medical Officer of Health Dr. Brendan Hanley. (Crystal Schick/Yukon News)
Exposure notice issued for April 3 Air North flight

Yukon Chief Medical Officer of Health Dr. Brendan Hanley has issued another… Continue reading

Crystal Schick/Yukon News file
Runners in the Yukon Arctic Ultra marathon race down the Yukon River near the Marwell industrial area in Whitehorse on Feb. 3, 2019.
Cold-weather exercise hard on the lungs

Amy Kenny Special to the Yukon News It might make you feel… Continue reading

lwtters
Today’s Mailbox: Rent freezes and the youth vote

Dear Editor, I read the article regarding the recommendations by the Yukon… Continue reading

Point-in-Time homeless count planned this month

Volunteers will count those in shelters, short-term housing and without shelter in a 24-hour period.

The Yukon’s new ATIPP Act came into effect on April 1. Yukoners can submit ATIPP requests online or at the Legislative Assembly building. (Gabrielle Plonka/Yukon News file)
New ATIPP Act in effect as of April 1

The changes promise increased government transparency

A new conservancy in northern B.C. is adjacent to Mount Edziza Provincial Park. (Courtesy BC Parks)
Ice Mountain Lands near Telegraph Creek, B.C., granted conservancy protection

The conservancy is the first step in a multi-year Tahltan Stewardship Initiative

Yukon RCMP reported a child pornography-related arrest on April 1. (Phil McLachlan/Black Press file)
Whitehorse man arrested on child pornography charges

The 43-year-old was charged with possession of child pornography and making child pornography

Team Yukon athletes wave flags at the 2012 Arctic Winter Games opening ceremony in Whitehorse. The postponed 2022 event in Wood Buffalo, Alta., has been rescheduled for Jan. 29 to Feb. 4, 2023. (Justin Kennedy/Yukon News file)
New dates set for Arctic Winter Games

Wood Buffalo, Alta. will host event Jan. 29 to Feb. 4, 2023

Victoria Gold Corp. has contributed $1 million to the First Nation of Na-cho Nyak Dun after six months of production at the Eagle Gold Mine. (Submitted/Victoria Gold Corp.)
Victoria Gold contributes $1 million to First Nation of Na-cho Nyak Dun

Victoria Gold signed a Comprehensive Cooperation and Benefits Agreement in 2011

Most Read