Agriculture branch vetoes Shallow Bay decision

The Yukon government has approved Karla DesRosiers’ 63-hectare hay farm and a barn near Shallow Bay, ignoring the recommendation of an…

The Yukon government has approved Karla DesRosiers’ 63-hectare hay farm and a barn near Shallow Bay, ignoring the recommendation of an environmental review board.

That decision flies in the face of concerns raised by the Kwanlin Dun and Ta’an Kwach’an First Nations, Environment Canada, the Yukon Conservation Society and the Yukon Bird Club, among others.

And it contradicts an official recommendation from the Yukon Environmental and Socio-Economic Assessment Board.

Since November 24, the board has gathered concerns about potential environmental and social impacts of DesRosiers’ proposal to mechanically clear about 50 hectares of land near Shallow Bay for hay crops and a barn, use herbicides such as Round Up and to build a perimeter fence made out of barbed wire.

The board received hundreds of pages of correspondence from more than 10 groups, as well as letters of support.

Many detailed worries about bird and fish habitat and increased impacts to the fish-bearing Horse Creek and Lake Laberge.

But most troubling is official government opposition from the Ta’an Kwach’an and Kwanlin Dun due to the project’s overlap with an historic fish camp at the mouth of nearby Horse Creek, as well as several traditional areas including gravesites.

Private ownership of land described as “the heart” of Ta’an Kwach’an territory will prevent it from being used for subsistence hunting and block access to historic sites, wrote Ta’an Kwach’an lands manager John Pattimore in a letter to the YESSA board.

On February 8, YESSA officer Keith Maguire submitted a 27-page report to the agriculture branch of Energy, Mines and Resources outlining the concerns and how they could not be avoided.

“[I]t is recommended that the project not be allowed to proceed, as the designated office (YESSA) has determined that the project will have significant adverse environmental or socio-economic effect in or outside Yukon that cannot be mitigated,” wrote Maguire.

But on March 9, the agriculture branch ignored Maguire’s recommendation.

“Yukon disagrees that there is no mitigation that could eliminate, reduce, or control the adverse effect on traditional and cultural use,” reads the decision, which is endorsed by agriculture director Tony Hill.

The six-page decision goes on to list several ways the branch proposes to reduce the environmental and social impacts of DesRosiers’ hay farm.

These include shrinking the proposal to 42 hectares from 63.

It also cited a pledge by DesRosiers not to disturb historic First Nation sites.

And the government suggested minimum setbacks from Shallow Bay and Horse Creek.

The YESSA board is set up as a recommendation body on projects that will affect Yukon land, but its recommendations can be ignored.

But many question how the government can so easily mitigate hundreds of documented concerns submitted through a four-month consultation that determined it can’t be done.

“YESSA isn’t the decision-making body, I recognize that,” New Democrat Steve Cardiff said on Friday.

“But they determine what mitigation factors need to be taken.”

It recommended the application be denied.

“Then the government turned around and developed their own mitigation measures to address the concerns raised by YESSA, and what’s problematic is they developed them without consulting Ta’an,” he said.

“If they’re serious about involving First Nations governments and respecting their authority and jurisdiction, it would have been appropriate for them to have consulted.”

Despite vocal opposition to the proposal by the Ta’an Kwach’an Council, the YESSA decision notes the land DesRosiers is hoping to turn into a hay farm was designated as settlement land during land claim negotiations, but wasn’t selected by Ta’an.

DesRosiers has had a hay-grazing lease for the location since 1978, while her family has used the property since the 1940s.

Just Posted

No vacancy: Whitehorse family spends five months seeking housing

‘I didn’t think it would be this hard’

Bedbug situation in Whitehorse building becoming intolerable, resident says

Gabriel Smarch said he’s been dealing with bedbugs since he moved into his apartment 15 years ago

Yukon government transfers responsibility for Native Language Centre to CYFN

‘At the end of the day the importance is that First Nations have control of the language’

New operator applies for licence at shuttered Whitehorse daycare

Application has listed a proposed program start date of Feb. 1.

The week in Yukon mining

Goldcorp re-submits Coffee plans, Mount Nansen sale looms, Kudz Ze Kayah comments open

Ice, ice, baby: scaling a frozen Yukon waterfall

‘There’s a really transformative affect with adventure’

Says Marwell is problematic, requests council further hash it out

You can buy alcohol and tobacco on Main Street in Whitehorse —… Continue reading

Yukon history is picture post card perfect

The most interesting gift I received at Christmas this year was the… Continue reading

Contentious Whitehorse quarry proposal raises city hackles

‘We’ve had concerns from the get-go on this one’

Whitehorse time machine

Yukon’s capital added 10,000 people over the last three decades, no YESAB application needed

How to make sure your car starts in the cold

It’s about more than just making sure your plug works

Whitehorse fuel delivery company fined $1,100 for Rancheria crash

The Crown stayed two other charges against the company related to the Aug. 7, 2017, crash

Most Read