When ‘final land claims’ aren’t actually ‘final’

The Yukon government can't seem to escape costly lawsuits when it comes to issues involving First Nations. It has been served with three lawsuits in the past month alone. This, despite the conclusion of land-claims agreements with 11 of its

by Yule Schmidt

The Yukon government can’t seem to escape costly lawsuits when it comes to issues involving First Nations. It has been served with three lawsuits in the past month alone. This, despite the conclusion of land-claims agreements with 11 of its 14 First Nations – almost half of the total agreements in Canada.

Land claims were supposed to provide legal certainty. The 1993 Umbrella Final Agreement between Canada, Yukon, and Yukon First Nations (the precursory framework to individual agreements) confirmed the parties’ “wish to achieve certainty with respect to the ownership and use of lands and other resources in Yukon” and “with respect to their relationships with each other.”

In other words, the goal was to define the parties’ respective rights and obligations and then ratify them in legally binding agreements. In addition, land claims were accompanied by a self-government agreement, which gave each settled First Nation autonomy over its own affairs and lands, and reset the relationship between the three signatories on equal, government-to-government footing.

Land claims were seen as the concluding fulfillment of government’s fiduciary responsibility to First Nations, severing the umbilical cord that had long bound them to territorial and federal administrations. But this finality has proved elusive.

Specifically, the agreements’ legal certainty has been subordinated to “the honour of the Crown” – a historical concept that was resurrected by the courts in the mid-1980s. Initially, it referred simply to the opposite of “sharp dealing” (i.e., unethical action) with First Nations.

But its definition has broadened over time. In Haida v. British Columbia (2004), the Supreme Court of Canada determined that the honour of the Crown includes the duty to consult and accommodate. Accordingly, treaties must be “understood generously” with regard to First Nations in order to “achieve the reconciliation of the pre-existence of aboriginal societies with the sovereignty of the Crown.”

Haida had a significant impact on Yukon land claims. In 2010, the Supreme Court of Canada invoked it as the basis for Beckman v. Little Salmon. Despite the existence of a settled land claim, the Little Salmon/Carmacks First Nation sued the Yukon government for allowing an agricultural lease, arguing that the government still had an obligation to consult on Crown land within its traditional territory.

The government countered that the land claim annulled the consultation requirement. By settling, the First Nation had ceded territory to the Crown, and the Crown was entitled to use it. In essence, the land claim negotiating process had been a protracted consultation period that needn’t be repeated.

But the court concluded that land claims did not, in fact, preclude the duty to consult. The honour of the Crown applied independently of, and in addition to, legal agreements.

The consequence of this decision has been to remove the “final” from Yukon’s final agreements, swapping agreed-upon legal provisions for a rather malleable concept of the Crown’s honour.

In addition to the danger of judicial activism that this new approach unleashes, it undermines the very goal of land claims – to end government paternalism and achieve socio-economic equality for Yukon First Nations through a conclusive settlement of grievances.

The assumption that Yukon First Nations require special treatment is the exact attitude their leaders sought to counteract through land claims

The two dissenting judges in Beckman recognized this objective: “To give full effect to the provisions of a treaty such as the Final Agreement is to renounce a paternalistic approach to relations with aboriginal peoples.” In short, “fiduciary” is just a synonym for paternalistic. By mandating the government to “generously” consult beyond the legal requirements of a land claim, the court inherently refuted First Nations’ ability to function within ungenerous (i.e., normal) legal bounds.

The assumption that Yukon First Nations require special treatment is the exact attitude their leaders sought to counteract through land claims. According to Together Today for Our Children Tomorrow, the 1973 document compiled by Yukon First Nations leaders that effectively sparked land claims negotiations: “The purpose of this settlement is to enable the Indian people in the Yukon to live and work together on equal terms with the Whiteman.”

Since then, the courts have replaced the government’s paternalism with a form of their own. And its enshrinement in statutory law will make it particularly difficult to undo.

As long as the honour of the Crown trumps the legal provisions of land claims, the Yukon government and its settled First Nations will continue disputing the meaning of their final agreements in court. The territory’s experience should serve as a warning to other jurisdictions considering a similar path.

Yule Schmidt is based in Whitehorse, where she serves as a special advisor to the Yukon government. This article, originally published in the National Post, reflects her personal views and not those of her employer.

Get local stories you won't find anywhere else right to your inbox.
Sign up here

Just Posted

During our recent conversation, John Nicholson showed me snapshots of his time working on the Yukon riverboats 70 years ago. (Michael Gates)
History Hunter: Yukon man relives the riverboat days after seven decades

John Nicholson took summer work on Yukon steamers in the 1950s

Yukonomist Keith Halliday
YUKONOMIST: Another election, another anomaly

Monday’s “double-tie” election is generating some free publicity for the Yukon as Outside news agencies scramble to find someone to interview.

A cyclist rides along the Millenium Trail in downtown Whitehorse on a frigid Feb. 9. Whitehorse city council has passed the first two readings of an e-bike bylaw that would designate how e-bike riders can use city trails. (Haley Ritchie/Yukon News)
First two readings passed on Whitehorse e-bike bylaw

Delegate calls on city to consider age restrictions and further regulations

Whitehorse City Hall at its Steele Street entrance. (Stephanie Waddell/Yukon News)
Change of plans approved for city hall

Project would see 1966 city hall demolished

A city map shows the property at 107 Range Road. The zoning is now in place for developers to proceed with plans for a Dairy Queen drive-thru. If plans proceed on schedule the new restaurant is anticipated to open in October. (Cyrstal Schick/Yukon News)
October opening eyed for Dairy Queen

Will depend on everything going according to plan

Joel Krahn/joelkran.com Hikers traverse the Chilkoot Trail in September 2015. Alaska side.
The Canadian side of the Chilkoot Trail will open for summer

The Canadian side of the Chilkoot Trail will open for summer Parks… Continue reading

A bulldozer levels piles of garbage at the Whitehorse landfill in January 2012. (Ian Stewart/Yukon News file)
Rural dump closures and tipping fees raise concern from small communities

The government has said the measures are a cost-cutting necessity

Letters to the editor.
Today’s mailbox: Hands of Hope, the quilt of poppies

Toilets are important Ed. note: Hands of Hope is a Whitehorse-based non-profit… Continue reading

Whitehorse City Hall (Yukon News file)
City news, briefly

A look at city council matters for the week of April 12

École Whitehorse Elementary Grade 7 students Yumi Traynor and Oscar Wolosewich participated in the Civix Student Vote in Whitehorse on April 12. (Haley Ritchie/Yukon News)
Yukon Student Vote chooses Yukon Party government; NDP take popular vote

The initiative is organized by national non-profit CIVIX

Yvonne Clarke is the newly elected Yukon Party MLA for Porter Creek Centre. (Submitted/Yukon Party)
Yvonne Clarke elected as first Filipina MLA in the Yukon Legislative Assembly

Clarke beat incumbent Liberal Paolo Gallina in Porter Creek Centre

Emily Tredger at NDP election night headquarters after winning the Whitehorse Centre riding. (Stephanie Waddell/Yukon News)
Emily Tredger takes Whitehorse Centre for NDP

MLA-elect ready to get to work in new role

Chief Medical Officer of Health Dr. Brendan Hanley. (Crystal Schick/Yukon News)
Two new cases of COVID-19 variant identified in territory

“If variants were to get out of control in the Yukon, the impact could be serious.”

Most Read