Outrage at human rights commissions is misplaced

Human rights commissions and tribunals across Canada certainly get a bad rap.

Human rights commissions and tribunals across Canada certainly get a bad rap. Their critics deride them as “kangaroo courts” run by “left wing activists” who dole out cash for “hurt feelings” after a “show trial” where the complainant is provided with free legal counsel and the accused is forced to fund its own defence.

The commissions and those who defend them deserve some of the blame for these perceptions. Toronto comedian Guy Earle was forced to pay money to offended guests at a Vancouver comedy club after some off-colour jokes sparked a confrontation. There was also the spectacle of conservative firebrand Ezra Levant being forced to defend his decision to publish the relatively benign yet highly controversial Danish cartoons of Muhammad to a commission employee (the complaint against Levant was eventually withdrawn).

The public relations campaign in defence of the various commissions across Canada in recent years has been disastrous. Rather than acknowledging that at its most basic, the system is very much like any other – designed to impose consequences for bad behaviour and compensate complainants for their losses – we hear fluff about how the process is “remedial” rather than “punitive,” and that there is no “accused” or “guilt.”

Financial awards for “hurt feelings” and “injury to dignity” – damages not compensable in most other areas of law – don’t help perceptions. The tendency to portray the process as a friendly chat in the principal’s office where everyone hugs and makes up at the end does not endear the public to the work of the commissions.

These failings aside, I do not share the view of those who believe we should get rid of the commissions: first because the basic mandate of the commissions (i.e. fighting discrimination) is a valid social objective, and second because there isn’t really a better tool to accomplish that objective.

There are certainly those people who, for ideological reasons, do not agree that the state has any role to play in policing discrimination. “Hey, it is my business! I can hire who I want, and sell to whomever I chose! It is none of the government’s business.” If you are one of these people you will likely not find much that you agree with in what follows.

Because I, like many others, believe it is a reasonable limit on our right to run our own business as we please that it be illegal to say “I will not hire you because you are a woman” or “I will not rent to you because you are black” or “get out of my store we don’t serve aboriginals here.” That kind of absolutist libertarianism has been roundly rejected in the Canadian political culture. One can object to some of the more marginal, even frivolous complaints that commissions deal with, but it is clear to me that real discrimination still exists and a mechanism should be in place to address it.

The next question is, whose job is it to police discrimination? The answer in (almost) every jurisdiction in Canada has been a quasi-judicial system involving a commission that investigates claims of discrimination and a tribunal that hears the cases and determines outcomes.

Critics of human rights commissions suggest that such disputes should be handled in “real courts” by “real judges.” In my view, this would be a bad idea and strangely this suggestion is rarely heard with respect to other quasi-judicial bodies that have power in other areas, such as employment and rental standards in other provinces.

The first reason is that our “real judges” are extremely busy. Have you tried to schedule any time with one lately? I have and usually you end up waiting anywhere from several weeks to several months just for a one hour conference with a judge. Want a day or more with one of our real judges? You can expect to wait the better part of a year to get into court.

There is also the reality that most human rights cases involve relatively small amounts of money. For example, take a recent Ontario case where a man was asked by his potential employer if he was white or black and was told that “(the employer) don’t hire foreners (sic)” received an award of a whopping $8,000. One must question the economy of having the most talented and highly paid legal minds in our community (judges) spending days dealing with cases where such minor sums are on the line.

Finally, I do not believe that a shift to a judicially run human rights system will fix many of the more common complaints we hear from critics regarding the current system.

In real court, defendants still pay the cost of their own defence, and when costs are awarded to successful litigant they rarely fully reimburse the party. In real court, civil cases are decided on the basis of a balance of probabilities, rather than proof beyond reasonable doubt.

In real court, in cases involving smaller dollar amounts (i.e. small claims court) the stricter rules of evidence are relaxed. In real court, the names of defendants are a matter of public record and frequently picked up by the media.

In real court, even wrongly accused litigants face the unfortunate choice of paying for settlement or the potentially greater cost of defending a case.

There are many reforms I would propose to the way that human rights commissions operate, and I have serious misgivings about commissions having jurisdiction over speech (thankfully the latter issue is not currently something Yukoner’s need to concern themselves with territorially or federally). But I do believe that a quasi-judicial process for the resolution of these disputes is better than imposing yet another burden on our overstretched court system.

Kyle Carruthers is born and raised Yukoner who lives and practises law in Whitehorse.

Get local stories you won't find anywhere else right to your inbox.
Sign up here

Just Posted

Dr. Brendan Hanley, Yukon’s chief medical officer of health, speaks to media at a press conference about COVID-19 in Whitehorse on March 30. The Yukon government announced three new cases of COVID-19 in Watson Lake on Oct. 23. (Crystal Schick/Yukon News file)
Three new COVID-19 cases identified in Watson Lake

The Yukon government has identified three locations in town where public exposure may have occurred

A pedestrian passes by an offsales sandwich board along Fourth Avenue in Whitehorse on Oct. 22. NDP MLA Liz Hanson raised concerns Oct. 21 in the legislature about increased hospitalizations due to alcohol consumption that correlate with an extension in the hours alcohol can be sold in the territory. (Crystal Schick/Yukon News)
Alcohol-related hospitalizations rise after off-sales hours extended

Reduced hours for off-sale liquor establishments likely part of Liquor Act spring reforms

Tourism and Culture Minister Jeanie McLean (formerly Dendys) speaks during legislative assembly in Whitehorse on Nov. 27, 2017. The Yukon government has announced $2.8 million in tourism relief funding aimed at businesses in the accommodation sector that have already maxed out existing funds. (Crystal Schick/Yukon News file)
Tourism relief funding offers $2.8 million to hotels and overnight accommodations

$15 million in relief funding is planned for the tourism sector over the next three years

The Whitehorse sewage lagoons photographed in 2011. With new regulations for wastewater anticipated to be introduced by the federal government within the next decade, the City of Whitehorse may soon be doing some prep work by looking at exactly what type of pollutants are making their way into the city’s wastewater. (Ian Stewart/Yukon News file)
Pondering pollutants

City could spend $70,000 looking at what contaminents are in waste water

Most of Whitehorse Individual Learning Centre’s class of 2020 graduates. The former students were welcomed back and honoured by staff at the school on Oct. 14 with a personalized grad ceremony for each graduate. (Submitted)
Individual Learning Centre grads honoured

Members of the Whitehorse Individual Learning Centre’s class of 2020 were welcomed… Continue reading

Benjamin Munn, 12, watches the HPV vaccine in 2013. Beginning Jan. 1, 2021, the Human Papillomavirus (HPV) vaccine will be available to all Yukoners up to, and including, age 26. Currently the program is only available to girls ages nine to 18 and boys ages nine to 14. (Dan Bates/Black Press file)
HPV vaccine will be available to Yukoners up to, including, age 26

Beginning Jan. 1, 2021, the Human Papillomavirus (HPV) vaccine will be available… Continue reading

Whitehorse City Hall. (Joel Krahn/Yukon News file)
City hall, briefly

A look at decisions made by Whitehorse city council this week

COMMENTARY: Me and systemic racism

The view from a place of privilege

Today’s mailbox: Electricity and air travel

Letters to the editor published Oct. 23, 2020

Yukonomist Keith Halliday
Yukonomist: Irony versus Climate

Lately it seems like Irony has taken over as Editor-in-Chief at media… Continue reading

Evan Lafreniere races downhill during the U Kon Echelon Halloweeny Cross-Country Race on Oct. 16. (Inara Barker/Submitted)
Costumed bike race marks end of season

The U Kon Echelon Bike Club hosted its final race of the… Continue reading

Smartphone showing various applications to social media services and Google. (Pixabay photo)
National media calling for level playing field with Google, Facebook

In Canada, Google and Facebook control 80 per cent of all online advertising revenues

Education Minister Tracy-Anne McPhee, right, before question period at the Yukon legislative assembly in Whitehorse on March 7, 2019. The Yukon government announced Oct. 19 it has increased the honoraria rates for school council members. (Crystal Schick/Yukon News file)
Honoraria increased for school council members

Members of school councils throughout the territory could soon receive an increased… Continue reading

Most Read