Our current electoral system is obsolete and broken

With Democratic Institutions Minister Maryam Monsef in town last week to discuss electoral reform with Canadians, outgoing Yukon Party cabinet minister Currie Dixon took to these pages to offer his defense of the first-past-the-post electoral system.

With Democratic Institutions Minister Maryam Monsef in town last week on her cross country tour to discuss electoral reform with Canadians, outgoing Yukon Party cabinet minister Currie Dixon took to these pages to offer his defense of the first-past-the-post electoral system.

It is indeed important to acknowledge the merits of the status quo.

First-past-the-post is a simple and easy to understand system for voters. It does a reasonably good job of giving a voice to the disparate and diverse regions of this large country. And, most importantly, it provides a direct link between citizen and government through local elected representatives — a link that is threatened under some models of proportional representation.

But in acknowledging what our first-past-the-post electoral system does well we cannot lose sight of why we are having this discussion to begin with: First-past-the-post does one thing very very poorly and that is produce governments that are even remtotely reflective of the majority opinion of the country.

Dixon rejects the characterization of first-past-the-post as “antiquated,” but that is exactly what it is. First-past-the-post is a relic of an era when only two major parties contested elections.

It actually operated reasonably well until third parties became a permanent fixture on the Canadian political scene in 1921. In most elections prior to that year the party that won a majority of the seats also won a majority of the popular vote — whic is how a democracy should roughly function.

A notable exception was the election of 1896 when Wilfred Laurier was elected to office with not only less than fifty percent of the vote but fewer votes than the Conservative incumbent. By no coincidence it was the first time third parties drew a significant share of the vote — taking 10 per cent in total.

After Laurier’s election, third party vote share dwindled for a few decades until 1921 — when the Progressive Party vied for power for the first time. This marked the end of two-party dominance in Canada (at least in terms of the popular vote). Since then third parties have had a significant vote share in every election and as a result the winning party has taken 50 per cent or more only four times in almost 100 years.

And the problem with first-past-the-post goes beyond governments winning majority governments with less than half the vote. Dixon heralds the direct link between citizen and representative and the accountability that supposedly produces as a reason to keep first-past-the-post. But can our individual members of Parliament really be said to be any more representative of their constituents than our governments are?

In ridings across the country MPs are routinely elected with less than half the vote. In 2011, more than half of the ridings in the country were won in this manner. In 2015, an NDP candidate in one Quebec riding was elected with a mere 28.5% of the vote – getting the approval of just more than 1 in 4 voters in the riding.

Mr. Dixon points to the results in the Yukon in the 2011 election as evidence that first-past-the-post works. It is a popular narrative in the Yukon that Larry Bagnell lost the 2011 election because of anger over the gun registry. And there is a grain of truth here because Yukoners didn’t like the registry and there were a number of voters who parked their votes elsewhere that year because of his reluctant vote to keep it.

But is this really good evidence that first-past-the-post works? After all, Bagnell’s Conservative challenger, Ryan Leef, won that election with only 33 per cent of the vote and regardless how we might feel about the gun registry, nearly two-thirds of Yukoners voted for parties that supported maintaining it. This tells me — simple narratives aside — that most Yukoners had other priorities that year.

Dixon highlights the fact that first-past-the-post gives a voice to smaller regions like the Yukon and implies that the lack of proportionality in the first-past-the-post system is somehow related to the regional accommodations it makes.

But, mathematically speaking, the relative overrepresentation is but a minor contributor to the disconnect we see between popular vote and seat count in this country. The main reason is that we have all kinds of vote splits in a large number of ridings.

It is important to point out — as Dixon does — that there are many considerations that go into crafting an electoral system, that proportionality between popular vote and power is but one, and that first-past-the-post incorporates some of those considerations.

And it is more than fair to question the process that the federal Liberals have undertaken to reform it. I too have very serious misgivings about the ham-fisted manner with which this file has been handled. It is a very dangerous precedent the Liberals will set if they purport to meddle with our electoral system without a formal expression of popular support through a referendum.

Even so, first-past-the-post is both “broken” and “antiquated.”

It is “antiquated” because it is a system designed for elections contested by only two major political parties — which hasn’t been the case in Canada for almost a hundred years. And it is “broken” because the disparity between popular vote and seat count is so wildly out of whack that it is barely deserves to be called democratic.

The only reason we don’t think it’s broken is because it has been distorting the democratic will in almost every election since before most of our grandparents were born. We have become so accustomed to how our system operates that many of us have internalized a subtle redefinition of democracy from rule of the majority to rule of the plurality.

But that is not what elections are supposed to be about.

Kyle Carruthers is a born-and-raised Yukoner who lives and practises law in Whitehorse.

Get local stories you won't find anywhere else right to your inbox.
Sign up here

Just Posted

Maria Metzen off the start line of the Yukon Dog Mushers Association’s sled dog race on Jan. 9. (Gabrielle Plonka/Yukon News)
Mushers race in preparation for FirstMate Babe Southwick

The annual race is set for Feb. 12 and 13.

The Yukon government is making changes to the medical travel system, including doubling the per diem and making destinations for medical services more flexible. (Joel Krahn/Yukon News file)
Subsidy for medical travel doubled with more supports coming

The change was recommended in the Putting People First report endorsed by the government

Chloe Sergerie, who was fined $500 under the <em>Civil Emergency Measures Act</em> on Jan. 12, says she made the safest choice available to her when she entered the territory. (Mike Thomas/Yukon News file)
Woman fined $500 under CEMA says she made ‘safest decision’ available

Filling out a declaration at the airport was contrary to self-isolation, says accused

The Yukon Department of Education building in Whitehorse on Dec. 22, 2020. Advocates are calling on the Department of Education to reverse their redefinition of Individualized Education Plans (IEPs) that led to 138 students losing the program this year. (John Hopkins-Hill/Yukon News file)
Advocates call redefinition of IEPs “hugely concerning,” call for reversal

At least 138 students were moved off the learning plans this year

Yukonomist Keith Halliday
Yukonomist: Your Northern regulatory adventure awaits!

“Your Northern adventure awaits!” blared the headline on a recent YESAB assessment… Continue reading

Yukoner Shirley Chua-Tan is taking on the role of vice-chair of the social inclusion working group with the Canadian Academy of Health Sciences’ oversight panel and working groups for the autism assessment. (Submitted)
Canadian Academy of Health Sciences names Yukoner to panel

Shirley Chua-Tan is well-known for a number of roles she plays in… Continue reading

The Fish Lake area viewed from the top of Haeckel Hill on Sept. 11, 2018. The Yukon government and Kwanlin Dün First Nation (KDFN) announced they are in the beginning stages of a local area planning process for the area. (Crystal Schick/Yukon News file)
Local area planning for Fish Lake announced

The Government of Yukon and Kwanlin Dün First Nation (KDFN) announced in… Continue reading

Whitehorse City Hall. (Joel Krahn/Yukon News file)
City hall, briefly

A look at decisions made by Whitehorse city council this week

Fire damage, photographed on Jan. 11, to a downtown apartment building which occurred late in the evening on Jan. 8. Zander Firth, 20, from Inuvik, was charged with the arson and is facing several other charges following his Jan. 12 court appearance. (Gabrielle Plonka/Yukon News)
More charges for arson suspect

The Inuvik man charged in relation to the fire at Ryder Apartments… Continue reading

The grace period for the new Yukon lobbyist registry has come to an end and those who seek to influence politicians will now need to report their efforts to a public database. (Mike Thomas/Yukon News file)
Grace period for new lobbyist registry ends

So far nine lobbyists have registered their activities with politicians in the territory

The Government of Yukon Main Administration Building in Whitehorse on Aug. 21, 2020. Some Yukon tourism and culture non-profit organizations may be eligible to receive up to $20,000 to help recover from losses due to the COVID-19 pandemic. (Crystal Schick/Yukon News file)
Details released on relief funding for tourism and culture non-profits

Some Yukon tourism and culture non-profit organizations may be eligible to receive… Continue reading

Most Read