Northern Cross suit could cripple the Yukon

If a lawsuit recently brought by Northern Cross against the Yukon government is to believed, the territory is on the hook for $2.2 billion — an amount roughly equal to our gross domestic product for one year.

If a lawsuit recently brought by Northern Cross against the Yukon government is to believed, the territory is on the hook for $2.2 billion — an amount roughly equal to our gross domestic product for one year.

Why? Because our elected government — acting in response to concerns raised by Yukoners — decided to place to a moratorium on fracking in most of the territory. And that limits the amount of gas that Northern Cross can extract from the Eagle Plains region.

Whether or not Northern Cross has a legal case against the Yukon government is a legal question lawyers and bureaucrats would have to answer. I offer no opinion on this question — although the amount of the claim seems dubious. It would seem to assume a lot of what-ifs — including future fuel prices, the cost of production, the amount of reserves, the likelihood that production would have ever occured — going the company’s way to arrive at that gargantuan figure.

However, the question of whether private companies ought to have a claim for compensation against elected governments that decide for various social or environmental reasons to make policy decisions that have a detrimental effect on business prospects is a more interesting philosophical and political one.

It is also one of particular practical importance for our little territory of modest means, which is being eyed up for its resources from Outside by some rather big players.

Back in the early 90s and a stone’s throw from our southern border, the B.C. government paid the owners of the Windy Craggy mineral claims a $103 million settlement after that government decided to create what is now the Tatshenishini-Alsek Provincial Park effectively precluding the owners from developing their claims.

There was nothing overly unusual about that payout. And provincial governments, with budgets in the tens of billions can afford these occasional settlements.

The Yukon government? Not so much. We may enjoy considerable largesse on a per capita basis, but in absolute terms we are a very small fish.

If the Yukon government ever had to make a payout of the kind made in the Windy Craggy case (which is plausible) we’d be talking about something in the neighbourhood of 10-15 per cent of territorial revenues for that year — an absolutely crippling price for the audacious act of listening to constituents who prefer conserving a particular area over developing it.

But this is always going to be a risk we take if we allow investors to obtain resource rights in our territory and then decide for one reason or another to make policy decisions that might strand those assets.

In the case of Northern Cross it only took the issuance of some oil and gas licenses and exploration approvals to give rise to this lawsuit against our government. And even if it takes a small fraction of that amount to settle this claim it will have serious fiscal repercussions for our small jurisdiction.

The question of compensating interest holders also arises in the case of the Peel. One of the concerns raised by proponents of the previous government plan was that an overly restrictive approach in the region would expose the territorial government to lawsuits by existing claims owners. Once the land use planning process is complete we may still have to contend with another round of suits similar to the one brought by Northern Cross.

Back in 2013, then-Energy Mines and Resources Minister Brad Cathers suggested that, for example, Chevron might sue if it lost access to the Crest iron ore deposit (a suggestion the company refused to speculate on at the time). This is part of the reason Premier Sandy Silver spoke repeatedly in the last election about the importance of getting the land use planning process back on track.

But the completion of land use planning is no guarantee of anything, so perhaps we ought to seriously consider bringing some clarity to the question in a broad and comprehensive manner. After all, it is within the powers of the Yukon legislative assembly to pass legislation setting out if and when compensation will be paid in these types of situations. It can legislate away this type of lawsuit if it wishes. Or it can set limits on the amount companies might be entitled to, and under what circumstances.

The main counter-argument of practical implication to such a move is the effect of that kind of uncertainty would have on investment.

After all, who wants to spend money investing in a jurisdiction that could change its mind tomorrow and effectively sticks investors with the bill?

That is certainly a risk we take if we say, as a territory, that we reserve unto ourselves the right to make changes to our social and environmental policies as circumstances evolve without any promise of compensation.

But investment decisions about resource activity already have a significant amount of risk that returns will never come to fruition priced in so it seems doubtful that the possibility of future regulatory changes is going to be a show-stopper.

And the alternative — that we surrender our ability to determine our future out of fear of paying crippling damage claims made against our elected government by outside investors — is far worse.

Private property is an important principle. But it is unreasonable to tell a democratic society that it must choose between environmental protection of its land, air and water and paying large sums of money we do not have to investors.

Kyle Carruthers is a born-and-raised Yukoner who lives and practises law in Whitehorse.

Get local stories you won't find anywhere else right to your inbox.
Sign up here

Just Posted

Yukonomist Keith Halliday
Yukonomist: Are they coming?

One of COVID-19’s big economic questions is whether it will prompt a… Continue reading

Yukon MP Larry Bagnell, along with Yukon health and education delegates, announce a new medical research initiative via a Zoom conference on Jan. 21. (Screen shot)
New medical research unit at Yukon University launched

The SPOR SUPPORT Unit will implement patient-first research practices

Yukon First Nation Education Directorate members Bill Bennett, community engagement coordinator and Mobile Therapeutic Unit team lead, left, and Katherine Alexander, director of policy and analytics, speak to the News about the Mobile Therapeutic Unit that will provide education and health support to students in the communities. (
Mobile Therapeutic Unit will bring education, health support to Indigenous rural students

The mobile unit will begin travelling to communities in the coming weeks

Premier Sandy Silver, left, and Chief Medical Officer of Health Dr. Brendan Hanley, speak during a live stream in Whitehorse on January 20, about the new swish and gargle COVID-19 tests. (Crystal Schick/Yukon News)
Swish and spit COVID-19 test now available in Yukon

Vaccination efforts continue in Whitehorse and smaller communities in the territory

The Royal Canadian Mounted Police detachment in Faro photgraphed in 2016. Faro will receive a new RCMP detachment in 2022, replacing the decades-old building currently accommodating officers. (Joel Krahn/Yukon News file)
Faro RCMP tagged for new detachment

Faro will receive a new RCMP detachment in 2022, replacing the decades-old… Continue reading

In a Jan. 18 announcement, the Yukon government said the shingles vaccine is now being publicly funded for Yukoners between age 65 and 70, while the HPV vaccine program has been expanded to all Yukoners up to and including age 26. (
Changes made to shingles, HPV vaccine programs

Pharmacists in the Yukon can now provide the shingles vaccine and the… Continue reading

Parking attendant Const. Ouellet puts a parking ticket on the windshield of a vehicle in downtown Whitehorse on Dec. 6, 2018. The City of Whitehorse is hoping to write of nearly $300,000 in outstanding fees, bylaw fines and court fees, $20,225 of which is attributed to parking fines issued to non-Yukon license plates. (Crystal Schick/Yukon News file)
City of Whitehorse could write off nearly $300,000

The City of Whitehorse could write off $294,345 in outstanding fees, bylaw… Continue reading

Grants available to address gender-based violence

Organizations could receive up to $200,000

In this illustration, artist-journalist Charles Fripp reveals the human side of tragedy on the Stikine trail to the Klondike in 1898. A man chases his partner around the tent with an axe, while a third man follows, attempting to intervene. (The Daily Graphic/July 27, 1898)
History Hunter: Charles Fripp — gold rush artist

The Alaskan coastal town of Wrangell was ill-equipped for the tide of… Continue reading

A man walks passed the polling place sign at city hall in Whitehorse on Oct. 18, 2018. While Whitehorse Mayor Dan Curtis is now setting his sights on the upcoming territorial election, other members of council are still pondering their election plans for the coming year. (Crystal Schick/Yukon News file)
Councillors undecided on election plans

Municipal vote set for Oct. 21

Whitehorse City Hall. (Joel Krahn/Yukon News file)
City hall, briefly

A look at decicions made by Whitehorse city council this week.

A file photo of grizzly bear along the highway outside Dawson City. Yukon conservation officers euthanized a grizzly bear Jan. 15 that was originally sighted near Braeburn. (Alistair Maitland/Yukon News file)
Male grizzly euthanized near Braeburn

Yukon conservation officers have euthanized a grizzly bear that was originally sighted… Continue reading

Most Read