Non partisanship is no pancea

Partisanship turns a lot of people off of politics, and it is easy to see why. The excesses of partisanship are a sorry sight. 

Partisanship turns a lot of people off of politics, and it is easy to see why.

The excesses of partisanship are a sorry sight. Not unlike warring armies, political parties and their loyal legions form ranks and rally around the flag. Partisans will usually refuse to acknowledge when their opponents are right, except when such an admission is unavoidable, in which case they tend to pivot and criticize their opponent for “mishandling the issue.”

Several solutions have been proposed to this problem. Occasionally I hear the odd Yukoner pine for the system of government that our neighbours to the east enjoy when lamenting the sorry state of partisanship in our territorial legislature.

The Northwest Territories and Nunavut both have what is known as “consensus” government. MLAs are each elected as de facto independents. Once the election is over they choose the premier and cabinet from among their own by secret ballot. No one “runs” to be premier of the Northwest Territories or Nunavut in the way we are accustomed to.

Another idea that was floated a few years ago during the controversy over the potential privatization of Yukon Energy was the idea of a “non-partisan” political party. This led to some meetings, but the plan failed to get off the ground.

The hearts of those who are fed up with partisan politics are in the right place. The instinct to “get along” and “find common ground” is both natural and healthy. But the idea of removing partisan conflict from politics strikes me as naive. Whether we like it or not, politics is more often than not a zero-sum game.

There is a feel-good idea in society that if we all just sit down and have respectful dialogue we can arrive at a consensus, or at least a compromise, on just about any issue. But this ignores the fact that there are a lot of “either-or” decisions that need to be made in politics, that people have strong views on these decisions and that we are divided in the outcome we desire based on our ideologies and interests.

For instance, miners and environmentalists are not going to be able to sit down at a table together and hammer out a mutually acceptable solution to the question of the Peel.

Politics is ultimately about who exercises power, and we differ greatly on how we want to see that power exercised.

Partisanship is the necessary consequence of our disagreements. We affiliate with people who share our values and our interests to form a common front against those who do not. Even in allegedly “non-partisan” political institutions (i.e. city councils, student unions, etc.), parties often emerge organically in the form of slates and informal coalitions.

The fact that we tend to act like children in the process is an unfortunate side-effect, but pretending that our differences don’t exist is not the solution.

Attack politics get a bad rap in no small part because it is practised so disingenuously. But ultimately we have to depend on opposing organized political parties to expose the faults of the others. We certainly can’t count on politicians to highlight their own various shortcomings in their glossy campaign materials to allow voters to weigh their pros and cons. It is the others that allows us to see those faults.

“Consensus government” as it is practice in the Northwest Territories and Nunavut is a rhetorically pleasing misnomer. Neither legislature truly functions on the basis of “consensus” as we typically understand it – a broad agreement or something more than majority.

And the system is not without its critics. Those territories may not have political parties but as a consequence their leaders lack any sort of direct democratic mandate and are difficult to hold accountable. The solution to remove a particular political party from power in the Yukon is to vote them out in the next election. Voters in the other territories don’t have that ability and have no way of knowing who their next premier will be.

The idea of a “non-partisan” party, when it was proposed, was a far greater absurdity. What proponents were essentially asking us voters to do was to select an MLA based solely on his or her purported “non-partisanship.” We wouldn’t be voting for someone based on his or her views on development, conservation, taxes, or spending but rather on some guarantee that they will be “non-partisan.” I, for one, am not about to waste my one small opportunity to influence policy on such an unknown quality.

The ideological spectrum in the Yukon may be narrower than it is elsewhere in Canada due to the fact that we are a major recipient of federal transfers. We are not forced to make the tough ideological decisions that other jurisdictions are forced to make.

But at the end of the day we are still too different to be lumped together under one “big tent.”

Even the biggest of big tents has an occupancy limit and can only stand so much difference without tearing at its seams. While we should always strive to act like adults and put in power those who can behave in a civil manner, accepting some of the nastiness of partisanship is probably the cost of living in a functioning democracy. Problematic alternatives like “non-partisan” parties and consensus government are not the answer.

Kyle Carruthers is a born and raised Yukoner who lives and practises law in Whitehorse.

Get local stories you won't find anywhere else right to your inbox.
Sign up here

Just Posted

Team Togo member Katie Moen sits in a sled behind a snowmobile for the ride from the airport to Chief Zzeh Gittlit School. (Haley Ritchie/Yukon News)
Coming together: How Old Crow became one of the first communities in the world to be fully vaccinated

Team Togo and Team Balto assembled with a mission to not waste a single dose of vaccine

Main Street in Whitehorse on May 4. If council moves forward with bylaw changes, eating and drinking establishments could set up pop-up patios in on-street parking spaces. (Stephanie Waddell/Yukon News)
Patios may be popping up in Whitehorse this summer

City considers program for downtown restaurants and bars

The Yukon Coroner's Service has confirmed the death of a skateboarder found injured on Hamilton Boulevard on May 2. Gabrielle Plonka/Yukon News
Whitehorse man dies in skateboarding accident

Coroner urges the use of helmets, protective gear, while skateboarding.

The new Yukon Liberal caucus poses for a photo during the swearing-in ceremony held on May 3. (Yukon Government/Submitted)
Liberal cabinet sworn in at legislature before house resumes on May 11

Newly elected MLA Jeremy Harper has been nominated as speaker.

The Yukon Wildlife Preserve’s baby bison, born April 22, mingles with the herd on April 29. (John Tonin/Yukon News)
Yukon Wildlife Preserves welcomes two bison calves

A bison calf was the first 2021 baby born at the Yukon Wildlife Preserve

A map provided by the Yukon government shows the location of unpermitted logging leading to a $2,500 fine. (Courtesy/Yukon government)
Man fined $2,500 for felling trees near Beaver Creek

The incident was investigated by natural resource officers and brought to court.

The site of the Old Crow solar project photographed on Feb. 20. The Vuntut Gwitchin solar project was planned for completion last summer, but delays related to the COVID-19 pandemic pushed it back. (Haley Ritchie/Yukon News)
Old Crow is switching to solar

The first phase of the community’s solar array is already generating power.

Chief Medical Officer of Health Dr. Brendan Hanley. (Crystal Schick/Yukon News file)
One new case of COVID-19 in the Yukon

Case number 82 is the territory’s only active case

Flood and fire risk and potential were discussed April 29. Yukoners were told to be prepared in the event of either a flood or a fire. Submitted Photo/B.C. Wildfire Service
Yukoners told to be prepared for floods and wildland fire season

Floods and fire personelle spoke to the current risks of both weather events in the coming months.

From left to right, Pascale Marceau and Eva Capozzola departed for Kluane National Park on April 12. The duo is the first all-woman expedition to summit Mt. Lucania. (Michael Schmidt/Icefield Discovery)
First all-woman team summits Mt. Lucania

“You have gifted us with a magical journey that we will forever treasure.”

Whitehorse City Hall (Yukon News file)
City news, briefly

Whitehorse goings-on for the week of April 26

The Yukon Department of Education in Whitehorse on Dec. 22, 2020. The department has announced new dates for the 2021/2022 school year. (John Hopkins-Hill/Yukon News file)
Yukon school dates set for 2021/22

The schedule shows classes starting on Aug. 23, 2021 for all Whitehorse schools and in some communities.

Most Read