It’s not up to the Liberals to drop the Peel case but they could have done a better job saying so

As predicted, navigating the thorny final chapter of the Peel appeal has turned out to be challenging for the new government.

As predicted, navigating the thorny final chapter of the Peel appeal has turned out to be challenging for the new government. Last week, the Yukon government filed its factum with the Supreme Court of Canada and held a press conference to explain its decision to continue the previous government’s opposition to the appeal brought by First Nations and environmental groups.

The legal argument, contained in a factum filed with the court, represented a fully defensible response to the dilemma the government faces.

After all, the Peel appeal isn’t just about the Peel. It’s about the land use planning process and the adverse precedent that might be set if the appellants were able to argue their case unopposed. The government was, in my view at least, correct to argue that despite the breach committed by the previous government, the process ought to be returned to an early stage. I see little inconsistency in arguing that the Court of Appeal’s decision ought to be upheld while rejecting the previous government’s plans for development.

But the government’s statements at last week’s press conference have proven a tad more controversial. Not only did the government concede that it could not simply accept the plan proposed by the Peel planning commission (as it promised in its platform in the recent election), the new justice minister mused that the plan that might ultimately emerge from this process may not be the same as that which was previously proposed by the commission.

The opposition Yukon Party was quick to pounce, accusing the Liberals of “flip flopping” on its election promises and (gasp!) continuing to do exactly what the Pasloski government had done.

So did the Liberals break their promise?

In a literal sense, they have. The new government will not — and they say cannot — simply “accept the final report of the original Peel Land Use Planning Commission” as they explicitly promised in their platform. That is unquestionably a broken promise.

And once again we have an example of a very specific guarantee being made during the heat and excitement of an election campaign that, in hindsight, ought to have been framed in a more cautious and narrow manner (although it seems likely that the NDP would have pounced on any attempts by the Liberals to insert any nuance into its position on the Peel, as they did with fracking, but I digress).

But it is not fully clear if the Liberals are just being overly cautious in their wording or are truly backtracking on the substance of their promise and have some sort of hidden agenda to allow more development in the region than the original plan allowed. Or perhaps they are simply over-lawyering the appeal.

But excessive cynicism isn’t my thing so — like others including the Tr’ondek Hwech’in First Nation and the Yukon Conservation Society — I want to see how this all plays out before writing off the broader principles of the government’s promise.

The Liberals still have plenty of opportunities to stay loyal to the substance of their commitment to those Yukoners who want to see a plan for the Peel that emphasizes protection over development.

It is, after all, technically true that it isn’t within the government’s range of options to simply accept the recommended plan and call it a day. There is a process that needs to play out before that option will again be in front of them.

And it is also true that, if the process is sent back to an earlier stage in the proceeding, the government may need to consult with affected First Nations who may propose changes to the plan. The process has already been derailed and by putting the matter in front of the court we can’t be sure how it will all shake out.

Despite what the official Opposition is implying, neither the arguments made in the new government’s factum, nor the statements made at its press conference mean that the Liberals have any intention of introducing a plan resembling the now-infamous Yukon Party proposal, which ultimately is what those following this case would be most concerned about. Legally this may be about land use planning, but politically it is about protecting the Peel.

But by being coy about where this is all going, the Liberals are certainly inviting people to draw negative inferences.

I appreciate the reasons for this and I agree with the government’s decision to continue the defence of the Court of Appeal decision. Its hands are more or less tied by the fact that the appellants insisted on moving forward with the appeal.

But Premier Sandy Silver and company could have done a better job communicating their rationale and assuring Yukoners that they hadn’t been duped by a party that says one thing to get elected and does another.

Kyle Carruthers is a born-and-raised Yukoner who lives and practises law in Whitehorse.

Get local stories you won't find anywhere else right to your inbox.
Sign up here

Just Posted

Willow Brewster, a paramedic helping in the COVID-19 drive-thru testing centre, holds a swab used for the COVID-19 test moments before conducting a test with it on Nov. 24. (Crystal Schick/Yukon News)
An inside look at the COVID-19 drive-thru testing centre

As the active COVID-19 case count grew last week, so too did… Continue reading

Conservation officers search for a black bear in the Riverdale area in Whitehorse on Sept. 17. The Department of Environment intends to purchase 20 semi-automatic AR-10 rifles, despite the inclusion of the weapons in a recently released ban introduced by the federal government, for peace officers, such as conservation officers. (Crystal Schick/Yukon News file)
Environment Minister defends purchase of AR-10 rifles for conservation officers

The federal list of banned firearms includes an exception for peace officers

Yukonomist Keith Halliday
Yukonomist: The K-shaped economic recovery and what Yukoners can do about it

It looks like COVID-19 will play the role of Grinch this holiday… Continue reading

Jodie Gibson has been named the 2020 Prospector of the Year by the Yukon Prospectors Association. (Submitted)
Jodie Gibson named 2020 Prospector of the Year

Annual award handed out by the Yukon Prospector’s Association

A number 55 is lit in honour of Travis Adams, who died earlier this year, at the Winter Wonderland Walk at Meadow Lakes Golf Club in Whitehorse on Nov. 24. (Crystal Schick/Yukon News)
A new take on holiday traditions

Winter Wonderland Walk, virtual Stories with Santa all part of 2020 festive events in Whitehorse

Black Press Media and BraveFace have come together to support children facing life-threatening conditions. Net proceeds from these washable, reusable, three-layer masks go to Make-A-Wish Foundation BC & Yukon.
Put on a BraveFace: Help make children’s wishes come true

Black Press Media, BraveFace host mask fundraiser for Make-A-Wish Foundation

Colin McDowell, the director of land management for the Yukon government, pulls lottery tickets at random during a Whistle Bend property lottery in Whitehorse on Sept. 9, 2019. A large amount of lots are becoming available via lottery in Whistle Bend as the neighbourhood enters phase five of development. (Crystal Schick/Yukon News file)
Lottery for more than 250 new Whistle Bend lots planned for January 2021

Eight commercial lots are being tendered in additional to residential plots

The Government of Yukon Main Administration Building in Whitehorse on Aug. 21. The Canada Border Services Agency announced Nov. 26 that they have laid charges against six people, including one Government of Yukon employee, connected to immigration fraud that involved forged Yukon government documents. (Crystal Schick/Yukon News file)
Charges laid in immigration fraud scheme, warrant out for former Yukon government employee

Permanent residency applications were submitted with fake Yukon government documents

Whitehorse City Hall. (Joel Krahn/Yukon News file)
City hall, briefly

A look at decisions made by Whitehorse city council this week

Karen Wenkebach has been appointed as a judge for the Yukon Supreme Court. (Yukon News file)
New justice appointed

Karen Wenckebach has been appointed as a judge for the Supreme Court… Continue reading

Catherine Constable, the city’s manager of legislative services, speaks at a council and senior management (CASM) meeting about CASM policy in Whitehorse on June 13, 2019. Constable highlighted research showing many municipalities require a lengthy notice period before a delegate can be added to the agenda of a council meeting. Under the current Whitehorse procedures bylaw, residents wanting to register as delegates are asked to do so by 11 a.m. on the Friday ahead of the council meeting. (Crystal Schick/Yukon News file)
Changes continue to be contemplated for procedures bylaw

Registration deadline may be altered for delegates

Cody Pederson of the CA Storm walks around LJ’s Sabres player Clay Plume during the ‘A’ division final of the 2019 Yukon Native Hockey Tournament. The 2021 Yukon Native Hockey Tournament, scheduled for March 25 to 28 in Whitehorse next year, was officially cancelled on Nov. 24 in a press release from organizers. (John Hopkins-Hill/Yukon News file)
2021 Yukon Native Hockey Tournament cancelled

The 2021 Yukon Native Hockey Tournament, scheduled for March 25 to 28… Continue reading

Lev Dolgachov/123rf
The Yukon’s Information and Privacy Commissioner stressed the need to safeguard personal information while shopping this holiday season in a press release on Nov. 24.
Information and Privacy Commissioner issues reminder about shopping

The Yukon’s Information and Privacy Commissioner Diane McLeod-McKay stressed the need to… Continue reading

Most Read