How much Chinese forest land do you own?

How much of your retirement fund have you invested in Chinese trees? You may laugh, but your smile would probably disappear if you looked at the list of companies owned by the mutual funds in your retirement account.

How much of your retirement fund have you invested in Chinese trees?

You may laugh, but your smile would probably disappear if you looked at the list of companies owned by the mutual funds in your retirement account.

You wouldn’t be the only one rifling through your portfolio looking for the dreaded words “Sino-Forest.” Investors in Sino-Forest, a major player in Chinese forestry that is listed on the Toronto exchange, have looked on in horror as their shares fell from over $25 to around $2 in just a few weeks. That’s shaved around 90 per cent of the company’s $5.7-billion value as of last Christmas.

Short-sellers at a firm called Muddy Waters prompted the carnage when they released a report questioning the accuracy of Sino-Forest’s claimed assets in China. This is a big deal, since Sino-Forest said it managed almost a million hectares of Chinese forest. They also say they have rights to purchase wood on another 1.25 to 1.4 million hectares.

Sino-Forest has defended itself vigorously, and none of the allegations have been proven in court. But fresh Sino-Forest press releases and hastily translated Chinese documents on the company’s website have not calmed the markets.

Renowned investor John Paulson dumped his entire stake in the company, costing him a reported $750 million loss.

What do Chinese forests and unhappy hedge fund billionaires have to do with regular savers here in the Yukon?

Unfortunately for many investors, Sino-Forest was big enough to get into the S&P/TSX Composite index. This is the successor to the well-known TSE 300, which means many Canadian investors will have ended up owning Sino-Forest indirectly. In fact, as of last March Sino-Forest had a bigger place in the index than household names such as Canadian Tire, Loblaw and Westjet.

The managers of many pension and mutual funds buy the stocks in such indexes, not least because their performances are compared against them. Until last month, any fund manager who ignored Sino-Forest would have suffered against competitors. The company’s annual report for 2010 trumpeted the fact that Sino-Forest’s share price had outperformed the S&P/TSX Composite by 303 per cent in the previous five years.

Popular, low-cost index funds offered by the country’s biggest fund families and exchange-traded funds such as iShares’ popular $1.4 billion Canadian Capped Composite Index Fund would also have included Sino-Forest, since they automatically buy all the stocks in the index in proportion to their size.

The damage done may have been in the billions, but fortunately it wasn’t huge on a percentage basis. On March 31, Sino-Forest made up 0.38 per cent of the S&P/TSX Composite Index. Even if it ends up being a total loss, it would only vapourize $3.80 on a $1,000 investment in an index-tracking fund.

You would have been hit harder by the fall in Research in Motion (RIM). RIM was 1.55 per cent of the index in March, and its problems have vapourized about $10 billion in shareholder value since then. That’s around double the pain that Sino-Forest has caused.

Nonetheless, the Sino-Forest incident is troubling. How could an obscure company whose business is to buy and sell forests in distant provinces of China have made it into our pension funds? The 2010 annual report says it made money by buying trees for $45 per cubic metre and selling them for $79, mostly in China. Didn’t this strike any of our highly paid fund managers and equity analysts as an improbable business model?

Have our fund managers also got our savings invested in companies that sell swampland in Florida?

The episode illustrates two long-standing problems with Canadian investing.

The first is the relative small size of our stock market. Compared to London or New York, we just don’t have that many companies. Once you get out of the top 100, you get into some companies that are little known and by global standards are quite small. Companies like Flint Energy Services and CML Healthcare. Fine companies perhaps, but I have to admit I have never heard of either of them.

Index funds reduce risk by giving you diversification, but that isn’t so helpful if the smaller companies you’ve diversified into are quite risky.

This is one of the reasons why they have created the more concentrated S&P/TSX 60. But that doesn’t solve the problem if you were involved with one of the many funds who tracked the broader S&P/TSX Composite.

The second problem is how accident prone our capital markets seem to be. We had the Bre-X scandal in the 1990s, where the company’s Indonesian gold reserves ended up being much smaller than claimed. Many Canadian investors lost their shirts amid a welter of fraud allegations.

Then there was Nortel. As the bubble inflated in 2000 and 2001, the company got so big that at one point it represented around one-third of the S&P/TSX Composite. As a result, risk-averse investors who thought they were investing conservatively ended up owning a large concentration of what turned out to be a highly risky tech company.

A joke a few years later went like this: what was a better investment, $1000 of Nortel or $1000 of beer? The punch line was “beer, since at least you get the bottle deposit back.”

Sadly, the joke was right.

After the Nortel debacle, they invented “capped” index funds that put limits on how big a single company can get.

Unfortunately, the Sino-Forest implosion illustrates that conservative Canadian investors still need to be cautious. Sino-Forest was in the index. It had “buy” recommendations from equity analysts at respectable firms. And if regulators had any worries about the company, this investor didn’t hear about it.

It’s a reminder that the investor trusts the investment establishment in Canada at his or her peril. “Buyer beware” should be every investor’s motto.

Keith Halliday is a Yukon economist and author of the Aurore of the Yukon series of historical children’s adventure novels.

Get local stories you won't find anywhere else right to your inbox.
Sign up here

Just Posted

Yukonomist Keith Halliday
Yukonomist: Are they coming?

One of COVID-19’s big economic questions is whether it will prompt a… Continue reading

Yukon MP Larry Bagnell, along with Yukon health and education delegates, announce a new medical research initiative via a Zoom conference on Jan. 21. (Screen shot)
New medical research unit at Yukon University launched

The SPOR SUPPORT Unit will implement patient-first research practices

Yukon First Nation Education Directorate members Bill Bennett, community engagement coordinator and Mobile Therapeutic Unit team lead, left, and Katherine Alexander, director of policy and analytics, speak to the News about the Mobile Therapeutic Unit that will provide education and health support to students in the communities. (
Mobile Therapeutic Unit will bring education, health support to Indigenous rural students

The mobile unit will begin travelling to communities in the coming weeks

Premier Sandy Silver, left, and Chief Medical Officer of Health Dr. Brendan Hanley, speak during a live stream in Whitehorse on January 20, about the new swish and gargle COVID-19 tests. (Crystal Schick/Yukon News)
Swish and spit COVID-19 test now available in Yukon

Vaccination efforts continue in Whitehorse and smaller communities in the territory

The Royal Canadian Mounted Police detachment in Faro photgraphed in 2016. Faro will receive a new RCMP detachment in 2022, replacing the decades-old building currently accommodating officers. (Joel Krahn/Yukon News file)
Faro RCMP tagged for new detachment

Faro will receive a new RCMP detachment in 2022, replacing the decades-old… Continue reading

In a Jan. 18 announcement, the Yukon government said the shingles vaccine is now being publicly funded for Yukoners between age 65 and 70, while the HPV vaccine program has been expanded to all Yukoners up to and including age 26. (
Changes made to shingles, HPV vaccine programs

Pharmacists in the Yukon can now provide the shingles vaccine and the… Continue reading

Parking attendant Const. Ouellet puts a parking ticket on the windshield of a vehicle in downtown Whitehorse on Dec. 6, 2018. The City of Whitehorse is hoping to write of nearly $300,000 in outstanding fees, bylaw fines and court fees, $20,225 of which is attributed to parking fines issued to non-Yukon license plates. (Crystal Schick/Yukon News file)
City of Whitehorse could write off nearly $300,000

The City of Whitehorse could write off $294,345 in outstanding fees, bylaw… Continue reading

Grants available to address gender-based violence

Organizations could receive up to $200,000

In this illustration, artist-journalist Charles Fripp reveals the human side of tragedy on the Stikine trail to the Klondike in 1898. A man chases his partner around the tent with an axe, while a third man follows, attempting to intervene. (The Daily Graphic/July 27, 1898)
History Hunter: Charles Fripp — gold rush artist

The Alaskan coastal town of Wrangell was ill-equipped for the tide of… Continue reading

A man walks passed the polling place sign at city hall in Whitehorse on Oct. 18, 2018. While Whitehorse Mayor Dan Curtis is now setting his sights on the upcoming territorial election, other members of council are still pondering their election plans for the coming year. (Crystal Schick/Yukon News file)
Councillors undecided on election plans

Municipal vote set for Oct. 21

Whitehorse City Hall. (Joel Krahn/Yukon News file)
City hall, briefly

A look at decicions made by Whitehorse city council this week.

A file photo of grizzly bear along the highway outside Dawson City. Yukon conservation officers euthanized a grizzly bear Jan. 15 that was originally sighted near Braeburn. (Alistair Maitland/Yukon News file)
Male grizzly euthanized near Braeburn

Yukon conservation officers have euthanized a grizzly bear that was originally sighted… Continue reading

Most Read