economics shaky for a sovereign quebec

The "neverendum" is back. Even though Pauline Marois only won a minority, we're sure to be talking about sovereignty, separation, independence - call it what you will - as long as there is a Parti Quebecois premier in Quebec City.

The “neverendum” is back. Even though Pauline Marois only won a minority, we’re sure to be talking about sovereignty, separation, independence – call it what you will – as long as there is a Parti Quebecois premier in Quebec City.

As if to underline the old metaphor that French and English Canada are like two ships passing in the night, recent polls have shown that support for independence is flat or down in Quebec even as English Canadians are becoming increasingly comfortable with the idea.

Just before the election, an Ipsos Reid poll had 49 per cent of “Rest of Canada” respondents agreeing with the phrase, “If Quebec separates, it’s not really a big deal to me.” Meanwhile, 49 per cent of Quebecois said they would vote against sovereignty while only 31 per cent said they would vote in favour.

This is down markedly from the last referendum in 1995, which was a 51 per cent to 49 per cent squeaker, as you’ll recall.

If there is another referendum, and I’ll leave the speculation on that to the political pundits back East, there will be a very different economic context for the Quebec voter to think about.

Back in 1995, sovereignists could make a relatively coherent argument that the nation state was becoming less important economically thanks to free trade. Over in the European Union, Catalan companies could trade as easily with French clients as with Spanish ones. The same for Scottish or Bavarian businesses. In North America, Quebec sovereignists looked to the North American Free Trade Agreement as evidence that Quebec’s economic success didn’t depend on special access to Canadian markets any more.

American clients would be just as likely to buy Quebec maple syrup or regional jets if they said “Made in Quebec” instead of “Made in Canada.” Same for Albertan, German or Chinese clients.

However, the recent global financial crisis has reminded us of some economic truths we hadn’t thought about for a long time. The messages are especially sobering for small countries with high debts and aging populations. And while Quebec is no Greece, or even a Portugal, the issues are serious enough that Quebec voters have some big economic topics to think about.

The first topic is debt. Quebec is the most indebted province, with provincial net debt at 52 per cent of gross domestic product. According to TD Economics, the next highest province is Ontario at 40 per cent, while the Western provinces are all under 30 per cent.

If Quebec separated and took a share of the federal debt equal to its share of GDP, the new nation’s debt to GDP ratio would be 88 per cent. Nowhere near as high as Greece or Italy, but still well over the 60 per cent figure used in the famous “Maastricht criteria” in the European Union.

And to pay this debt back, it’s worth noting that the province’s economy has tended to grow a bit more slowly than the rest of the country over the last decade or two. In fact, the only year since 2001 when Quebec has grown faster than the Canadian average was 2009. And that wasn’t really growth. It was just that the Quebec economy sank less than the rest of the country during the downturn.

Recent events in Europe have reminded us how unpleasant it is to be a small, slow-growing country rolling over a large debt if the markets happen to be in a funk.

Then there’s demographics. All advanced Western countries are worrying about aging populations and how a smaller number of workers will pay for all the services older citizens have come to expect. According to the most recent census, Quebec’s population is older than the average for the rest of Canada. Quebec now has more senior citizens than youth under 15.

And Quebec gets fewer immigrants as a share of its population than the rest of the country. The Parti Quebecois’ election platform may not help, since one doesn’t appeal to most immigrants by forbidding their children from attending English-language junior colleges, banning non-French-speaking citizens from running for public office or forcing non-Christian government employees to put away their yarmulkes, kirpans or turbans.

The financial crisis also forces the awkward question of a Quebec dollar onto the agenda. Previous sovereignist governments have claimed they would keep using the Canadian dollar, hoping to reassure Quebecois that their assets wouldn’t be rapidly devalued (or Florida vacations more expensive) after a “oui” vote.

However, as Eurozone governments have found out, not controlling your own currency in a crisis means that your government loses a bunch of useful economic tools that countries like the U.K., Iceland and the U.S. have used lately. These include devaluation to boost exports, printing money to shore up your banks, or inflating your way out of a debt crisis.

I have heard sovereignists talk in the past about scenarios where the loonie becomes some kind of jointly-controlled “Canada-Quebec” common currency. This seems highly improbable, even before you factor in how voters in the rest of Canada would react to such a scheme. It would be a choice between using the Canadian dollar, with the Bank of Canada in control, or the massive and risky process of launching a new currency.

These challenges seem substantial, even before you start to worry about scenarios where the break up of Canada gets messy. If some relatively minor tuition hikes can bring business to a halt in Montreal, think what will happen to the economy if there is a close “yes” vote but northern Quebec aboriginal communities and some anglophone parts of Montreal decide they don’t want to leave Canada.

Quebec voters will have to think all this through. If Premier Marois does manage to get a new referendum bill through the National Assembly, her minister of finance is going to have a lot of convincing to do.

Keith Halliday is a Yukon economist and author of the Aurore of the Yukon series of historical children’s adventure novels.

Get local stories you won't find anywhere else right to your inbox.
Sign up here

Just Posted

Connie Peggy Thorn, 52, pleaded guilty Jan. 27 to manslaughter in the 2017 death of Greg Dawson. (Crystal Schick/Yukon News file)
Whitehorse woman pleads guilty to manslaughter in death of Greg Dawson

Connie Thorn, 52, was arrested in October 2019 and pleaded guilty in Supreme Court on Jan. 27.

Abigail Jirousek, left, is tailed by Brian Horton while climbing a hill during the Cross Country Yukon January Classic in Whitehorse on Jan. 23. Jirousek finished second in the U16 girls category. (Crystal Schick/Yukon News)
Cross Country Yukon hosts classic race

Cross Country Yukon hosted a classic technique cross-country ski race on Jan.… Continue reading

Yukon Premier Sandy Silver talks to media on March 5, 2020. The Yukon government said Jan. 25 that it is disappointed in a decision by the federal government to send the Kudz Ze Kayah mining project back to the drawing board. (Crystal Schick/Yukon News file)
Territorial and federal governments at odds over Kudz Ze Kayah mine project

The federal government, backed by Liard First Nation, sent the proposal back to the screening stage


Wyatt’s World for Jan. 27, 2021

Yukon RCMP said in a press release that they are seeing an increase in tinted front passenger windows and are reminding people that it is illegal and potentially dangerous. (RCMP handout)
RCMP warn against upward trend of tinted windows

Yukon RCMP are seeing more vehicles with tinted front passenger windows, prompting… Continue reading

An arrest warrant has been issued for a 22-year-old man facing two tickets violating the <em>Civil Emergency Measures Act</em>. (Joel Krahn/Yukon News file)
Arrest warrant issued for CEMA violation

An arrest warrant has been issued for Ansh Dhawan over two tickets for violating CEMA

The office space at 151 Industrial Road in Marwell. At Whitehorse city council’s Jan. 25 meeting, members voted to sign off on the conditional use approval so Unit 6 at 151 Industrial Rd. can be used for office space. (John Hopkins-Hill/Yukon News file)
Marwell move set for land and building services staff

Conditional use, lease approved for office space

The bus stop at the corner of Industrial and Jasper Road in Whitehorse on Jan. 25. The stop will be moved approximately 80 metres closer to Quartz Road. (Crystal Schick/Yukon News)
UPDATED: Industrial Road bus stop to be relocated

The city has postponed the move indefinitely

The Royal Canadian Mounted Police detachment in Faro photgraphed in 2016. Faro will receive a new RCMP detachment in 2022, replacing the decades-old building currently accommodating officers. (Joel Krahn/Yukon News file)
Faro RCMP tagged for new detachment

Faro will receive a new RCMP detachment in 2022, replacing the decades-old… Continue reading

In a Jan. 18 announcement, the Yukon government said the shingles vaccine is now being publicly funded for Yukoners between age 65 and 70, while the HPV vaccine program has been expanded to all Yukoners up to and including age 26. (
Changes made to shingles, HPV vaccine programs

Pharmacists in the Yukon can now provide the shingles vaccine and the… Continue reading

Parking attendant Const. Ouellet puts a parking ticket on the windshield of a vehicle in downtown Whitehorse on Dec. 6, 2018. The City of Whitehorse is hoping to write of nearly $300,000 in outstanding fees, bylaw fines and court fees, $20,225 of which is attributed to parking fines issued to non-Yukon license plates. (Crystal Schick/Yukon News file)
City of Whitehorse could write off nearly $300,000

The City of Whitehorse could write off $294,345 in outstanding fees, bylaw… Continue reading

Grants available to address gender-based violence

Organizations could receive up to $200,000

Most Read