Defunding Yukon’s Catholic schools won’t be easily done

Internet comments usually aren't much of a gauge of anything except for certain people's propensity for snark when cloaked in the comfortable robes of anonymity.

Internet comments usually aren’t much of a gauge of anything except for certain people’s propensity for snark when cloaked in the comfortable robes of anonymity. But I think it is fair to conclude from the volume and intensity of comments to the News’ story about the Yukon Green Party proposal to abolish the territory’s separate Catholic school system that this is an issue that evokes extremely strong feelings on both sides.

Not being a serious contender for territorial leadership, the Yukon Greens have the advantage of being able to stir the pot without fear of real-world electoral consequences. It could even draw a few extra votes for the nascent party from the handful of single-issue voters who are quite moved by this subject.

But with almost a thousand Yukon children attending publicly funded Catholic schools, it is unlikely that any of the three mainstream political parties is going to alienate and mobilize such a potentially large bloc of voters.

Even if they wanted to do away with Catholic education they’d have to convince Parliament to amend the Yukon Act first. The Yukon Act requires that “the minority of the ratepayers in that part of Yukon, whether Protestant or Roman Catholic, may establish separate schools” – or, in other words the Yukon government, is required to provide Catholic schools if parents want them.

All that sounds like a lot of effort just to alienate a group of voters that presumably cross political lines.

Much ink has been spilled over the fairness of our country’s “historical compromise” whereby Catholics enjoy the privilege of publicly funded religious education in certain provinces while followers of other religions enjoy no such funding.

There is definitely a certain amount of dissonance between that privilege and the Charter’s guarantee that everyone “has the right to the… equal benefit of the law without discrimination and, in particular, without discrimination based on… religion”. Whatever the practical and political implications, the notion that we should fund all religious schools or fund none at all has a certain ethical coherence to it. The best argument that defenders of the status quo can marshal in favour of their position is tradition, which, in my view at least, is a weak argument on any substantive issue of public policy.

Not surprisingly, the Supreme Court of Canada has had to wrestle with the legal contradiction between that one section of our country’s constitution, which says that people of all religions are entitled to equal treatment, and others, which require that certain provincial governments fund certain religious schools.

In the 1996 Adler decision, the high court came down on the side of Catholic schools deciding that the specific rights enjoyed by denominational schools trumped the more general right to equal religious treatment. So as far as the provinces are concerned – barring a change of heart by the court’s justices – the legal issues are effectively settled. Funding one but not others is constitutional.

But the Yukon’s status as a territory rather than a province does raise an interesting and untested legal question about whether the same conclusion could be reached about our situation here, were anyone ever so inclined to insist that the Yukon government establish a separate school system for any non-Christian religion.

Unlike the constitutional provisions insulating Catholic schools in certain provinces from Charter scrutiny, the Yukon Act is just an ordinary law. This means it cannot claim equal status with the Charter of Rights in the hierarchy of laws, and the reasoning in Adler would arguably not apply. As such, I think that were anyone to ever challenge the restriction on “separate schools” in the Yukon to “Protestant or Roman Catholic” religions on the basis that it infringes the Charter’s equality guarantee, there would be a decent legal argument that the Yukon government has to fund them all.

Of course, funding all is not a terribly palatable solution either. Such a proposal effectively killed the campaign of John Tory’s Ontario Progressive Conservatives in the 2007 provincial election. And since the primary rationale given by the Yukon Greens for abolishing the Catholic school system is the financial savings, extending the privilege of separate schools to other religions would only exacerbate the inefficiency of maintaining multiple parallel school systems.

So let’s review: Our territorial politicians have three options. They can stand in the path of historical inertia and irritate a bloc of voters by abolishing a school system those voters regard as being something akin to a sacred right. Or they can blow up the budget by creating a patchwork of religious schools no one is really strongly pushing for. Or they can continue to defend, through their silence, an indefensible, unequal and arguably unlawful status quo.

With options like those, it is no wonder the only party making noise about this issue is the one without a seat in the legislature.

Kyle Carruthers is a born-and-raised Yukoner who lives and practises law in Whitehorse.

Get local stories you won't find anywhere else right to your inbox.
Sign up here

Just Posted

Mobile vaccine team Team Balto practises vaccine clinic set-up and teardown at Vanier Catholic Secondary School. Mobile vaccine teams are heading out this week to the communities in order to begin Moderna vaccinations. (Haley Ritchie/Yukon News)
Mobile vaccine teams begin community vaccinations

“It’s an all-of-government approach”

The now empty lot at 410 Cook Street in Whitehorse on Jan. 19. As developers move forward with plans for a housing development that would feature 16 micro-units, they are asking city council for a zoning change that would reduce the number of required parking spaces. (Crystal Schick/Yukon News)
Developer asks for zoning change

Would reduce the number of required parking spaces

The Liard First Nation is preparing to enter negotiations for self-governance with the territorial and federal governments. (Jackie Hong/Yukon News file)
Liard First Nation preparing to enter self-governance negotiations with Yukon, federal governments

Chief Stephen Charlie seeking an agreement separate from “dead end” UFA


Wyatt’s World for Jan. 20, 2021

A Copper Ridge resident clears their driveway after a massive over night snowfall in Whitehorse on Nov. 2, 2020. Environment Canada has issued a winter storm warning for the Whitehorse and Haines Junction areas for Jan. 18. (Crystal Schick/Yukon News file)
Winter storm warning for Haines Junction and Whitehorse

Environment Canada says the storm will develop Monday and last until Tuesday

Mayor Dan Curtis listens to a councillor on the phone during a city council meeting in Whitehorse on April 14, 2020. Curtis announced Jan. 14 that he intends to seek nomination to be the Yukon Liberal candidate for Whitehorse Centre in the 2021 territorial election. (Crystal Schick/Yukon News)
Whitehorse mayor seeking nomination for territorial election

Whitehorse mayor Dan Curtis is preparing for a run in the upcoming… Continue reading

Gerard Redinger was charged under the <em>Civil Emergency Measures Act</em> with failing to self-isolate and failing to transit through the Yukon in under 24 hours. (Joel Krahn/Yukon News file)
Man ticketed $1,150 at Wolf Creek campground for failing to self-isolate

Gerard Redinger signed a 24-hour transit declaration, ticketed 13 days later

Yukon Energy, Solvest Inc. and Chu Níikwän Development Corporation are calling on the city for a meeting to look at possibilities for separate tax rates or incentives for renewable energy projects. (Crystal Schick/Yukon News file)
Tax changes sought for Whitehorse energy projects

Delegates call for separate property tax category for renewable energy projects

Yukon University has added seven members to its board of governors in recent months. (Crystal Schick/Yukon News file)
New members named to Yukon U’s board of governors

Required number of board members now up to 17

Yukonomist Keith Halliday
Yukonomist: Your Northern regulatory adventure awaits!

“Your Northern adventure awaits!” blared the headline on a recent YESAB assessment… Continue reading

Yukoner Shirley Chua-Tan is taking on the role of vice-chair of the social inclusion working group with the Canadian Academy of Health Sciences’ oversight panel and working groups for the autism assessment. (Submitted)
Canadian Academy of Health Sciences names Yukoner to panel

Shirley Chua-Tan is well-known for a number of roles she plays in… Continue reading

The Fish Lake area viewed from the top of Haeckel Hill on Sept. 11, 2018. The Yukon government and Kwanlin Dün First Nation (KDFN) announced they are in the beginning stages of a local area planning process for the area. (Crystal Schick/Yukon News file)
Local area planning for Fish Lake announced

The Government of Yukon and Kwanlin Dün First Nation (KDFN) announced in… Continue reading

Most Read