Ample evidence that log homes are energy hogs

Ample evidence that log homes are energy hogs Dave Loeks' letter in the Jan. 30 News attempts to twist the log home energy argument, but portions of it aptly make my point, including his statement that "we are all entitled to our own opinion, but not our

Dave Loeks’ letter in the Jan. 30 News attempts to twist the log home energy argument, but portions of it aptly make my point, including his statement that “we are all entitled to our own opinion, but not our own facts.” But who has offered an opinion, and who has referenced facts?

To summarize, this exchange started when Mr. Loeks claimed that log homes are energy efficient in ways that “aren’t really well understood.” Now he’s claiming that log homes are more comfortable, and presumably more energy efficient, than frame homes.

That’s a problem with those who profit from selling alternate construction assemblies. Every product has trade-offs, but the marketing claims would have you believe it’s all pro, no con. I believe that potential purchasers should have some facts before they make a decision.

Mr. Loeks states that my rebuttal to his claims is just an opinion, even though I quoted sources such as the National Research Council and a log builders association. Referencing reputable sources isn’t a personal opinion, it’s a presentation of facts based on testing.

Ah, but Mr. Loeks claims that all testing has been laboratory work or computer modeling, so isn’t representative. The lab work has been large-scale test walls that allowed for multiple variables, not little test-tube samples. Further, over 50 years of testing has produced consistent results. In sum, log walls are poor insulators, the thermal mass has some value in a moderate climate, and log homes use a lot of energy in a cold climate.

But wait! Loeks notes that the Southern Alberta Institute of Technology is going to do a whole-home, real world comparison of different wall constructions, and this will “at last provide valid comparative data.” Apparently Mr. Loeks is unaware of a study conducted during 1981-82 in the U.S. Complete homes with identical plans, one frame and one log, were measured.

I suppose this test isn’t quoted by log builders because it didn’t give the results they want. There have been similar “in the field” studies. I’m surprised Loeks doesn’t know about them.

Loeks states that the data proving log homes are energy hogs doesn’t “yet exist.” Sure it does, unless Loeks’s personal opinion outweighs 50 years of testing.

But rather than believe either Loeks or myself, there’s a couple simple observations any Yukoner can make. In a cold winter, my 20-year-old wrap-and-strap house burns three cords of wood in an Ardent 65 stove to heat 1,800 square feet. Simply, that’s one cord per 600 square feet per winter. People I know in similarly sized log homes use between eight and 12 cords, or three to four times as much. What’s your consumption?

Yukoners are also familiar with the stud lines on house walls that appear both inside and outside, when it gets cold. A friend joked that he’d wait until winter to hang pictures, as he could see every stud. That’s the wood conducting energy outside.

Mr. Loeks has one thing right: “saying it’s so doesn’t make it so.” I think it’s pretty clear which one of us is just saying things, and which has substantial evidence to back up the statement that log homes are energy hogs.

Charles McLaren


Just Posted

Car crashes through Whitehorse school fence

2 people taken to hospital, no kids hurt

Tagish dog rescue owner asks for court order to get rid of dogs to be put on hold

Shelley Cuthbert argued forcing her to get rid of all but two dogs would cause ‘irreparable harm’

Yukon College officially unveils new $3.59M Whitehorse learning space

Innovation Commons designed to let the sunlight in

No vacancy: Whitehorse family spends five months seeking housing

‘I didn’t think it would be this hard’

Bedbug situation in Whitehorse building becoming intolerable, resident says

Gabriel Smarch said he’s been dealing with bedbugs since he moved into his apartment 15 years ago

The week in Yukon mining

Goldcorp re-submits Coffee plans, Mount Nansen sale looms, Kudz Ze Kayah comments open

Painting the past: Kaska artist explores his childhood in new show

‘I used to say I painted and I carved. But now I say it’s through my ancestors.’

Rain and warm weather makes for interesting Carbon Hill race day

‘I guess we all start getting used to this crazy weather.’

Ice, ice, baby: scaling a frozen Yukon waterfall

‘There’s a really transformative affect with adventure’

Delegate blunt about proposed location of cannabis retail stores

‘Marijuana has had a stigma of being a bad thing’

What does the NDP need to gain power once again?

The party will need to do some soul searching before we head to the polls again

Yukon history is picture post card perfect

The most interesting gift I received at Christmas this year was the… Continue reading

Most Read