The justice system failed Michael Nehass — and by extension all of us

It’s clear at this point that, unsupervised, Michael Nehass is a danger to himself and to society at large. But that’s no excuse for the seemingly endless legal labyrinth he has endured since his 2011 arrest.

Michael Nehass believes the CIA is out to get him.

He believes senior officials in the Yukon government conspired to silence him because he has information about missing and murdered Indigenous women.

He told a court hearing that jail guards at the Whitehorse Correctional Centre, which has been his home for much of his adult life, stitched fabric laced with carcinogens into his stomach in an effort to kill him.

And at one point, while in custody, Nehass swallowed makeshift razor blades, fashioned from an aluminum beverage can, in order to be taken to the hospital.

Nehass has been in jail since 2011 on charges of assault with a weapon, forcible confinement and breach of probation. At trial, court heard he dragged a woman into a Watson Lake apartment, hit her, grabbed her by the throat and threatened her with a knife. In May 2015 he was found guilty of those charges by a jury after five and a half hours of deliberation.

That’s after Nehass was found mentally unfit for trial by a judge, then fit for trial by the Yukon Review Board in a decision that was confirmed by another judge.

Most recently, he was found unfit for a hearing to have him declared a dangerous offender because the psychosis that plagues him has gotten worse, according to expert testimony.

And this week, Justice Scott Brooker ruled Nehass is in a “legal void” because the Criminal Code does not provide for requiring people convicted of crimes to undergo mental health treatment — in Nehass’s case, a round of anti-psychotic medication that could allow the case to proceed. Brooker was left with no option but to declare a mistrial, meaning Nehass now returns to the trial stage.

Nehass himself has rejected the suggestion that he is mentally ill and has shown himself to be an intelligent person who understands how the court system works. He has fired lawyer after lawyer and acted as his own legal counsel. He has torn apart cells at the Whitehorse Correctional Centre and spat on guards there.

This is a highly abridged recounting of Michael Nehass’s complex and sometimes contradictory legal saga. It’s clear at this point that, unsupervised, Nehass is a danger to himself and to society at large. But that’s no excuse for the seemingly endless legal labyrinth he has endured since his 2011 arrest.

While in jail, Nehass was hauled naked, apart from a blanket, in front of a video hearing. He spent long stretches in segregation at WCC, without being allowed outside and without so much as television for stimulus. He was allowed to stew in his own thoughts without the counselling or medication that could help him.

That is not acceptable. We are not Victorian England. We do not lock the mentally ill into cells and throw away the keys. Many would say we should. That it’s what a man like Nehass deserves. But the self-righteousness of random punters is not justice.

It’s true that Nehass has done bad things. Perhaps he does deserve to be designated a dangerous offender. That’s a matter for a court of law to decide. But it’s telling that the Crown, the judge and the defence all agree Nehass is currently in no condition to undergo such a hearing. It is possible for someone to be both a violent criminal and a victim.

Jail and justice department officials have likewise long believed the WCC is not where Nehass belongs. Yet it was only in November that Nehass was finally relocated to a forensic hospital in Whitby, Ontario, where he can undergo treatment. It should never have taken so long.

“There was a lack of will, resources, and a lack of guidelines,” Nehass’s current lawyer, Anick Morrow, told court in January during her argument in favour of a mistrial. “It’s not about assigning blame but the system breakdown across so many issues.”

Yukon’s justice system has failed Nehass and revealed its complete inability to properly handle complicated cases where violence and mental illness intersect. Nehass is a hard case, and thankfully, those are rare in the Yukon. But there will be others in the future and our justice system must figure out how to deal with them.

The government must review the system and make changes. We owe that much to society, and to Michael Nehass himself.

Contact Chris Windeyer at editor@yukon-news.com.

Just Posted

A new leash on life: Injured Whitehorse pup settles into new home

‘I think now he’s less of a perfect dog but he’s more himself’

Yukon well represented in Olympic ski relays

‘It’s always rewarding when you’re racing for a team’

Yukon government launches new website and logo

Opposition slams $500K project cost as a waste

Former Whitehorse gas station employee sues over alleged sexual harassment, assault

Susan Lynn Keleher alleges there was a ‘campaign’ of sexual harassment and assault against her

Tagish dog rescue owner says she’s euthanized 10 dogs

Shelley Cuthbert said she put down 10 dogs after surrendering them to the animal health unit Feb. 15

No Resource Gateway construction work this season, YG says

‘We’re not as advanced as we would have liked to have been but we still are advancing’

Former Whitehorse RCMP officer gets conditional discharge for sexual assault

Judge Richard Scheider sided with the defence’s argument that conditional discharge was appropriate

Tagish dog rescue owner asks court to change dog surrender order

Shelley Cuthbert is asking for changes to an order requiring her to surrender 10 dogs per month

Dangerous offender hearing underway for former Yukon man who sexually abused 13 girls

The man pleaded guilty to sexually abusing 13 girls over seven years in the Yukon, B.C. and Ontario

Team Yukon has strong showing at Whistler Super Youth and Timber Tour

‘Anwyn absolutely destroyed the competition’

Yukon skier turns in personal best at Junior World Championships

‘It was another great international racing experience’

Most Canadians believe journalism plays critical role in democracy: poll

Survey suggests 94 per cent of Canadians feel journalism plays ‘important’ part

Yukon child care deal to fund grandparents, courses for caregivers

‘How this is completely going to look, we’re still working on’

Most Read