Peel decision a hollow win for the Yukon government

Well, it looks like the crystal ball at the Yukon News could use a spit shine. We’ve previously predicted in these pages that the Yukon government would keep on losing in its long-running court battle.

Well, it looks like the crystal ball at the Yukon News could use a spit shine. We’ve previously predicted in these pages that the Yukon government would keep on losing in its long-running court battle with First Nations over the fate of the Peel watershed. Instead, the Court of Appeal offered a decision on Wednesday that is probably the best that the government could have hoped for, and should be considered a qualified victory of sorts.

That hasn’t stopped many people, including both of Yukon’s opposition parties, from concluding that the Yukon government lost the case. It didn’t exactly inspire confidence to see NDP Leader Liz Hanson share a post by her party that says “We’re brimming with hope: the Yukon Court of Appeal just rejected the Yukon Party government’s appeal in the Peel watershed case,” right underneath a screen grab that shows the decision’s conclusion that the appeal would, in fact, be “allowed in part.”

Why the confusion? Well, to nobody’s surprise, the appeals judges found the Yukon government behaved badly during its dealings with First Nations during planning talks, concluding that “Yukon undermined reconciliation by failing to honour the letter and spirit of its treaty obligations.” And the appeals judges agreed with an earlier Supreme Court decision that quashed the plan rammed through by the Yukon government, which nearly inverted the planning commission’s recommendations by opening most of the watershed up for development.

Upon hearing this much, it seems some didn’t bother reading any further in the judgment, and ended up missing the real take-away.

The appeals judges ended up rejecting a key contention made by Thomas Berger, the famed aboriginal lawyer who represented the plaintiffs – namely, that the Yukon government should not get a chance at a do-over by going back a few steps in the process and presenting the type of plan it wants to affected First Nations. Berger warned that allowing this would amount to rewarding the government for its dirty deeds.

Supreme Court Judge Ron Veale agreed with this conclusion. But the appeals judges thought differently, saying that allowing a re-do at an earlier stage “would not permit Yukon ‘to benefit from its flawed process’; it would allow the process to unfold as it was meant to.”

The Yukon won’t be allowed to simply submit its own plan for the watershed at an earlier stage, the judges say. Instead, it must go through another round of consultations with First Nations and the planning commission, providing the sort of details it was supposed to have provided in the first place and giving First Nations and the planning commission a chance to respond. But it looks like the government could jump through these hoops and still lawfully push through a plan that would leave much of the watershed open to development, as Berger now warns.

In fact, this is an outcome that the Yukon government has always asked for, barring a fantasy ruling that upheld the government’s dumb-as-nails behaviour up until this point.

Lest there be any remaining confusion, the Yukon government has issued a statement that says it’s pleased with the outcome. The plaintiffs, meanwhile, are considering taking the case to the Supreme Court of Canada. These would be strange responses if the Yukon government had, in fact, lost.

Yet none of this should suggest that the government will actually see its dreams realized of iron ore trucks rumbling along newly-graded roads through what was once near-pristine wilderness in the Peel. Even if the government is able to put in place the plan it wants, and setting aside the questionable economics of building a mine in such a far-flung spot, First Nations opposition to mining projects remains a kiss of death for proponents. And if the Yukon Party has accomplished anything with the great mess it has created in the name of developing the Peel, it has been to galvanize opposition to development in the watershed. The Peel debacle will stand as an enduring example of the Yukon Party’s utter inability to play well with others.

Our territorial leaders had many chances, during seven long years of planning talks, to make an upfront, reasoned pitch that the benefits of new mines in the region would outweigh any loss of natural splendour. Instead they took a route that was cowardly, contemptuous of the public and fundamentally dishonest.

Remember, this is a gang that tried to suppress government information that buttressed calls for conservation in the region, and steadfastly refused to give any sense of how much development it wanted for the region up until the planning commission had wrapped up – and, conveniently enough, until after a territorial election. This is a gang that always insisted it would respect Yukon’s treaties with First Nations, particularly at the moment when it was undermining these agreements. This is a gang that made pie-in-the-sky promises that they could deliver a plan that would please all involved, rather than engaging in an adult discussion about necessarily painful trade-offs.

Now our leaders hope to somehow patch things up and come to terms with the chiefs they’ve been feuding with all this time. Good luck with that. So far our premier hasn’t even been willing to admit any culpability for the mess he played a large part in creating. To make headway, that would be a good place to start.

Correction: An earlier version of this editorial misidentified the Supreme Court judge who ruled on the Peel case. We’re sorry for the mix-up.

Get local stories you won't find anywhere else right to your inbox.
Sign up here

Just Posted

Two people walk up the stairs past an advance polling sign at the Canda Games Centre on April 4. (Haley Ritchie/Yukon News)
April 12 is polling day: Here’s how to vote

If in doubt, electionsyukon.ca has an address-to-riding tool

Yukon Party leader Currie Dixon addressing media at a press conference on April 8. The territorial election is on April 12. (Haley Ritchie/Yukon News)
Getting to know Currie Dixon and the Yukon Party platform

A closer look at the party leader and promises on the campaign trail

Yukon NDP leader Kate White, surrounded by socially distanced candidates, announces her platform in Whitehorse on March 29. (Haley Ritchie/Yukon News)
Getting to know Kate White and the Yukon NDP Platform

A detailed look at the NDP platform and Kate White’s leadership campaign this election

Crystal Schick/Yukon News
Sandy Silver announces the territorial election in Whitehorse. Silver is seeking a second term as premier and third term as Klondike MLA. (Crystal Schick/Yukon News)
Getting to know Sandy Silver and the Yukon Liberal platform

Yukon Liberal Leader Sandy Silver is vying for a second term as… Continue reading

Whitehorse City Hall (Joel Krahn/Yukon News file)
This week at city hall

A look at issues discussed by Whitehorse city council at its April 6 meeting.

Point-in-Time homeless count planned this month

Volunteers will count those in shelters, short-term housing and without shelter in a 24-hour period.

The Yukon’s new ATIPP Act came into effect on April 1. Yukoners can submit ATIPP requests online or at the Legislative Assembly building. (Gabrielle Plonka/Yukon News file)
New ATIPP Act in effect as of April 1

The changes promise increased government transparency

A new conservancy in northern B.C. is adjacent to Mount Edziza Provincial Park. (Courtesy BC Parks)
Ice Mountain Lands near Telegraph Creek, B.C., granted conservancy protection

The conservancy is the first step in a multi-year Tahltan Stewardship Initiative

Yukon RCMP reported a child pornography-related arrest on April 1. (Phil McLachlan/Black Press file)
Whitehorse man arrested on child pornography charges

The 43-year-old was charged with possession of child pornography and making child pornography

Team Yukon athletes wave flags at the 2012 Arctic Winter Games opening ceremony in Whitehorse. The postponed 2022 event in Wood Buffalo, Alta., has been rescheduled for Jan. 29 to Feb. 4, 2023. (Justin Kennedy/Yukon News file)
New dates set for Arctic Winter Games

Wood Buffalo, Alta. will host event Jan. 29 to Feb. 4, 2023

Victoria Gold Corp. has contributed $1 million to the First Nation of Na-cho Nyak Dun after six months of production at the Eagle Gold Mine. (Submitted/Victoria Gold Corp.)
Victoria Gold contributes $1 million to First Nation of Na-cho Nyak Dun

Victoria Gold signed a Comprehensive Cooperation and Benefits Agreement in 2011

Chief Medical Officer of Health Dr. Brendan Hanley speaks to media in Whitehorse on October 30, 2020. Hanley is now encouraging Yukon to continue following health regulations, noting it could still be some time before changes to restrictions are made. (Crystal Schick/Yukon News file)
No active COVID cases in Yukon

Hanley highlights concerns over variants, encourages vaccinations

Most Read