odd choices

We all have choices to make. In the strange case of Kari Knopp, it's troubling how many have been wrong. Until a couple of weeks ago, Knopp was living on the chilly streets of Whitehorse with three dogs.

We all have choices to make. In the strange case of Kari Knopp, it’s troubling how many have been wrong.

Until a couple of weeks ago, Knopp was living on the chilly streets of Whitehorse with three dogs. Now, thanks to compassionate citizens, she’s dogless and homeless.

Throughout the summer, many people phoned bylaw and the media expressing concern about the well-being of Knopp’s healthy-looking pets. Not about Knopp, mind you, just her dogs, which were frequently tied to posts around town while Knopp visited various businesses and restaurants.

Filled with compassion, for the dogs, which many assumed lacked food and shelter, these big-hearted folks demanded action.

After several months, bylaw checked out yet another complaint about the dogs, which were tied in Shipyards Park.

Knopp was nowhere in sight.

Though he knew the owner, her dogs and about their homelessness, bylaw manager Dave Pruden chose, finally, to deem the animals at large and impounded them.

This is an interesting decision, and warrants consideration by all dog owners.

According to city law, dogs can’t be tied up and left. So people who, while walking their pets, tie them up outside while visiting a friend or shopping might emerge to find them impounded simply because some compassionate individual has made an assumption and complained.

An inconvenience for most pet owners. A much more significant action to take against Knopp.

In this case, the homeless woman lost the companions that, undoubtedly, she depended on to keep warm and to ward off any predators she might encounter during the long night.

Remember, for a second, that Knopp’s dogs were healthy.

Despite this, Pruden chose to get a court order guaranteeing the 21-year-old woman couldn’t spring her animals from the pound without promising to provide food, water and shelter for her pets.

After months of complaints, he didn’t want to be fielding more calls about the animals the next day, he said.

However, he felt compassion for Knopp and was bothered by her homelessness. In that, he was unusual.

Few of the people calling about the dogs were, he said. Most were indifferent to the woman’s plight.

She has a choice. The dogs don’t, seems to be the refrain.

But what, precisely, were people protecting Knopp’s dogs from?

And why do people feel compelled to protect dogs and not a young woman? That, again, seems an odd choice.

Society itself has a hard time grappling with such cases. Dogs are chattel and easily impounded. People less so, even when their decision-making abilities are suspect.

For whatever reason, Knopp has also made a poor choice – placing herself at risk on the cold, wet streets of Whitehorse. Why?

Without talking to her, it’s hard to know.

However, many who have spoken to Knopp have their suspicions, even if they are reluctant to voice them publicly – another choice.

And society itself has made a choice, for the liberty of the individual.

It is up to you to seek help for an illness, even if you are unaware it afflicts you. Others may see it plain as day, but if you don’t, or can’t, society has decided it’s not its business.

As long as you don’t pose an immediate threat to yourself, or others, you can refuse help from the police. From ambulance attendants. From doctors. From nurses. You can check yourself out of the hospital … it’s your choice.

No professional will intervene.

A young woman, alone on the streets of Whitehorse, is not at risk. At least, not enough for officials to act on her behalf.

Scared about making mistakes, they will not do anything for these people.

Neither will fellow citizens.

Unless, of course, the homeless person has dogs.

Then the choice is clear.

The dogs must have food and shelter.

And the young woman?

We’re content to leave her out in the cold.

Just Posted

Yukon government releases Whitehorse Correctional Centre inspection report

The report contains 40 recommendations on how facilities and services at the WCC should be improved

Many Rivers staff vote to strike

18 counsellors and support staff have been without a contract for over a year

Crown, defence ask for 10 years’ parole ineligibility for Watson Lake murderer

Travis Dennis pleaded guilty to second-degree murder in May for killing Andy Giraudel in 2016

18 bears killed in the Yukon between April and July this year

Environment Yukon has not been providing updates on bear deaths this year due to workload involved

Gymkhana tests Yukon horses and riders

‘I don’t ever want somebody to leave feeling like they didn’t accomplish some kind of goal’

Cozens, Team Canada off to strong start at Hlinka Gretzky Cup

Canada rolls through Switzerland and Slovakia to set up showdown with Sweden

Selkirk First Nation says chinook salmon numbers similar to last year’s

Sonar on the Pelly River had counted just more than 7,900 chinook as of Aug. 5

Whitehorse council talks hotel height increase

Proposal to build a taller hotel passes first reading

Whitehorse: The Surveillance City

Good news! The totalitarian hellworld is coming to the Yukon!

Yukoners fought at the battle of Amiens

In which getting shot in the leg with a machine gun is described as a ‘blighty’

Special Olympics Canada 2018 Summer Games underway in Nova Scotia

Team Yukon has eight top-10 finishes in the first two days of competition

Feds award $80M Faro construction manager contract

‘Finally, we are coming to a place where we can put the shovel in the ground’

Most Read