In defence of first past the post

Given the amount of recent letters devoted to promoting alternate voting regimes in the Yukon, I thought it was time for someone to weigh in in support of our current first-past-the-post electoral system.

Given the amount of recent letters devoted to promoting alternate voting regimes in the Yukon, I thought it was time for someone to weigh in in support of our current first-past-the-post electoral system.

As it stands, the party with the most votes wins the riding, even if the amount of votes received is less than 50 per cent. The common complaint about first-past-the-post is that an individual can win a riding, or a party can win an election, with only 35 per cent of the popular vote, as all that matters is getting more than the second place person.

This can, and usually does, result in a legislature that is not necessarily reflective of the popular vote received by the three major parties.

Rather than see this result as a weakness, I see it as a strength, in that less than 50 per cent of the votes can still result in the election of a strong, unified management team. While a majority does vest a considerable amount of power in the winning party, it also ensures a stable political environment with a management team empowered to make decisions without having to constantly negotiate its positions.

Conversely, alternate voting systems, such as proportional representation and single transferable vote have a tendency to result in minority governments and a fracturing of the legislature. What we make up for in a representative legislature we lose in cohesive and lasting management.

Under proportional representation, or PR, the last election would have seen parties receive a number of seats in proportion to the percentage of votes received. The result would have been a minority Yukon Party government, with the Yukon Party receiving eight seats, the NDP six and the Liberals five.

Similarly, a single transferable vote, or STV, in which a voter marks a ballot for first, second and third choice with the third place party’s votes divvied between the two remaining parties, would most likely have resulted in a similar Yukon Party minority government. Without going in-depth into the math, if we assume that all last place NDP and Yukon Party votes went to the Liberals and that all last place Liberal votes broke 60/40 in favour of the NDP, we get a legislature that looks a lot like the PR system above, with a couple real squeakers for the Yukon Party.

In either case the result is a minority government, which means that parties must work together in order to pass legislation and generally govern. While on the surface this would seem to be a liveable result, the practical reality is an electoral system fraught with horse-trading between parties and early elections.

The second and third party need only wait for a wedge issue to arise and, if the prevailing wind is in their favour, decry the current government and force an election. In a system with three major parties a PR or STV system is a recipe for fragile coalitions and games of brinkmanship (i.e. the current political situation plaguing Ontario’s minority Liberal government).

The strength of the first-past-the-post system is that it lends itself to “big tent” politics in that different segments of society are forced together to determine cohesive platforms in order to obtain the threshold of votes required to win an election. The very survival of parties requires that unrepresented portions of society be approached by the major parties in an attempt to form a big enough coalition of voters to elect a government. These compromises of factions within a party are given pay through a party’s platform, and then presented to an electorate during the election. Upon election the majority government is guided by the platform, meaning, in short, that the electorate know what they are getting.

With a minority government there is no one guiding document, as any coalition parties must horse-trade after the election to determine what priorities move forward. The way forward is less clear, as the horse-trading happens after the election, rather than solely within policy conventions before the election. The result is a more bland electoral style, with legislatures less likely to implement progressive or experimental legislation.

Further, it is important to note that there is no barrier to any party gaining ascendancy in the Yukon. In the past 20 years each of the three major parties have formed majority governments. The first-past-the-post system offers no systemic advantage to one party over another (though the Yukon Party has been on a winning streak of late). Upon defeat the second or third party’s ideas do not somehow disappear, they can be repackaged in the next election and, as the wheel eventually turns, those lasting ideas will eventually have their time in the sun.

At the end of the day it is really a choice between strong centralized management or a more diverse, but perhaps less stable, government. There is no right or wrong answer to the question, nor is one option more fair than the other, it is really just an issue of picking a management result that works best for the Yukon.

It is my opinion that our current first-past-the-post system does the job, in that it produces a strong central management team (regardless of which party wins) and keeps us away from the polls until terms expire, meaning Yukon isn’t in a constant state of election. In short, the current system isn’t broken, so no need to fix it.

Graham Lang is a Whitehorse lawyer and long-time Yukoner.

Get local stories you won't find anywhere else right to your inbox.
Sign up here

Just Posted

The Many Rivers Counselling and Support Services building in Whitehorse on March 28, 2019. Three people who sat on Many Rivers’ board immediately before it closed for good say they were relieved to hear that the Yukon RCMP has undertaken a forensic audit into the now-defunct NGO’s financial affairs. (Crystal Schick/Yukon News file)
Former Many Rivers board members relieved to hear about forensic audit, wonder what took so long

Three people who sat on Many Rivers’ board immediately before it closed… Continue reading

Whitehorse General Hospital in Whitehorse on Feb. 14, 2019. The Yukon Employees’ Union and Yukon Hospital Corporation are at odds over whether there’s a critical staffing shortage at the territory’s hospitals. (Crystal Schick/Yukon News file)
YEU, Yukon Hospital Corp. at odds over whether hospitals are understaffed

YEU says four nurses quit within 12 hours last week, a claim the YHC says is “inaccurate”

Two former Whitehorse Correctional Centre inmates, Ray Hartling and Mark Lange, have filed a class action against the jail, corrections officials and Yukon government on behalf of everyone who’s been placed in two restrictive units over the past six years. (Joel Krahn/Yukon News file)
Class action filed against Whitehorse Correctional Centre over use of segregation

Two former Whitehorse Correctional Centre inmates have filed a class action against… Continue reading


Wyatt’s World for Oct. 21, 2020

Movie poster for <em>Ìfé,</em> a movie being shown during OUT North Film Festival, which includes approximately 20 different films accessible online this year. (Submitted)
OUT North Film Festival moves to virtual format

In its ninth year, the artistic director said this year has a more diverse set of short and feature films

Triple J’s Canna Space in Whitehorse on April 17, 2019, opens their first container of product. Two years after Canada legalized the sale of cannabis, Yukon leads the country in per capita legal sales. (Crystal Schick/Yukon News file)
Yukon leads Canadian cannabis sales two years after legalization

Private retailers still asking for changes that would allow online sales

A sign greets guests near the entrance of the Canada Games Centre in Whitehorse on June 11. The city announced Oct. 16 it was moving into the next part of its phased reopening plan with spectator seating areas open at a reduced capacity to allow for physical distancing. (Crystal Schick/Yukon News file)
CGC reopening continues

Limited spectator seating now available

During Whitehorse city council’s Oct. 19 meeting, planning manager Mélodie Simard brought forward a recommendation that a proposed Official Community Plan amendment move forward that would designate a 56.3 hectare piece of land in Whistle Bend, currently designated as green space, as urban residential use. (Courtesy City of Whitehorse)
More development in Whistle Bend contemplated

OCP change would be the first of several steps to develop future area

EDITORIAL: Don’t let the City of Whitehorse distract you

A little over two weeks after Whitehorse city council voted to give… Continue reading

Whitehorse City Hall. (Joel Krahn/Yukon News file)
City hall, briefly

A look at decisions made by Whitehorse city council this week

Northwestel has released the proposed prices for its unlimited plans. Unlimited internet in Whitehorse and Carcross could cost users between $160.95 and $249.95 per month depending on their choice of package. (Yukon News file)
Unlimited internet options outlined

Will require CRTC approval before Northwestel makes them available

Legislative assembly on the last day of the fall sitting in Whitehorse. Yukon’s territorial government will sit for 45 days this sitting instead of 30 days to make up for lost time caused by COVID-19 in the spring. (Crystal Schick/Yukon News file)
Legislative assembly sitting extended

Yukon’s territorial government will sit for 45 days this sitting. The extension… Continue reading

Today’s mailbox: Mad about MAD

Letters to the editor published Oct. 16, 2020

Most Read